Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

PALESTINE-ISRAEL: Between The Lines, Inside The Walled City

Deborah Horan

JERUSALEM, Apr 17 1997 (IPS) - At noon on Fridays, as the holy men sing out verses from the Koran over loudspeakers, thousands of Muslims pour through the gates of Jerusalem’s walled Old City and move in waves toward the golden Dome of the Rock and al-Aqsa mosques.

Below the compound, thousands of Jews gather at the Western Wall, the only remnant of the Second Temple destroyed by the Romans in 70 AD, to prepare for Sabbath prayers, which begin at sundown.

The Old City, with its ancient cobble stone streets, minarets and religious sanctuaries, goes to the heart of the Middle East conflict. Jews and Muslims worldwide revere its holy shrines. Israelis and Palestinians regard it as a symbol of their nationalism.

The walled city also marks the demographic divide between two distinct groups who have shared its narrow streets since Israel captured the eastern half of Jerusalem from Jordan in 1967. Since then, those demographic lines have been slowly blurred in a way that makes any political solution involving a redivision of the city difficult.

To the west of the Old City, the streets are filled with ultra- Orthodox men in black hats and coats and women with their hair covered with long netting or colorful scarves. Soldiers, machine guns draped over their shoulders, young people and tourists rest in outdoor cafes that line Ben Yehuda street.

To the east of the old Crusader walls, the picture looks more like Cairo. Old men with stubble beards push green carts down crowded Sultan Suleiman street, past peasant women who sit on the sidewalk selling vegetables and spices. Most women wear traditional Islamic long coats and veils.

The dividing line is a four-lane highway running north to south that follows the old ‘green line’ boundary that once separated Israel from Jordan. Step across that invisible line and the language changes abruptly from Hebrew to Arabic. Even the time zone can change: Israel moves to daylight saving time two weeks earlier than the Palestinians.

Israeli opinion polls consistently find more than 80 percent opposed to redividing Jerusalem as part of any peace deal with the Palestinians. In line with public opinion, successive Israeli governments have insisted the disputed city will remain Israel’s “eternal, undivided capital”.

Still, today few Israelis venture into the Arab areas. “The city is already divided,” said Hagit Yaari, spokeswoman for IrShalem, a left-wing Israeli organisation opposed to Israeli sovereignty in east Jerusalem. “There’s a definite psychological barrier.”

That barrier is intensified because of a slower pace of development over the years in Palestinian areas of the city. While the west is filled with four-lane highways, five-star hotels, public parks and high-rise apartments, the east is a collection of tiny villages built into the surrounding hills.

Sometimes, the lack of development has led to some grim statistics, say human rights workers. For instance, one-third of all Palestinians in Jerusalem live three or more to a room, according to a 1995 report called “A Policy of Discrimination” issued by the Israeli human rights group, B’Tselem. Palestinians say they need permits to build at least 15,000 apartments immediately to ease the severe housing shortage.

And while Palestinians pay from 20 to 30 percent of the municipal taxes, they receive between six and eight percent of the services, according to Anat Hoffman, a city councilwoman from the left-wing Meretz party. “We give them the minimum that we can get away with,” Hoffman charged. “We give them enough services to keep them quiet.”

That does not mean all Palestinians are poor. Those who own factories in the West Bank or chic clothing boutiques in the city can be quite well off. The difference is that their white stone mansions with red tiled roofs dot hilltops along narrow, often pot- holed streets.

Part of the problem stems from the fact that the 160,000 Arab residents in the city have consistently refused to participate in municipal elections. When it came to allocating limited tax revenues, they had no one at City Hall to represent them.

“Voting in Israeli municipal elections would mean that we recognise Israeli sovereignty in the eastern half of the city,” said Ghassan Khatib, director of the Jerusalem Media and Communications Center, a Palestinian research institute. “We do not accept this. East Jerusalem is simply part of the territory Israel occupied in 1967.”

Since his election in 1994, Jerusalem Mayor Ehud Olmert of the right-wing Likud party has pledged to erase these barriers by bringing spending in Palestinian areas of the city on par with Jewish areas. At the beginning of the year, he proposed a 40 million dollar plan to develop infrastructure in Arab sectors of Jerusalem.

“All these sums of money are not just a facade, not just a hypothetical,” Olmert said at a recent press conference announcing the government’s intentions. “It’s a working plan and the programs are being carried out.”

While Palestinian leaders in the city said they would like to see their tax money spent in their neighbourhoods, Palestinian negotiators accused Olmert of allocating the funds as a show of Israeli sovereignty over east Jerusalem. Even if an infusion of money into the Arab sector compensates for past inequalities, they say, it is not a substitute for solving the larger political dispute over the city.

Palestinians want to see the Arab sectors of Jerusalem under their sovereignty by the end of the negotiations with Israel, which are supposed to conclude by May 1999, according to a timetable set out in interim peace deals.

But the demographic dividing line so clearly cut near the Old City, has been blurred in most other areas of the city. Many of the village-like Palestinian areas are surrounded by high-rise Jewish neighbourhoods, which Palestinians call settlements.

The patchwork demographics, along with gerrymandered municipal boundaries that bisect Arab areas, counting some streets as within Jerusalem while adjacent ones are considered to be in the West Bank, makes a neat redivision of the city, impossible.

Instead, some Israeli and Palestinian researchers looking for an acceptable solution have drawn up complicated scenarios involving Israel agreeing to cede some Arab areas to Palestinian control, which the present Israeli government has vowed never to do.

Others have suggested Palestinians take control of the West Bank halves of bisected neighbourhoods — in other words, those Arab areas considered to be part of Jerusalem by Palestinians, but which fall outside Israel’s defined boundaries of the city — a solution unacceptable to the Palestinians.

“The problem is when it comes to Jerusalem, we are not talking about sharing neighbourhoods,” said Moshe Maoz, an Israeli analyst at Jerusalem’s Hebrew University. “When we talk about Jerusalem, we mean the Old City — the Western Wall and the Dome of the Rock. That is what makes the solution so difficult.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags