Friday, November 20, 2026
Thalif Deen
- The United States has begun to market its package of U.N. reforms, but the United Nations appears to be unwilling to buy.
As part of a hard sell, a team of officials, including a U.S. Senator and a U.S. ambassador, paced the corridors of the United Nations Friday, trying to convince European and Third World envoys of the efficacy of the proposed package.
“They were more like snake oil salesmen than spin doctors,” said one ambassador speaking on condition of anonymity.
Republican Senator Rod Grams, chairman of the International Operations Sub-committee of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, said details of the proposed reforms will have to be worked out with other member states.
“We are not planning to micro-manage the United Nations,” he told reporters. “And this is not a take-it-or-leave-it offer.”
The package, approved by both Republicans and Democrats in the U.S. Senate, would impose rigid conditions in return for the payment of longstanding U.S. arrears to the United Nations.
The United Nations says that Washington owes about 1.3 billion dollars in dues, while Washington insists the arrears amount only to about 819 million dollars.
Grams said the bipartisan agreement was a “major step forward.” He added: “We feel this is a good start.”
Senator Jesse Helms, chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, said Thursday the conditions would be “Congressionally designated benchmarks…No reforms, no American taxpayers’ money.”
But U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations Bill Richardson sang a different tune, pointing out that the proposals were meant to be “broad-based suggestions.”
“I will be consulting with the rest of the member states and will also visit capitals,” he said.
Grams was also more conciliatory than his counterpart in the Senate. Describing the package as a “fair”, bipartisan agreement to resolve the United Nations’ ongoing cash crisis, he said, “We have to work out the exact details as we begin negotiating with other member states.”
Asked if Washington would pay its dues if the United Nations did not conform to Congress’ benchmarks, Grams sidestepped the question: “We will follow the law as it is. This is the start of the process. We have three months of negotiations before us.”
But the initial reaction both from the 15 members of the European Union (EU) and the 132 members of the ‘Group of 77’ developing countries has been negative.
“We don’t want to be forced into making any public comments just now,” one Third World envoy said on condition of anonymity. “Let the U.S. formally introduce the package before one of the committees here, and then we will react.”
According to the U.S. proposal, Congress will decide to reduce U.S. dues, from the current 25 percent of the U.N. budget to 20 percent. Congress has already unilaterally reduced its contribution to the peacekeeping budget: from 31 percent to 25 percent. The dues and other assessments are usually decided by the U.N. General Assembly.
The Europeans have said that it would set a bad precedent if such decisions were taken by the legislature of a member-state.
“Traditionally, it is the U.N. that makes the decisions, and our national legislatures follow suit,” according to one European diplomat. “But the U.S. proposal reverses the whole process.”
“We will have a major political problems in our hands, if each of the 15 European parliaments begin dictating terms to the United Nations,” he said. “It would be pure political chaos.”
Yet another diplomat said that the unilateral decisions being made by Washington would violate the U.N. charter. “It’s a disease that could spread to other member states,” this envoy said.
Among other things, the U.S. package calls for the United Nations to give the Washington-based Congressional watchdog, the General Accounting Office (GAO), authority to audit U.N. programmes, and it requires a reduction in the overall budgets of all specialised agencies.
It also calls for the United Nations to obtain full notification and consultation with Congress on peacekeeping operations, and it seeks to cut the foreign aid of nations whose U.N. diplomats owe parking fines.
In Washington, State Department spokesman Nichola Burns told reporters Friday that the United States was not being “onerous or impossible” in its demands. “The fact is that we are the largest donor. And the American taxpayers have a right, as well as, certainly, the members of the (U.S.) Senate and House, to expect that the administration will be vigorous in supporting the concept of (U.N.) reform,” he added.
As Secretary-General Kofi Annan sees it, it’s one thing to discuss things in the U.S. Congress, “but that does not mean that it is going to become law in the United Nations. It does not necessarily mean that the member states are going to accept it.”
Annan told reporters here Thursday that on a number issues, the United States will have to come and negotiate with the other member states. “It is going to be a real challenge for U.S. diplomacy, and I think the (Bill Clinton) Administration realises it,” he said. “I do not think anyone expects that Congress can take decisions and impose them unilaterally on the other 184 member states.”
Annan has also been a strong critic of benchmarks and conditions. “We would have been happier if the totality of what we believe is owed were paid, and if the deck had been cleared, and we did not have to deal with benchmarks,” he said.