Thursday, November 19, 2026
Andrei Ivanov and Judith Perera
- In the early hours of Dec. 1, an explosion smashed through the shafts and galleries of the Zyryanovskaya mine in Novokuznetsk in the heart of central Russia’s Kuzbass coal basin.
A government commision of inquiry later found that a single canister of oxygen, part of some emergency apparatus, somehow fell into some machinery. It split and the oxygen rush fanned sparks into a blaze, igniting coal dust and methane gas.
Of the 130 miners working on that night’s shift, 67 died.
The cash flow crisis, strikes and allegations of corruption and embezzlement by industry managers that has crippled so much of Russian heavy industry has hit safety procedures hard in the country’s mines. But Zyryanovskaya, though opened in 1946, is among the most modern and profitable in the Kuzbass region.
Deputy prime minister Oleg Sysuev, who led the inquiry, says Zyryanovskaya must be reopened and “must regain its previous profitability”. But his tribunal is also expected, with prosecutors from the local procurator’s office to name the guilty men.
Ivan Mokhnachuk, deputy chairman of the Independent Trade Union of Miners warns that it would be a mistake to draw hasty conclusions. “The easiest way is to accuse the chief engineer or the mine supervisor, but this will not solve the problem of poor safety at Russia’s coal mines. This, in turn is due to underfunding,” he says.
The Russian Federation’s coal industry required at least 10,000 billion (1.7 billion dollars) roubles this year, but only 6,500 billion roubles were allocated from the state budget, and of that only 5,700 billion actually reached the mines.
As a result mines have had to lay off workers such as auxiliary personnel and engineers. Safety standards are also affected by wage delays, for example at Zyryanovskaya workers had not been paid for two months, but miners at other pits have had no money for half a year. “Obviously, low morale and insecurity will undermine safety,” Mokhnachuk says.
It was the second major accident at a Russian mine this year. In September, an explosion at the Arktikugol state coal mining trust, operating on the Norwegian island of Spitsbergen, killed 23 miners from Russia and Ukraine. And in August, five miners died in a methane explosion at a mine in Kemerovo Region in southern Siberia.
Vladimir Rossikhin, the main labour-safety inspector of the miners’ union, the Zyryanovskaya disaster, brought the death toll in Russian mines in 1997 to 258. This compares with 121 in 1996, and until this year the death rate had been falling — down from 227 in 1995 and 309 in 1991. The decrease was due mainly to the closure of old inefficient and dangerous pits, with 50 shut over the past three years, rather than to any real improvements in safety.
So far, restructuring of the coal industry has largely taken the form of withdrawal of state funding, with the predictable result that debts are mounting all round and strikes are a regular occurrence. The aim is to close 140 out of Russia’s total 240 mines by 2000 with employment cut from 750,000 to 500,000.
Over the past two years government grants to the industry have been reduced to an eighth of what they were. However, structural changes in the industry have failed to improve conditions for the miners, and for some conditions had deteriorated. Miners’ wages (when they are paid) have dropped from third position on the national state pay scale to seventh, while arrears continued to mount. At teh same time the amount of unpaid bills from the mines’ main customers, the power generators continues to rise,
Consumer debts for coal supplied have surged since the start of the year from 4,500 billion roubles to 6,900 billion (1.18 billion dollars). The largest debtor is the state-controlled national grid whose debts have increased 75.9 percent since the start of the year to reach 3,3600 billion roubles.
Only 18.8 percent of coal supplied is paid for with money, and 70 percent through barters and mutual settlements. Pit closures and the transfer of social responsibilities for the redundant miners to the local authorities are taking place without proper financing.
As the situation has deteriorated, the state coal concern Rosugol, which owns over 90 percent of Russia’s mines, had been criticised for mismanagement and corruption.
Last year it was accused of mishandling a World Bank coal loan of 500 million dollars intended to aid restructuring. This has delayed a further loan intended for 1997. To calm the mounting protests earlier this year president Boris Yeltsin assigned deputy premier Anatoly Chubais to sort out the mess as head of a special trouble-shooting government commission. So far, however, he has had little effect.
Now Yeltsin plans to abolish Rosugol in a bid to tighten government control over the coal industry.
Under the new structure, coal-industry policy will be set by a special interagency commission, and a unit within the Fuel and Energy Ministry will be created to handle the closure of unprofitable mines. Another will deal with the social problems in coal-mining regions. The aim is to end the conflict of interests with Rosugol in charge of both distributing state subsidies and overseeing restructuring. Government officials have accused Rosugol of blocking reforms.
The creation of a single headquarters for the coal industry at the ministry is expected to make it easier for Russia to secure a 750 million dollar second credit from the World Bank. Without this credit, the coal industry faces huge problems in 1998 as the draft budget allocates only 5,800 billion roubles to the sector – less than half this year’s amount once inflation is taken into account.
It is hoped that these changes will be enough to defuse the growing tension in Russia’s mines as winter approaches. For the mines in the northern territories especially, another winter with no pay in freezing and near starvation conditions is likely to spark protests of unprecedented proportions.
Aware of this, and how the latest accident could exacerbate the situation, prime minister Victor Chernomyrdin is eager to reassure miners in the Kuzbass. “The Kuzbass has been and will remain the country’s main coal- mining region. Nobody will deny this and nobody intends to belittle the significance of the Kuzbass coal region.”
He has promised that resources for restoration of the Zyryanovskaya mine will be allocated in full from the state budget. Meanwhile, the mine’s charity account has already received 12 million roubles from the Kuzbass rural Novokuznetsk district authorities.
Food has also been delivered for the families of the dead miners. and the neighbouring Tomsk regional emergencies commission is to set aside 100 million (about 17,000 dollars) to help the miners’ families.
The federal budget has so far issued five billion roubles for preliminary clean-up operations, but the total cost is expected to be come to approximately 20 billion roubles.
But with Rosugol gone, the Russian government will have to take the brunt of the criticism as the coal industry restructures. Its first test is likely to be how it handles any further World Bank loans. Russia’s miners will be watching very closely to see where the money goes in 1998.