Africa, Headlines, North America

RIGHTS: US Group Cites Rise of Xenophobia in RSA

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Mar 27 1998 (IPS) - The South African government – despite its progress in black-white reconciliation – is tolerating an alarming rise in xenophobia as shown by mounting attacks against immigrants and asylum-seekers, according to a U.S. human rights group.

A report by the New York-based Human Rights Watch (HRW), has detailed a range of abuses suffered by immigrants from neighbouring countries and takes the ruling African National Congress (ANC) government to task for failing to address the situation.

Abuses include arbitrary arrest, prolonged detention, extortion, robbery and beatings, according to the report. At least one refugee, Jean-Pierre Kanyangwa of Burundi, died after being beaten in police custody, according to the 236-page report.

“During the apartheid era, many African countries opened their doors to South African migrants, exiles and refugees and paid a heavy economic price for their opposition to apartheid,” said Peter Takirambudde, who heads HRW’s Africa division. “Now that the tables are turned, it is shameful to see how hostile South Africans have become today to migrants and refugess who are in need.”

The report immediately was denounced in South Africa by Home Affairs Minister Mangosuthu Buthelezi who accused HRW of calling for “five-star treatment of illegal aliens while more than 50 percent of South Africans live below the poverty line.”

Takirambudde, however, labelled Buthelezi’s comments “ill- informed.”

The report, ‘Prohibited Persons: Abuse of Undocumented Migrants, Asylum-Seekers and Refugees in South Africa,’ is based on a two-year investigation which included interviews with foreign farm workers, migrants in detention, asylum-seekers, hawkers, repatriated Mozambicans and representatives of non-governmental organisations.

HRW researchers also met with officials from the Department of Home Affairs, the South African police, the Department of Correctional Services, the army, and the Mozambican Labour Ministry.

The South African economy has long relied on the cheap and easily exploitable labour of undocumented laborers, particularly in its farming, mining, security and construction sectors. These workers work for as little as five rands (one US dollar) a day, according to the report which also found that physical abuse of farm labourers, some of whom are cheated out of their wages or deported before receiving their pay, is “common.”

There are no reliable data on the actual number of undocumented migrants and asylum-seekers living in South Africa, although some politicians, police and media, which have helped whip up anti- foreigner sentiment, have put the figure as high as nine million – or almost 25 percent of the country’s total population.

HRW estimates the actual range of foreigners at between 500,000 and 1.5 million, almost all of whom have come from countries which, like Pretoria itself, belong to the Southern African Development Community (SADC).

Deportations have quadrupled since the late 1980s and probably approached 200,000 in 1997, the report said. Whether this increase has resulted from greater immigration or from more crackdowns by security forces remains unclear, according to HRW.

The report estimates that up to 20 percent of those initially arrested on suspicion of being undocumented are actually South African citizens or lawful residents, forced to spend several days in detention until their status is cleared. That is due in part to the use by the authorities of unreliable criteria, such as complexion, accent, or inoculation marks, for identifying suspects.

“We documented cases of persons who claimed they were arrested for being ‘to black,’ having a foreign name, or in one case, walking ‘like a Mozambican,”‘ the report said.

Those who are detained risk abuse literally from the moment of their actual arrest. “Assault and theft during the arrest process seems disturbingly common,” according to the report which adds that, in some urban areas, especially Johannesburg, police often suggested that payment of a “fine” or bribe could lead to release.

After arrest, suspected illegal migrants are brought to detention facilities where they may remain for months in conditions that are international standards. In some cases, they are forced to share cells with criminal suspects who rob them, according to the report.

In the Lindela private facility, operated on behalf of the Home Affairs Department, HRW investigators interviewed detainees, who claimed they had been beaten by security personnel there on several occasions, and obtained medical records which appeared to confirm their injuries. The facility had fewer beds than inmates, according to the reprot.

Actual deportation also presents risks to migrants who, in some areas, are not allowed to take their belongings with them. Several migrants told HRW they had been verbally and physically abused by police guards during the long train ride back to Mozambique. They also testified that guards would permit them to jump from the moving train in exchange for substantial bribes.

Asylum-seekers and refugees also face abuse largely because of the government’s failure to live up to its obligations under international conventions it signed over the last several years.

HRW investigators found evidence of “extensive corruption” in the refugee determination process with officials in the Department of Home Affairs “demanding bribes for the scheduling of interviews and for the granting of permits.” In addition, asylum- seekers from several African countries, including Angola, Mozambique, Tanzania and Malawi, are routinely turned down.

The report also deplores what it calls South Africa’s “increasingly xenophobic public culture” which tolerates “unsubstantiated and inflammatory statements” by politicians that blame migrants for the current crime wave, rising unemployment, or even the spread of diseases.

As a result, “migrants have increasingly become the target of abuse at the hands of South African citizens, as well as members of the police, the army, and the Department of Home Affairs.”

Foreign hawkers, who are often asylum applicants with temporary residence permits, repeatedly suffered as targets of violent protests, beatings, and other forms of intimidation by local competitors and ordinary criminals, according to the report.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags