Europe, Headlines, Human Rights

DISARMAMENT: British ‘Ethical’ Arms Policy Exposed As Hollow

Alex Whiting

LONDON, Jun 24 1998 (IPS) - The British government has granted 2,181 arms export licences to 35 countries with poor human rights records within its first year in power despite professing an ethical foreign policy, according to a new report published Wednesday.

The report by the non-governmental organisation Saferworld, comes just weeks before the British Labour government is due to publish its own report on the arms trade.

The figures contravene the government’s own ‘ethical’ guidelines that say licenses for arms exports will not be granted “if there is a clearly identifiable risk that the proposed export might be used for internal repression.”

The guidelines also caution against selling arms “if there is a clearly identifiable risk that the intended recipient would use the proposed export aggressively against another country, or to assert by force a territorial claim.”

On both counts, Britain, the world’s second largest arms exporter, was seen to have failed the ethical test. Not only that, a leading Member of Parliament accused Britain of fuelling the arms race instead of working to contain it.

Saferworld, an independent research body, based its report on official figures, and says Britain granted: Ten export licences to Algeria for categories that could include military helmets, body armour and armoured off-road vehicles; Sixty four licenses to Indonesia for equipment including small arms, ammunition, bombs, tanks and combat aircraft; Licences to Eritrea, India and Pakistan, all of which could include combat aircraft.

Other agreements included: Thirty-six export licences to China despite a European Union arms embargo, which the government interprets to mean: “large calibre weapons, bombs, torpedoes, rockets and missiles… military aircraft and… armoured fighting vehicles”; and licences for exports of categories that could include small arms and machine guns to Bahrain, Colombia, India, Indonesia, Kenya, Mexico, Morocco, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Sri Lanka, Syria, Turkey, Uganda, Yemen, Zambia and Zimbabwe.

“Between March and May this year 15 arms export licences were granted to Indonesia,” said Menzies Campbell, foreign affairs spokesman for the opposition Liberal Democrats.

“This was a time of political, social and economic turmoil. It is extraordinary that the government did not even put a moratorium on such deliveries during this time.”

Calling for “some real steps towards changing the culture which surrounds the granting of arms export licenses,” Campbell said the present export categories are too broad for effective parliamentary scrutiny.

The MP particularly criticised the fact that Britain continued to sell “sophisticated and deadly” weapons and arms to India and Pakistan — countries which have recently conducted nuclear tests and where, according to Campbell, “the situation is potentially explosive.”

“(British foreign secretary) Robin Cook has rightly stated… that a lowering of tension between these two countries cannot be built on the unstable foundation of an arms race,” he says.

“Yet in the light of the fact that 535 licenses have been grated to India from May 1 to May 10 this year for such items as bombs, missiles, combat aircraft and riot control agents, we are clearly fuelling an arms race ourselves.”

Campbell’s comments echoed the frustration that some British Members of Parliament have voiced over their lack of access to information on British arms sales.

It has also prompted calls for the government to give clear and precise information about exports in its annual report to the British Parliament, the first of which is expected to be published in July.

Arms campaigners said until detailed information is given out as a matter of course, public debate will be based on suspicion and not fact.

Saferworld, for instance, is calling for a committee of MPs in each exporting country to scrutinise licence applications to countries ‘of concern’ in advance, as happens in Sweden.

This, it says, is the most effective way to ensure that concerns for human rights, regional stability and sustainable development are not overridden by short-term commercial gain. In fact, it argues, it is possible to balance the two.

“These new figures are concerning. According to the information given, many arms exports appear to be in contravention of Government guidelines,” said Paul Eavis, Director of Saferworld. “The only way to convince people that this is not the case is to publish more detailed information, starting with the forthcoming annual report.”

He says prior parliamentary scrutiny of weapons sales is vital to ensure that policy is being implemented in practice.

“This is all about the supply of weapons,” adds Martin Honeywell, Associate Director of the NGO International Alert. “The other end is the demand for weapons and we are working with those who are trying to change the situation so that there is no demand for weapons.”

Researcher Owen Greene of Bradford University pointed out that Britain also exports arms to countries where they are diverted to “other sources.” These could include third countries or militant groups. “For example, Singapore sends its weapons overseas. Even if countries don’t disperse the weapons they buy, they use them to re-equip their own armies and then the arms released are sold elsewhere,” he added.

According to some estimates the world community has spent some 30 trillion dollars on military items over the last 50 years. The United Nations estimates that the cost of achieving universal access to basic health services would be 25 billion dollars a year, just three percent of the 800 billion dollars that currently go into military spending every year.

The lost development opportunities due to military spending are overwhelming: In this decade alone an estimated four million people have died in violent conflicts, 90 percent of them civilians, according to the Carnegie Commission on Preventing Deadly Conflict.

The United Nations Development Programme estimates that more than 100 million people are chronically malnourished in today’s conflict zones.

Members of the Organisation of Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) together contribute up to 10 billion dollars every year in emergency humanitarian assistance, much of it conflict-related.

Hefty peacekeeping costs include five billion dollars for Bosnia in 1996, in addition to 2.45 billion pounds to be spent by the European Union for rebuilding Bosnia.

“While less developed countries are, of course, entitled to self- defence, the amounts spent on the military by many poorer countries may exceed what is required for this purpose,” the Saferworld report says.

“We need transparency in these matters and the best way to get it is by establishing a select committee of the House of Commons with the responsibility for scrutinising government arms export policy and individual license applications,” Campbell added.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags