Development & Aid, Headlines, Health, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

POPULATION-BARBADOS: Mercy Killing Now on the Agenda

Sandra Brown

BRIDGETOWN, Jun 26 1998 (IPS) - For the past two years, Marcelina Brown’s life has not been the same. The 70 year-old woman’s life changed forever when her 45 year-old daughter, Sonia, was diagnosed with an inoperable brain tumour.

And while Sonia is still alive, she “has her bad days” when her illness takes her physical strength away. But her strength to live is also waning and sometimes she feels as if she cannot go on any longer. She also feels that she is a burden to her mother.

Brown (not her real name) says her daughter has contemplated mercy killing or euthanasia as the ethicists call it, at times when the pain becomes unbearable.

“I will have none of that. She feels she is a pain to me but that’s not true. I love my daughter and I just want to make sure she is comfortable and as pain-free as possible.

“While I am scared for her to die from cancer I do not feel she should go before her time and only the Lord can decide that,” says Brown.

One Minister of Religion, who did not want to be named, says while he understands Sonia’s pain, he does not feel it is right to take a life.

“God decides when it is time for each of us to go. That decision is not left to us. And while in certain illnesses people want to opt for doctor-assisted suicides because of the pain… I still don’t think it is right to decide when we go,” he says.

In recent times the question of doctor-assisted suicide, the phenomenon which was made popular by American, Dr. Jack Kevorkian, have become a topic for discussion in this eastern Caribbean island with a population of 252,000.

Health Minister, Elizabeth Thompson says many doctors and patients have raised the issue, but opinions differ as to whether or not it should be legalised.

“We have no policy on it at the moment, but several people have asked us to look at the whole issue of doctor-assisted suicide.

“Then there’s also the whole question of executing living wills which determine what happens to you in the event that you are really sick and can no longer make choices,” she says.

Chief-of-Staff at the Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Tony Harris cautions that doctor-assisted suicide will not become a way of life here anytime soon because of the many ethical and legal issues involved.

“It will take a whole societal change in attitude … before we can get close to that,” he says. The laws of Britain, which many Caribbean islands have adopted state that “everyone’s right to life shall be protected by law.”

Meanwhile, the medical practice of “do not resuscitate” (DNR) and organ donation, may soon be raised with the Minister of Health, adds Harris.

He says the question of whether doctors could determine if a person is brain-dead and on that basis could pull the plug, surfaced here several years ago and has seemingly been put back on the agenda with this new wave of persons wanting to end their lives with the help of a doctor when they are terminally ill.

“She (Thompson) could very well be asked to deal with this problem in the near future,” says Harris.

This too, would require a change in the country’s legislation. “Right now, you can’t pull the plug on anyone who is brain-dead. If we can get legislation dealing with brain-dead patients, then we can pull plugs and get into organ donations and so on.

“That is different from someone who has cancer willing to get a doctor help them die so they won’t have prolonged suffering. But we need to have legislation in place that explains to us what is brain-dead and what you can or cannot do with a person on life support,” Harris says.

He, however, agrees that patients have the right to determine their course of action if they feel that they have little chance of surviving, but adds that the decision must be unbiased and therefore made by a doctor other than the patient’s own.

Harris says there is currently no rule defining the difference between a patient who is brain-dead and one who is clinically dead. “There is a total void as far as that is concerned,” he says.

“Someone can be on a ventilator and not be brain-dead. If anything was to happen and one had to go on a ventilator, right now no one is legally authorised to turn it off,” he adds.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags