Development & Aid, Europe, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

MIGRATION-GERMANY: Foreigners Forced Into The Election Battleground

Yojana Sharma

BERLIN, Jul 29 1998 (IPS) - Fourteen year old ‘Mehmet’ has been tried and convicted for a string of crimes, and today sits in a German detention centre awaiting deportation to Turkey.

But the Bavarian authorities say that Mehmet’s parents must also pay a penalty for their son’s crimes, and must leave with him, despite their 30 years of working life in Germany and the fact that they have two other law-abiding children still working here.

With elections approaching, the Bavarian Christian Social Union (CSU), conservative partners in a centre-right government coalition under extreme pressure in the polls, thinks it needs to make a public example of Mehmet and his family.

They want to convince right-wing voters that something is being done about foreign children who turn to crime — and ‘foreigners and law and order’ are a perfect mix of right-of-centre political concerns.

On the other side of the spectrum, Fereschta Ludin, 25, a German national of Afghan origin has been refused a job as a teacher, which in Germany confers civil service status.

For she insists on wearing her head scarf in class, and that, say the authorities of the southern state of Baden-Wuerttemberg, sets a bad example to Turkish girls trying to integrate into German society, and unlikely to promote tolerance among students.

Few politicians support her stand, and other states in the German federation said they would have done the same in similar circumstances. Only a member of the environmental Green Party was willing to argue that it would be a more effective symbol of tolerance to allow Ms Ludin her head scarf.

Foreigners have become an election issue for all political parties in Germany amid rising xenophobia in the country. The campaign has been further distorted by the fallout from recent advances by extreme-right neo-Nazi parties, who blame foreigners for rising unemployment.

So far the only party of the centre-right to buck the trend has been the Free Democrats (FDP), the junior party in the tripartite coalition with the CSU and the Christian Democrats (CDU) led by Chancellor Helmut Kohl.

FDP Minister of Economics Guenter Rexrodt has warned that anti- foreigner rhetoric could scare off foreign investors and jeopardise economic recovery in Germany. “Does anyone think an investor will bring his money to Germany if he will not be well- liked as a person here?” Rexrodt asked recently.

As a subject it makes some of his colleagues unhappy. Heiner Geissler, deputy chairman of the CDU/CSU parliamentary group, says the foreigner debate distracts from the “really important issues”.

But national elections will be held on Sep. 27 and the gloves are off. At first, controlling immigration was a subject raised only by the far right and by the conservative CSU. Now all the major parties have put “action on foreigners” on their agenda.

They fear that without promises on immigration control, votes will be lost to far-right parties, particularly in the eastern part of Germany. In April the far-right German People’s Union polled 13 percent of the vote in Saxony-Anhalt’s recent state elections, entering the state parliament with 16 members.

The ruling Christian Democrats, trailing behind the Social Democrats in the polls, have tried to set the agenda while eschewing some of the xenophobia of the Bavarian CSU. But they do pander to a view that foreigners are unwanted and, say some, are creating divisions that will outlast the current electioneering.

Even the centre-left Social Democrats (SPD), which had earlier shied away from the foreigner-bashing that sometimes characterises the CDU/CSU coalition campaign, now echoes their line.

The SDP now warn that migrants who commit crimes in Germany will face tough action — including possible deportation. They also allege that certain criminal activities, such as drug trafficking and prostitution, are ‘dominated’ by migrant groups.

Theo Waigel, CSU head and German finance minister, takes note of the shift. “Anyone who abuses their rights as a guest has to leave Germany,” he said. “When we first said that a year or two ago, it caused a huge commotion. In the meantime the opposition is now repeating what we’ve been saying all along.”

Later the SPD tried to distance itself from the CDU, arguing that overall crime rates among non-Germans was lower than among the German population as a whole. But the mitigating message was lost in the tabloid headlines.

“When the Germans look around and say, ‘who are all these foreign criminals who are living on social security?’ They see us Turks and they say, ‘it must be you’,” says Ilmet, who works in a bicycle repair shop.

He says the statements of politicians have merely exacerbated the ‘them and us’ divide among Turks living in Germany. “Despite all our efforts, the gulf (between Germans and Turks) is getting wider when it should be narrowing,” he says.

Statistics show the Turks are no more likely than Germans to commit crimes. And it is the more recent arrivals from the former Soviet Union and refugees from the civil war in Bosnia-Hercegovina who make up the numerical bulk of foreigners on welfare handouts.

But such distinctions are not made here and rather than tackling the problems of the individual groups, the politicians prefer to lump them together.

Foreign migrants, known here as ‘guestworkers’, make up some 8.5 percent of the country’s population. Around 40 percent have lived in Germany more than 20 years and two thirds of their children were born in the country. But few have citizenship or voting rights, and can be targeted easily without much fear of losing votes.

Attempts to give long-term residents citizenship have foundered, opposed by centre-right politicians who believe ‘foreigners’ who have the right to vote will vote centre-left.

In the current election campaign messages being put out by the parties is that foreigners live in ‘ghettos’, refuse to learn adequate German and are poorly integrated into society.

Proposals floated by the ruling CDU for action to ‘integrate’ non- Germans include the requirement that foreigners learn German before they can get long-term work permits and a proposal to bar new migrants from living in areas with large non-German communities.

Migrant children in some inner city areas could even be barred from schools if ‘too many foreigners’ are already enrolled.

Even ostensibly ‘liberal’ measures have a hardline sub-text. CSU parliamentary group leader Michael Glos actually advocates a relaxation of the rules on migrant family reunions, calling for a reduction on the age limit of migrant children allowed to join their families in Germany from 16 to ten.

Why? “Those who come here when they are young learn better German, finish school and integrate better,” he says. “If someone wants a permanent residence permit, then they want something from the German state,” Glos said in a magazine interview. “They owe something in return, including an obligation to learn the German language.”

The Berlin region’s hardline interior minister, Joerg Schoenbohm (CDU), takes a similar line. He says foreigners who fail to “integrate properly” and did not want to learn German should be sent home or have their social security benefits cut.

Abdussalem Kutuk has lived for 22 years in Germany. He, his wife and his three children, all students, speak perfect German. They live far away from the Turkish ‘ghetto’ in Berlin’s Kreuzberg district, yet they find Schoenbohm’s speeches disturbing.

“Schoenbohm has no idea,” says Kutuk’s daughter Nurdan, currently studying German and French at Berlin’s Technical University. “Turkish parents long ago realised the importance of language. Many take on cleaning jobs in order to pay for after- school tuition for their children.”

Ahmet, a kebab stall owner, says that since the politicians started taking this line, more of his customers have come out with racist comments. “I just do my work, pay my taxes and keep quiet,” says Ahmet. “Soon this election will be over and the politicians will be quiet again.”

But others are not so sure things will be calm. Politicians are creating divisions and encouraging prejudices instead of breaking them down. Mere efforts to encourage tolerance, such as the Green Party’s multi-cultural policies here, have come under attack from Schoenbohm.

Kutuk’s son, Ilker, 27, believes that Schoenbohm’s speeches have “lit the fuse of a (stick of) dynamite” which is bound to affect the lives of all foreigners in Berlin. “It is only the beginning,” he says.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags