Development & Aid, Europe, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

RIGHTS-BRITAIN: Mixed Response To Asylum Rights Shake-Up

Dipankar De Sarkar

LONDON, Jul 27 1998 (IPS) - The British government Monday unveiled plans for a “fairer, faster and firmer” system for migrants and asylum seekers coming to Britain, but drew a mixed reception from refugee rights groups.

“What we are presenting today is an integrated strategy to deliver a fairer, faster and firmer approach to immigration control,” Home Secretary Jack Straw said announcing the plans as part of a White Paper in the British lower house of Parliament.

“Fundamental to this,” he continued, “is the need to modernise procedures and deliver faster decisions.”

Straw’s proposals for migration law reform in 1988 include increased powers for immigration officers to enter premises to search and detain people. There are also plans to give officers more powers to remove and deport would-be immigrants or asylum seekers, refugee groups quoted Straw as telling them in a recent meeting.

“We are extremely worried about the increased powers for immigration officers and for plans to increase checks on people in their countries of origin,” said Mick Chatwin, Legal Director at Briatin’s Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants.

Immigration officers already have the powers to forcibly enter premises and search and seize, but they must do so in the presence of police.

A Home Office document quoted in the British press recently says: “Providing these powers, together with the power to execute a warrant, would enable immigration officers to act more frequently independently of the police.”

Other plans include quadrupling the number of airlines liaison officers — government officials who are posted abroad to ensure that only bona fide visitors are allowed to travel to Britain. There are currently five such officials, working in Lagos, Accra, Dhaka, Delhi and Islamabad.

“The point is to scale down passport checks in British airports,” Chatwin said. “Jack Straw for instance told us ‘why should we bother to look at the passport of every Japanese tourist?’

“The implication is that there will be targetted checks on certain airlines.”

But immigration and refugee groups gave a cautious welcome to Straw’s decision to put some 10,000 pending asylum applications on the fast track

“This is a grudging acceptance that people who have been living in limbo for years are going to be allowed to get on with their lives,” said Nick Hardwick, Chief Executive of the NGO the Refugee Council.

“This is a paltry measure which does not go far enough. We will have to see if the government can really deliver a more efficient system, or the backlog will simply build up again,” he added.

Chatwin said his group welcomed the announcement that “cases can be cleared up more rapidly and the expectation that people can get on with planning their future.”

However, Straw refused to allow a partial amnesty to deal with the nearly 53,000 asylum cases that he said are currently outstanding. These delayed rulings are costing the British government 500 million pounds (800 million dollars) a year in benefits and legal bills.

“In the past 10 years, we have seen a tenfold increase in the number of people claiming asylum in this country,” Straw said.

“If their case is properly established and they cannot go back because of really serious worry about persecution, they will be able to stay here. But for those people who come and abuse the system, we are going to be a lot tougher.”

Controversy dogs the issue of asylum seekers in Britain, even though the number of asylum seekers arriving here is not large compared to some other European countries. The wait for permission to stay in Britain can often last as long as seven years while immigration officers decide the cases.

Many are housed in asylum centres that are run like prisons by private security companies, creating conditions that were castigated in April this year by the government’s own Chief Inspector of Prisons, Sir David Ramsbotham.

Detainees at the most infamous of these centres, at Campsfield near Oxford in south east England, erupted into a day-long riot in August last year. This prompted Ramsbotham to say: “Until clear rules and obligations are established for people held in detention and for the staff who look after them, the prospect of repeat disturbances… will remain.”

Liberal Democrat MP Evan Harris, whose constituency includes Campsfield, said: “It is clear that this country detains far too many (asylum seekers) for far too long, at far too young an age in many cases, without good reason, without giving a reason, without judicial oversight, under the wrong regimes and with inadequate safeguards.”

The plans announced Monday included proposals for an independent review of decisions to detain asylum seekers, but refugee groups said they were concerned by additional intentions to detain more of those whose appeals are refused.

Among the most controversial of Straw’s proposals was one that seeks to introduce a new system of supporting asylum seekers with aid in kind — through the provision of food and clothing for instance — rather than cash benefits.

According to Chatwin, this will take the form of a “new form of allowance” to be paid by the Home Office (the British interior ministry), in place of the earlier system where would-be refugees were entitled to normal income support cash benefits.

“The best way to support asylum seekers is to allow them to work,” said Hardwick of the Refugee Council. “If they are not allowed to work, the simplest and most efficient system is to make cash payments. The government’s proposal to provide support in kind is a huge risk and may end up replacing one shambles with another.”

Refugee and immigration groups accuse successive British governments of implementing harsh immigration and asylum laws and of being “obsessed with numbers.”

“Britain’s record has never been particularly good — there has always been a lot of rhetoric about economic migrants. This has continued well into the collapse of the Soviet Union and the subsequent recent European immigrants,” said Chatwin.

Nick Hardwick added, “It’s a mixed bag of measures. We will have to wait and see if the Home Office is successful at making the system faster and we are not convinced that the White Paper’s proposed steps to make it fairer.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags