Saturday, November 21, 2026
Thalif Deen
- The United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF), one of the U.N.’s strongest advocates of a permanent war crimes tribunal, has mixed feelings about the new International Criminal Court (ICC) established last week.
“The good news is that the Court will come into being,” UNICEF Executive Director Carol Bellamy said Monday. “The bad news, however, is that there are elements in the statute itself which could deny or severely delay justice for many children and women.”
Bellamy expressed “serious reservations” about two elements of the final ICC statute which was adopted by U.N. members Friday at a conference in Rome by the overwhelming majority of 120-7, with 21 abstentions.
One of these is a provision that guarantees states can “opt out” of the agreement seven years after the treaty’s entry into force. They could do so by declaring that they do not accept the ICC’s jurisidction if a crime is allegedly committed by one of their nationals or on their territory.
As a U.N. agency opposed to child soldiers, UNICEF also is critical of the provision that permits 15-year-olds to be pressed into military service.
Bellamy specifically criticised the inclusion of the “opt- out” clause in the statute. “This clause, if exercised, could give those responsible for today’s atrocities a green light to continue their nefarious violations of human rights and international law,” she noted. “It is therefore UNICEF’s hope that states will refrain from making use of the opt-out clause.”
The most serious result of extending the time frame for accepting the jurisdiction of the ICC, will be to diminish the possibility that current perpetrators of atrocities against women and children will ever be brought to justice, she said.
Bellamy said delays could mean that those who have stolen Dinka children in southern Sudan can continue to act with impunity, and that the maiming, kidnapping and slaughter at the hands of Joseph Kony and the Lord’s Resistance Army can proceed unabated.
“The wholesale mutilation of children and rape of women from Sierra Leone to Indonesia can occur with vastly diminished prospects that there will ever be prosecution,” she added.
Bellamy also expressed UNICEF’s opposition to 15 as the age at which children can be recruited into the military. “While UNICEF is pleased that the enlistment of children into the military will be seen as a war crime, UNICEF holds to its conviction that the minimum age should be 18 – not 15.”
“There is a clear contradiction if the military recruitment age is set at 15, when the statute also says that no child below the age of 18 can be tried by the Court. The latter position is laudable, but the former may put at risk the fundamental rights of children,” she said.
The statute that was adopted last week grants the ICC jurisdiction over four types of crime – genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and aggression. But the Court’s jurisdiction over the crime of aggression was delayed until an agreement can be reached on its definition.
U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan admitted the shortcomings of the new court when said that “many of us, no doubt, would have liked a Court vested with even more far reaching powers.” “But that should not lead us to minimise the breakthrough you have achieved,” he told delegates at the signing ceremony in Rome Saturday.
“The establishment of the ICC is still a gift of hope to future generations, and a giant step forward in the march towards universal human rights and the rule of law,” Annan said. “It is an achievement which, only a few years ago, nobody would have thought possible.”
Looking at the positive aspects of the court, Bellamy herself admitted that despite UNICEF’s disappointment on individual issues, “the entire ICC process is a triumph because it will result in the establishment of a permanent international tribunal which can bring individuals to justice for genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity.”
“With all of the disagreements and delays,” she pointed out, “we should not be blind to the incredible progress that has been made since Trinidad and Tobago revived the 50-year-old dream of a permanent international criminal court back in 1989,” Bellamy said.
Meanwhile, there was no official breakdown of the voting on the statute because the United States insisted on a “non-recorded vote.” Since there was no electronic voting in Rome, the United Nations has refused to name the countries which voted for, against or abstained, purely because it has no record of it.
Some of the newsreports coming out of Rome differed in their accounts of which countries voted against and which abstained.
“It’s a shame,” one U.N. official said Monday, “here is a historic institution that took about 50 years to become a reality – and there is no official record of voting on its creation.”
The only official indication of voting came from 14 countries – India, Uruguay, Mauritius, Philippines, Norway, Belgium, the United States, Brazil, Israel, Sri Lanka, China, Turkey, Singapore and the United Kingdom. At the end of the meeting delegates took the floor to explain why they voted as they did. However, the signatures and ratifications in the coming months will provide an indication of who voted for the court.