Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

FINANCE-US: IMF Critics Tie Strings to Funds

Abid Aslam

WASHINGTON, Sep 16 1998 (IPS) - Congressional critics of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) scrambled Wednesday to subject the global lender to a dose of its own medicine: conditionality.

“The IMF has long recognised that tying strings to money is the most effective way to ensure certain performance targets,” said Carol Welch, policy analyst with the environmental group Friends of the Earth. “It should understand firsthand why Congress refuses to hand it a blank cheque.”

Members of the House of Representatives sought to take advantage of a vote on increased U.S. funding for the IMF – expected on Thursday – to press for reforms ranging from reduced secrecy to improved performance on debt relief and the environment.

The administration of President Bill Clinton asked Congress for 18 billion dollars for the IMF, including 14.5 billion dollars to increase the U.S. ‘quota’, or membership dues. The international financial institution’s hopes of expanding its capital base by 45 percent hinged on the United States, with its decisive 18-percent stake in the Fund.

A key House committee last week struck down the quota increase and instead recommended only 3.5 billion dollars for an emergency line of credit to help the global lender of last resort to cope with financial crises.

Legislative sources said the quota increase remained a live issue because top Democrats and other members sympathetic to the embattled IMF or beleaguered Clinton were expected to make a renewed push for it on the House floor.

Even if the 435-member chamber endorsed last week’s House Appropriations Committee decision, the quota increase could resurface in a ‘conference committee’ of Senators and Representatives. Such a group would be charged with reconciling differences between the House and Senate, which recently approved the full 18 billion dollars.

Confronted with those possibilities, legislators scrambled to signal that they were “fed up with the IMF’s tortoise-like pace of reforms and its deplorable record in attempting to restore the economies of Thailand, Indonesia, Korea, and now Russia,” said Welch.

According to legislative and political sources, a number of amendments to the ‘Foreign Operations Appropriations Bill’ for fiscal 1999 were already in the works.

– Rep. Cynthia McKinney, Democrat of Georgia, hoped to condition new IMF funding on the agency’s agreement to reduce, and then limit, developing countries’ debt service burden to 10 percent or less of their export earnings.

– Rep. George Miller, Democrat of California, in a draft amendment, sought to make Fund loans “subject to adherence to and enforcement of” international environmental agreements. The agency would have to prepare environmental assessments for all proposed loans, consult environmental agencies (not only finance ministries and central banks), and include the costs of “environmental depletion and degradation” in member countries’ national accounts.

– Rep. Dennis Kucinich, Democrat of Ohio, proposed stripping from the appropriations bill, Congressional endorsement of the IMF’s requirements that developing countries deregulate trade in goods, services, and investment. As a result, explained one Congressional source, the Fund would not have Congress’ approval for its efforts to enforce free-trade agreements or ease the flow of private capital.

– Rep. Jim Saxton, Republican of New Jersey, sought to extract promises of greater IMF transparency in exchange for U.S. funds. Saxton has urged greater openness on the lending agency’s internal resources because assessments of its financial health after a year of record lending varied widely – and because Washington’s representative at the Fund admitted that the agency’s accounts were mysterious to her.

– Rep. Spencer Bachus, Republican of Alabama, reportedly was considering measures to require private lenders to share the costs of international financial rescues such as those in Asia and Russia. His position, summarised by one political observer, was that there should be “no public bailouts for bad business decisions.”

– Rep. Bernard Sanders, Independent of Vermont, was weighing measures to strengthen the ‘Sanders-Frank Amendment’ of 1994, which required the U.S. government to use its “voice and vote” to urge the IMF to “encourage borrowing countries to guarantee internationally recognised worker rights … and to include the status of such rights as an integral part of the institution’s policy dialogue with each borrowing country.”

Earlier this year, Sanders was outraged when Karin Lissakers, U.S. executive director at the Fund, said she had not voted against any loans because colleagues on the board favoured consensus over votes. Her admission made it clear that U.S. officials had disregarded the law on numerous occasions, Sanders argued. These included board discussions leading up to last year’s IMF-led bailout in Indonesia, which he said was illegal under the 1994 legislation.

Backers of amendments under preparation Wednesday acknowledged limitations on their ability to enforce conditions once U.S. funds reached the IMF. That was why Miller’s amendment, for example, would withhold the quota increase until after U.S. officials certified that the agency had put in place necessary mechanisms to meet the more stringent environmental requirements.

However, “once the policy is in effect, and the money has been released, you have the same problems of enforcement as at present,” Daniel Weiss, Miller’s chief of staff, told IPS. “You need watchdogs.”

In related developments Wednesday, a leading lobbying group of private banks and investment houses threw its support behind the U.S. administration’s request. “It is especially critical in current circumstances that adequate funding be assured for the IMF,” the Institute of International Finance said in a statement. It urged the Fund to increase “constructive dialogue with private financial firms”.

The Institute acknowledged that “the private financial community also needs to join…the official sector and borrowers…to consider how the volatility of short-term capital flows might be mitigated”.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags