Saturday, November 21, 2026
Jim Lobe
- As if he didn’t have enough to worry about already, U.S. President Bill Clinton may face a new crisis over North Korea when he returns home from this week’s trip to Russia and Northern Ireland.
Japan and South Korea have already put their militaries on a heightened state of alert in anticipation of a second missile test by Pyongyang this weekend following Monday’s launch of a two- stage, medium-range missile that soared over Japan before splashing into the Pacific Ocean.
Tokyo reacted to Monday’s launch by freezing aid to North Korea and by putting off talks on normalising ties with Pyongyang and signing a framework agreement to help finance the construction of two nuclear power plants under a 1994 accord negotiated by Washington.
The flashy public debut of the new Taepodong-1 missile, which is believed to have a range of about 2,000 kms, has also bolstered hawks in the Congress here. They have long argued that Pyongyang has no intention of abiding by the 1994 agreement to dismantle its own nuclear programme.
On Wednesday, the Senate approved an amendment to the 1999 foreign-aid bill which would delete Washington’s 35 million-dollar contribution to the international consortium – the Korean Energy Development Organization (KEDO) – unless Clinton certifies that Pyongyang is complying strictly with the 1994 accord.
So far, the administration, while expressing concern over the missile firing, has reacted cautiously, and some officials pointed at Friday’s announcement by Pyongyang that the missile actually launched a satellite into orbit and did not carry a dummy warhead, as had been widely assumed.
“Although it would have been nice to warn everyone ahead of time,” noted one senior official, “a satellite launch has a somewhat less provocative quality about it than a missile test.” He added that Washington was now trying to confirm whether the missile was, in fact, used to launch a satellite.
The 1994 accord with Pyongyang has been cited repeatedly by the Clinton administration as one of its most important foreign-policy breakthroughs, and officials would be loth to see it fall apart.
It provided that North Korea freeze and eventually dismantle its own nuclear programme – which Washington said was designed in part to manufacture nuclear weapons – in exchange for the construction by KEDO of two nuclear plants worth about 4.5 billion dollars and tens of millions of dollars in oil supplies over 20 years.
Under the accord, Japan and South Korea were to be KEDO’s main financial backers, while Washington agreed to provide much of the heating oil needed by North Korea. In addition, the administration pledged to upgrade diplomatic ties with Pyongyang.
The Republican-led Congress, however, has been skeptical about Pyongyang’s intentions virtually from the outset and has not fully funded Washington’s commitments under the 1994 accord. As a result, the United States has fallen far behind on its oil shipments.
In addition, Clinton, fearing a strong political backlash, has failed to end a 50-year economic embargo of the North despite encouragement to do so from South Korea’s president, Kim Dae Jung, who took office last January.
As a result, Pyongyang has declared its growing frustration with Washington’s failure to meet its expectations – to deliver the oil, upgrade diplomatic relations and end the embargo -. It has also threatened to resume its nuclear programme and increase its missile sales abroad to earn hard currency. Most recently, it has demanded that Washington compensate it for foregoing missiles sales.
Some analysts believe that Monday’s test – whose technical achievement was conceded by officials here – was essentially an advertisement for its missile programme, as well as a more general reminder, as University of Chicago specialist Bruce Cumings wrote, that “we exist.”
In any case, however, the launch was considered particularly ominous in light of intelligence reports last month that thousands of workers have been deployed to a huge underground complex about 40 kms from the Yongbyon nuclear plant, which is supposed to be dismantled under the 1994 agreement. Analysts believe that the site is designed to house a new nuclear plant, although they – and the administration – are unsure whether Pyongyang actually intends to build a reactor or to use it as a bargaining chip to gain compliance or more concessions from Washington.
Monday’s missile launch, however, has given the initiative in the debate over North Korean intentions to the hawks in the Senate and elsewhere. “The time has come to say, ‘We told you so,”‘ wrote a former Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) officer, Kent Harrington, in the Washington Post this week.
“Bent on achieving ultimate military power on the peninsula, North Korea has worked for 30 years to develop nuclear weapons. Its investment of resources, its risk-taking and its persistence make clear it does not intend to trade that goal for economic aid, political recognition or security guarantees.”
But other analysts both in and outside the administration are not ready to give up. “The choice for Washington (still) is whether it wants to spend a relatively small amount to build relations with Pyongyang and effectively buy out its missile program, or let threatening regimes in the Middle East buy them instad, and whether finally to recognize a regime that does not seem to be going away soon and lift the embargo, or to continue a 50-year policy that has not achieved its goals,” wrote Cumings in the Los Angeles Times.
Administration analysts tend more, at this point, to the Cumings view, although few favour normalising ties at this juncture.
“Pulling back from our own commitments (under the 1994 accord) at this point is very dangerous,” said one senior official who argued that the agreement remained a “very good deal for the U.S.” compared to the alternative.
If the missile was designed to launch a satellite rather than a dummy warhead, he noted, it may be easier for Japan, which had committed one billion dollars to KEDO, to temper its initial reaction and save the accord.