Europe, Headlines, Human Rights

RIGHTS-EUROPE: Complexity Of Case Foxes British And Spanish Media

Dolores Cortes

LONDON, Nov 18 1998 (IPS) - The case of former Chilean president Augusto Pinochet presents a serious challenge to the legal establishment.

But Spanish and British journalists covering the story face an even greater challenge. The case is legally complex and their response to it often coloured by the scale and cruelty of the offenses attributed to Pinochet, say observers here and in Madrid.

Pinochet was arrested by British police on Oct. 16 while recovering from a back operation in a London hospital pending a request for his extradition and from a Spanish judge. On Nov. 12 the Spanish government issued a formal demand for his extradition.

He seized power during a 1973 coup d’etat in which elected president Salvador Allende died. Judge Balthazar Garzon of Spain is investigating the disappearance of nearly a hundred Spanish passport holders during Pinochet’s 17 years in power.

A British court then ruled Pinochet’s arrest illegal on the ground that the Chilean general had ‘sovereign immunity’. The case went to appeal before Britain’s Law Lords, acting as the country’s supreme court. They are expected to give their verdict this week.

But with little time to reflect and limited space for their work, the media coverage of the Pinochet case has been described as inaccurate, misleading, and emotionally driven, say critics.

Gegorio Dionis is an Argentinian lawyer leading a Madrid based NGO, Equipo Nizkor, that campaigns for a greater awareness of human rights in Latin America. He complains that the Spanish media’s reporting on the Pinochet case has taken an “emotional approach to the subject, which often ignores the legal fundamentals”.

Although foreign media did get in touch with his group, Dionis says, “the Spanish media have not consulted us nor have they used any other legitimate sources.”

Dionis argues that the Spanish media has failed “to grasp the relevance of the parallel process carried out by Amnesty International (and other NGOs) in the House of Lords, nor the implications of the process for international law”.

The media approach, he claims, has focused on the official handling of the case rather than the legal issues raised by the NGOs, who have deployed some of the world’s top lawyers in international law in pursuit of their case. “I do not blame that on the journalists, but the (media) management who should encourage better research,” Dionis said.

The pressure on the Spanish media is high. Rafael Torres, a columnist for the Madrid daily El Mundo was sacked in early November after he published an exclusive interview with Joan Garces, a former associate of Allende and an expert in international law, now assisting Garzon’s team.

“After I published a column interviewing Joan Garces I was told that my column was finished from them on. I was made redundant,” Torres told IPS in a phone interview. He had worked for the paper for nine years.

Torres suspects that his dismissal may be linked to pressure from the chief of the Spanish High Court, Eduardo Fungairino. Fungairino is on record as rejecting Spain’s right to try Pinochet, a view overruled by a separate judicial hearing last month.

But the British media do not escape censure. The British “have adopted a moral stance saying: this guy has done wrong. Therefore it does not matter what laws exist to protect him because he should not be entitled to protection” says British lawyer Craig Barker, a specialist in diplomatic immunity.

Barker accuses British journalists, along with their Spanish colleagues, of “a lack of in depth research”. He says the main mistake committed by British journalists is their “inability to distinguish between the two basic concepts of diplomatic and sovereign immunity”.

The question of the legality of Pinochet’s arrest, which the House of Lords is currently considering, confuses the issue. “It is not a question of jurisdiction but a question of immunity” Barker says.

The media, he notes, seems to have forgotten that the British authorities are not trying Pinochet, but considering his claim to immunity from prosecution under international law. This must be confirmed if the earlier ruling refusing his arrest — and thus his extradition to Spain — is to stand.

Britain adheres to several treaties, including the Geneva Convention and the Convention Against Torture, which appear to contradict the 1978 State Immunity Act, the law originally cited by the British courts when they ruled that Pinochet had ‘sovereign immunity’ from prosecution as a head of state.

Yet the precedent set by the post World War II Nuremberg trials of German war criminals, means that no head of state can claim immunity from charges of crimes against humanity. It is this conflict that the Law Lords are trying to unravel. In doing so, Barker notes, they may be turning the British system upside down.

Barker is sure of one thing: “There is no way the Lords can overrule the concept of sovereign immunity according to our written British law (the State Immunity Act).” Only the British parliament can change the law in Britain — or so it is thought.

“If the Lords decide to deny Pinochet’s sovereign immunity it would be a breakthrough in our legal history because they would be overruling a parliamentary act issued in 1978,” Barker says.

But the case raises even deeper issues, far more complex than the dichotomy between domestic British law and international law. Barker says the entire idea of sovereignty of states, at the core of mainstream international law is being questioned.

The Amnesty case as presented by international law expert Ian Brownlie and others takes a less apocalyptic approach to the legal issues.

Their first argument is that the 1978 State Immunity Act does not apply to criminal proceedings such as mass murder or kidnapping. Barker concedes that if the Lords accept this point the appeal against immunity will almost certainly be successful and Pinochet will be on his way to a Spanish court.

But Amnesty’s case takes other strands, based on the theory that Pinochet committed the first of his crimes before he became head of state. “If there is evidence for that the Lords would be legally right to overturn the High Court decision,” says Barker.

A decision along these simpler lines would have political advantages and limit the legal fallout from a full scale clash between British domestic and international law.

The bid to try Pinochet has encouraged exile groups from Cuba to Bolivia to try and use the courts to extradite and try their political opponents in Spanish courts. Some say that if Pinochet is tried, Britain’s Queen or former prime minister Margaret Thatcher might face charges, for example, as ultimately responsible for rights abuses in Northern Ireland.

But if evidence is found that Pinochet committed his crimes before he became head of state, the validity of the concept of state immunity would be preserved and would mean, Barker concludes, that other heads of state “would not be at risk” in Britain.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags