Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

DEVELOPMENT: Canada Cuts Back on Foreign Aid

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Mar 1 1999 (IPS) - Canada’s new federal budget will reduce foreign aid by about 80 million dollars in the coming financial year, according to detailed spending estimates released Monday.

The cuts will be made to programs fighting malnutrition, disaster relief, and development aid.

The budget, released in February – while Canada held the chair of the Security Council – showed a slight increase in aid spending, but the details Monday shows that the increase has gone to pre- payment of memberships in multilateral organizations and payments to the International Monetary Fund.

The federal spending estimates show the Canadian government lopped about 80 million dollars off the country’s foreign aid grants. and about 30 million dollars off its overall aid budget, despite relatively string growth in the economy and a 7 billion dollars government surplus.

As a percentage of the country’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP), foreign aid expenditures have fallen below .34 percent, according to government statistics. Critics of the Canadian aid program say the percentage is lower.

Canada gives less as a percentage of GDP than does Denmark, Norway, Sweden, The Netherlands, France, Luxembourg, Belgium, Finland, Switzerland and Germany.

Included in the spending cuts are 50 million dollars from developmental aid to international organizations and developmental institutions, leaving that sector of the aid budget at about 21 million dollars.

About 4 million dollars has been cut from NGO programs to fight hunger, reducing that sector of Canadian government spending to about 50 million dollars. . The budget does add 15 million dollars for humanitarian assistance and disaster preparedness for Canadian agencies and NGOs, bringing that allocation up to about 60 million dollars.

Money for Canada’s International Development Agency (CIDA) have been cut by about 35 million dollars. Much of Canada’s aid is also contingent on using the money to buy Canadian goods and services, a policy that angers some opposition politicians.

Alexa McDunnough, leader of the social democratic New Democratic Party, denounced the failure of the Canadian government to increase its aid budget, and worries that too much foreign assistance is tied to trade.

We’re still way behind what is widely accepted as a reasonable level of commitment toward aid,” she said. “I think there’s a very big concern that our Prime Minister has become much more of a salesman than a statesman.

“Canada’s foreign aid has taken the form of being tied toward commercial interests and commercial ventures. I think we need to get back on a focus of humanitarian aid and ensuring it’s aid that’s genuinely going to those who most benefit from it.”

The cuts were condemned by the North-South Institute, a think- tank on Third World issues.

“It’s a bad thing. Aid has been hacked and chopped and tortured for decades. Either we should get out of it all together, or, if we decide to stay in it, needs to be rebuilt. We seemed to have bottomed out,” said Jim Culpeper, president of the institute.

He said money in the foreign aid budget has been used to pre-pay obligations to international agencies, so it’s possible that, after payments were made to multilateral organization, the real amount has “plateaued out”.

The institute does not believe the government’s ODA/GDP percentage calculations: “I’m surprised at the .34 calculation. We believe it’s even lower, at .27, ” Culpepper said.

Canadian opinion polls show that, among voters, foreign aid ranks far below state-run health care, debt reductions, tax cuts and domestic social programs as a spending priority. Still, many Canadians mistakenly believe their country remains among the front rank of donor countries.

Foreign aid spending was projected on a rolling three-year basis in the 1995-96 federal budget. Overall, the decline between 1994- 95 and 1998-99 was expected to reach close to 1 billion dollars.

Canada already has been criticized by the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) for failing to deliver on promised levels of international aid to poorest nations.

In January, 1997, an OECD review of foreign aid spending among the association’s 29 members showed Canada’s official development assistance fell to a 30-year low of 0.32 per cent of gross domestic product in 1996, down from 0.45 per cent of GDP in 1990.

Canada is below the OECD average of 0.40 per cent, and far below the United Nations target of 0.70 per cent of GDP. The United States, Britain and Italy give even less, in terms of percentage of GDP, but because their economies are so large, the amount of cash they give is greater.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags