Friday, November 20, 2026
Mark Bourrie
- The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), originally touted as a common market for goods and services, instead has proved to be a deal that gives multinational corporations the power to erode the laws of signatory countries, according to Canadian critics.
Under the agreement linking Canada, Mexico and the United States, US companies can demand compensation if they can prove that governments have passed laws against activities that are allowable business practices in the United States.
And the NAFTA lawsuits against Canada have been coming thick and fast, the most recent involving Pope-and-Talbot, an Oregon-based forestry company that operates three sawmills in the Kootenay Mountains of British Columbia.
Pope-and-Talbot claims the Canadian government has been unfairly reducing its quota to ship wood to the United States. The company was assigned the quotas under the Canada-US softwood lumber agreement which, ironically, was signed after US loggers said Canadians were unfairly dumping lumber on the US market.
The current litigation is part of a string of suits filed by U.S. companies against the Canadian government to force Canada to back off on environmental or cultural regulations.
In 1998, the Canadian government paid Ethyl Corp. 13 million dollars and lifted its ban on Ethyl’s gasoline additive MMT.
A lawsuit filed by California-based Sunfresh seeks to force Canada to lift its ban on water exports and, in late 1998, S.D. Meyers, a U.S. waste management company, filed a suit for 10 million dollars. It alleges that the Canadian government broke the NAFTA deal when it banned the export of polychlorinated biphenals from Canada.
The ban was imposed after Canadian journalists proved that toxic waste from Canada was illegally being dumped in third-world countries.
Maude Barlow, Chair of the Council of Canadians, a group that has opposed Free Trade since 1988, says the trade deal erodes Canadian sovereignty. She says governments have been secretive about the NAFTA litigation because it proves critics’ claims that the trade deal benefits corporations at the expense of the environment.
“Even when we asked for information under the (Canadian) Freedom of Information, the pages were all whited out,” says Barlow. “In the MMT Ethyl case, the government tried to secretly settle. Ethyl said ‘no’ but if Ethyl had agreed, we would never have known about it – or how much they got.”
She says NAFTA has given U.S.-based multinational corporations broad powers to attack the sovereignty of nations because it is the first treaty that allows corporations to bypass the U.S. government and sue foreign states directly.
“New legislation can regulate Canadian corporations, but US companies must be compensated. NAFTA gives multinational corporations huge powers over governments. And the Multilateral Agreement on Investment wants to make these Investor State Rights world-wide.”
Barlow says the Canadian government tried to portray her group as anti-business zealots, but she says the recent spate of lawsuits proves the trade deal erodes Canadian sovereignty. “We had to wait until we had the proof before people would stop saying we were nuts.”
She points to other problems caused by NAFTA. After the Free Trade Agreement was signed, dozens of US-owned factories were moved from Canada to low-wage US states or to Mexico. The threat of moving was used by many Canadian employers as a cudgel to keep wages down and break unions.
Gordon Laxer, a political economy professor at the University of Alberta, says modern trade deals are “corporate rights” agreements. He says the FTA and NAFTA have pushed Canada “back into a role as hewers of wood and drawers of water”.
He says Canadians have been misled about the nature of the deal.
“Canada thought it was getting free access to a foreign market while the U.S. thought it was an investment agreement about restructuring the role of government and getting access to Canadian resources.”
He says Canada has lost more than twice the number of jobs in the 1990s compared to the United States. In terms of job creation, 80 per cent of new Canadian jobs have been in self-employment, compared to 10 per cent in America.
Part-time employment has doubled in Canada, while remaining at about the same level in the United States.
Bob Saari of the Alliance of Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters says the agreements have delivered on their growth promises, but too many problems have arisen.
“We didn’t envision there would be this many problems and we didn’t envision it would be such a chore to sort them out. I think we’re all disappointed about how things have worked out with respect to lumber and food stocks,” he said.
Saari said the “Buy America” policies of some states have created an entirely new set of trade barriers, leaving Canada with the problems caused by the deals and fewer benefits than its supporters believed.