Thursday, November 19, 2026
Dipankar De Sarkar
- Political unease spread across Europe Friday in the wake of the bombing blitz on Yugoslavia by North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) warplanes.
The disquiet over the air strikes launched Wednesday – ostensibly over the issue of Serbia’s treatment of Albanian Kosovars – was clearly evident in political debate from Portugal to Britain and from Greece to Ireland.
In Britain, the first rumblings of dissent rippled through the House of Commons Thursday as veteran members of parliament from the ruling Labour Party and, remarkably, the opposition Tory Party joined ranks to question the NATO attack.
Opponents of the American and allied bombing were not just the “usual suspects” – left-wingers such as veteran Labour MP Tony Benn. Former establishment heavyweights from defence and foreign affairs departments were among those expressing their grave reservations.
Surprisingly the critics included Lord Carrington- the former Tory foreign secretary and onetime secretary general of NATO – former Tory defence minister Alan Clark and the former Labour Party defence chief Denis Healey.
“Many British servicemen regard the KLA (the rebel Kosovo Liberation Army, which supports the NATO attack) as a bunch of thugs deeply involved in the drug trade who are also operating various refugee operations into this country,” Clark told the lower house of parliament.
Lord Carrington, who resigned as Foreign Secretary over Britain’s invasion of the Falkland Islands and headed NATO from 1984-1988, told the upper house: “I think that the policy which has led us being where we are now is both mistaken and ill- conceived. I have the gravest misgivings on the course on which we are set.
“I don’t know where it’s going to end. I don’t know how it will end and I don’t know what the government will do if the bombing doesn’t achieve their aims.”
Dennis Healey, a World War II veteran who was Labour Defence Secretary from 1964-1970, went on television and radio to oppose the NATO attack.
“Serbia is recognised by the United Nations as a sovereign country,” he said. “Remember we are often criticised for what we do in Northern Ireland with the Irish Republican Army….
“It is a terrible error not to consult the UN over this. We made a mistake in acting so fast and in committing ourselves to a prolonged campaign, in which we have given total power of decision not to NATO governments, but to the NATO military commanders.”
Healey posed the question: “If you attack Yugoslavia over Kosovo, why don’t you attack Russia over Chechnya? Why don’t you attack Turkey for its war against the Kurds?”
Political analysts were quick to point out that, in contrast to the cross-party unanimity seen during the Gulf war, the action on Yugoslavia had deeply divided all shades of political opinion.
Opposition to the NATO attack appeared is total and political – not just along the lines of strategic opponents who argued that aerial bombing was useless without any ground attack.
The deep level of misgiving led several political commentators to even suggest that the British government would not have public approval for its involvement in the NATO attack – a mood likely to force Prime Minister Tony Blair into making a televised address to the country to justify the action.
Commentators also pointed to the irony of government ministers were one-time anti-war agitators supporting the NATO action while being condemned by those who saw action in World War II.
Elsewhere in Europe, other established figures had the same reservations.
In Lisbon, the former Portuguese President Mario Soares said, “We may not like Milosevic but, the fact is, he is a democratically-elected and internationally-recognised president and this conflict – I do not want to talk about a Third World War but about its unforeseeable consequences – is in the heart of Europe!”
He accused NATO of acting unilaterally. The 19-nation military pact, he said, “did not consult with the United Nations or Russia, breaking international law and order, which I consider extremely serious.”
Irish Foreign Minister David Andrews said “Our position is that we would have preferred a United Nations mandate but, in the circumstances, we cannot make any observation on that particular situation.”
Ireland, along with Finland and Austria, had called for a peaceful resolution to the crisis and have kept a neutral posture in the NATO-Yugoslavia conflict. In Spain, socialist MPs criticised their government for sending warplanes without consulting the parliament.
Political observers said the attack could also destabilise European governments and already the Italian PCDI party has warned that it will withdraw its three ministers from the government if Italy does not withdraw from the attack.
European MPs’ apparent sense of helplessness in the face of the NATO attack has been heightened by the fact that much of the the world-wide condemnations of the action has been played down in western media.
Angry protests by the governments of China, India and Indonesia – representing between them more than one-third of the world’s population – has gone virtually unreported in the most of the mainstream media, particularly television.