Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

TRADE-ENVIRONMENT: US Court Challenges WTO Ruling

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Apr 14 1999 (IPS) - The US Court of International Trade, has decided that attempts by the State Department to comply with rules set by the World Trade Organisation (WTO) violate US laws designed to protect endangered sea turtles from being caught and killed in shrimp nets.

The decision is likely to cause a stir in international trade circles since it calls into question whether the United States can comply with last year’s WTO ruling without first changing US law.

Earlier this year, environmental organisations, including the Sierra Club and the Sea Turtle Restoration Project, filed the suit against the State Department after it proposed new sea turtle protection guidelines in 1998 which the groups said were much weaker than previous regulations.

Environmentalists said the State Department violated national law by diluting its protection standards in response to the WTO ruling.

The law originally stated that all countries importing shrimp into the United States must use Turtle Excluder Devices (TEDs) that prevent sea turtles from getting caught in shrimp nets.

The new guidelines allow shrimps to be imported from nations that do not require the use of TEDs but the federal judge with the Court of International Trade agreed that the new proposals violated the original law.

“The court concludes that the part of the 1998 guidelines which constitutes the decision to permit the importation of…shrimp from uncertified nations, on its face, is not in accordance with (the law),” said the ruling released last week.

Environmentalists who have been following the trade issue closely for several months declared they had won a victory, not just for sea turtles but for domestic environmental protection laws in general.

“This legal victory establishes a strong precedent for the sovereignty of US laws of global trade bodies,” said Joshua Floum, attorney with California-based Legal Strategies Group which represented the environmental groups.

The US State Department has made no comment but is expected to appeal the ruling.

Without the use of turtle excluders devices, which cost between 75 and 200 dollars each, more than 150,000 turtles drown in shrimp nets worldwide each year, say environmental groups.

Six of the seven species of sea turtles in the world are on the US endangered species list, while all seven are covered under the UN Convention on Trade in Endangered Species of Flora and Fauna (CITES), which prohibits the trade of such species.

The original U.S. guidelines, established in 1996, required each country who wanted to import shrimp to the United States to establish national policies and practices requiring the use of Turtle Excluder Devices.

The WTO dispute panel ruled against the U.S. ban on imports after four countries said the requirement discriminated unfairly against them and violated the trade body’s rules.

Malaysia, Thailand, India and Pakistan fought the standards saying that they breach international law by imposing U.S. law on other countries. Thailand, which uses Turtle Excluder Devices, said it filed the case out of principle that the trade ban is not consistent with international trade rules.

In response, the State Department’s new proposed rules do not require foreign nations to establish regulations and allow individual shipments of shrimp from vessels claiming to use the devices to import to the United States.

Conservation organisations say that enforcing the use of Turtle Excluder Devices on a shipment-by-shipment basis is impossible. Earth Island Institute, the Sierra Club and other groups charged it would be easy to “launder” shrimp caught without the devices.

“How can enforcement on a shipment-by-shipment basis be accomplished?,” asks Peter Fugazzotto, associate director of the California-based Sea Turtle Restoration Project.

“If a vessel is approached at sea by enforcement personnel, how is that government agent to know if the vessel will claim the use of Turtle Excluder Devices two weeks later when it brings its shrimp to port?,” he says.

He adds that the previous guidelines gave other countries an economic incentive to pass regulations requiring the use of the devices and led to technical training programmes for shrimp fishers.

As a result of the U.S. import law, 16 countries, including all Central American countries and China, adopted domestic regulations requiring the use of Turtle Excluder Devices.

Environmentalists hope the court ruling will force the government to return to a “nation by nation” standard for the importation of wild shrimp into the United States. But, the ruling “calls into question exactly how the US will come into compliance with the WTO ruling,” says Fugazzotto.

“It’s possible, given their repeated failure in the courts, that the State Department will go to Congress and try to change the law, surrendering to the will of the WTO.”

Pointing to the growing public criticism of international economic trade agreements which led to the denial of Clinton’s “fast track” trade negotiating authority, Fugazzotto doubts that changing the law will receive much political support.

“I don’t think the US public will stomach that kind of attack on our laws,” he says.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags