Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Population | Analysis

DEVELOPMENT-MALAYSIA: 30 Years On, Ethnic Ties on Firmer Footing

Analysis - Anil Netto

PENANG, Malaysia, May 31 1999 (IPS) - Three decades after communal riots rocked the country, Malaysians can take comfort in the fact that ethnic relations in this multi-racial nation are on much firmer footing.

Although the country’s New Economic Policy that seeks to help boost the economic clout of ethnic Malays remains, recent trends indicate a greater ability by people to cross racial barriers.

Malaysia’s politics have often been divided along ethnic lines, but even this appears to be changing.

The September 1998 ouster and assault of deputy prime minister Anwar Ibrahim, now serving a jail term for corruption, changed the complexion of inter-ethnic relations. The episode left many Malaysian of all ethnic groups deeply disturbed.

Such sentiments made possible political alliances among groups that used to work separately, making opposition to the government of Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad weak.

The common platforms that the ethnic Chinese-led Democratic Action Party (DAP) and the Islamic PAS party have formed on justice and human rights — with keADILan, the party led by Anwar’s wife Dr Wan Azizah Wan Ismail bridging the yawning gap in ideology — has broken down many ethnic barriers.

Indeed, some say it has fuelled a new sense of what being Malaysian is all about.

Half of Malaysia’s 22 million people is Malay, 10 percent are indigenous groups, 30 percent ethnic Chinese and the remainder made up of Indians and other groups.

Still, the opposition DAP’s recent revival of its ‘Malaysian Malaysia’ vision and the government’s strong reaction against it highlight the opposing ideologies on a common “Malaysian identity”.

The controversy flared at about the same time a minister was sharply criticised for suggesting that Wan Azizah’s Chinese heritage made her unfit to lead the Malays, who dominate her new multi-ethnic keADILan or National Justice Party.

While this shows the touchiness of ethnic issues, it also the potential for change.

It is, after all, a long way from the 1969 communal riots that shook Kuala Lumpur and other urban areas in the aftermath of a closely contested general election fought on the emotional issues of education and language. Scores died in the May 13, 1969 riots.

In the 1960s, the Malays, who had weaker economic clout than other groups, viewed Chinese Malaysian gains in the 1969 general election as a threat.

Non-Malay politicians, for their part, appeared insensitive to Malay fears of being pushed to the margins of the mainstream economy and losing their political dominance.

The May 1969 riots left a deep scar in the collective psyche of Malaysians. Today, few want to talk about that fateful day, the memories perhaps too painful for the older generation even as those below 35 remain blissfully ignorant of it.

The only exception occurs during general election campaigns, when ruling coalition politicians routinely raise the spectre of May 13 to draw votes for ‘stability’.

Looking back though, three decades of impressive economic growth — and the ruling coalition’s realisation of the importance of non-Malay votes — have largely doused the flames of chauvinism and healed most of the wounds of May 13.

Today, ethnic Malays, Chinese, Indians and other indigenous groups live as neighbours and work side-by-side. “Our political environment has changed,” observes DAP deputy secretary-general Chong Eng. “It is not as racial.”

She says Malaysians of various races look at one other differently compared with the 1970s, and society is more able to discuss issues openly. Still, this change has not been easy.

After May 13, 1969, the Constitution was amended to forbid any party from raising ‘sensitive’ issues, such as the ‘special position’ of the ethnic Malays, the position of the Malay sultans, the status of Malay, the official language and Islam as the official religion, and the citizenship rights of non-Malays.

These amendments dimmed the DAP’s hopes of a ‘Malaysian Malaysia’ society in which Malaysians of all ethnic groups would have equal opportunities on a merit-based, level playing field.

In 1970, the government introduced the New Economic Policy (NEP) with affirmative action policies for the Malays. Special quotas, licences, and share allocations not only propelled many poor Malays into the middle class, but turned an elite group of already well-off Malays into millionaires.

For the first time, the terms “bumiputra” (literally ‘prince of the earth’, meaning indigenous) and “non-bumiputra” were coined.

That dichotomy and the NEP quotas in education and business triggered much silent resentment among non-Malays. Still, with nationalisation of industry, the Chinese Malaysian capitalist class increased their share of market capitalisation.

And, by the end of the NEP period, the government had moved to liberalise education and culture, placating non-Malay fears and even drawing their votes.

“Generally, society has become more open,” says Chong Eng. “And differences in culture and belief will enrich our national culture.”

The maintenance of a multi-cultural fabric is often called an achievement of the Mahathir government, under whose rule Malaysia underwent an economic boom that changed lives in less than a generation.

Analysts also contrast the Malaysian picture with that of its neighbour Indonesia, wracked by violence among different ethnic, religious and social groups.

Others attribute racial harmony here to Malaysians’ ‘live and let live’ attitude.

“While there might be some grievances over the special privileges of the Malays, there is no way anybody today will ever think of harming other Malaysians because of this,” says social reformer Jubal Lourdes. “Malaysians have grown to accept it.”

Attempts to forge a Malaysian identity have sometimes been thwarted by politicians who use communal issues to project themselves as champions of their politcal parties and to divert attention away from real issues.

But changes over the years are making the country’s ethnic groups more integrated than ever.

For instance, support for the government traditionally used to come mainly from the Malays while the opposition drew its support largely from the ranks of the non-Malays and Muslims who wanted an Islamic state.

But today, both sides of the political divide are more multi- ethnic than ever. This makes it harder for politicians to harp on communal issues — and just as well, activists say.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags