Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

POLITICS-UN: No Agreement on Special Session on Disarmament

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, May 13 1999 (IPS) - After four years of protracted negotiations, the United Nations failed to reach agreement this week on hosting a major UN conference on global disarmament.

The proposed Special Session on Disarmament (SSOD IV) – the fourth in a series – was expected to discuss several global security issues, including nuclear disarmament, nuclear non- proliferation, regional disarmament, conventional arms, weapons of mass destruction and the arms race in outer space.

The last three Special Sessions were held in 1978, 1982 and 1988. Although a declaration was adopted unanimously at the first session, the second and third sessions failed to reach agreement on a programme of action on global disarmament.

India, which initiated the idea of SSOD IV, made a dramatic 180-degree turn when it openly expressed strong reservations on the need for a Special Session.

“We asked for SSOD IV because we felt it would move the international community toward nuclear disarmament,” Indian Ambassador Savitri Kunadi told the Commission on Monday.

But last year, India had to test its own nuclear weapons, “impelled by a worsening security environment, marked by overt and covert deployment of nuclear weapons in our region,” she said. “Nevertheless, we continue to believe that global peace and security can only be ensured by universal nuclear disarmament.”

Making a strong case for total nuclear disarmament, Kunadi said that the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) had made it clear that its security depended on nuclear weapons and that they “preserve peace.”

In response, other nuclear weapon states also reaffirmed their intention of continuing with nuclear weapons in defence strategy.

She said that India believed that unless the primary objective of SSOD IV was to achieve nuclear disarmament – as spelt out in the principles and priorities adopted by consensus at SSOD 1 in 1978 – “there would be no point in having the session (SSOD IV).”

The UN Disarmament Commission entrusted with the task of seeking agreement on the conference agreed that, in the absence of consensus, the proposal would be temporarily shelved.

Since the Commission takes decisions only by consensus, a single dissenting voice can hold up any decision.

One Third World diplomat told IPS that “the tragedy of it all” was that India, which initiated the proposal, also was responsible for wrecking it.

He said India possibly would continue with its stand until it was formally recognised as a major nuclear power. “There is more to it than meets the eye,” the diplomat said.

US delegate Katharine Crittenberger told the Commission that although Washington questioned the value of a fourth special session on disarmament, it had accepted the notion of a special session because of a forward-looking meeting to elaborate an agenda for multilateral disarmament and arms control in the post Cold War era.

“In our view, the kind of SSOD IV sought by some countries – that is a meeting mired in the dregs of the past – would be of no value,” she said.

There would, of course, be some hope of doing so only if states displayed a willingness to compromise and limit their aspirations to the attainable. Unfortunately, such a willingness did not emerge, she added.

“In spite of four years of painstaking work, it is regrettable that consensus continued to elude the Disarmament Commission on the objectives and agenda for a fourth Special Session devoted to disarmament,” Crittenberger noted.

She said that under the present circumstances, an SSOD IV “would likely be a waste of time and effort because the same fundamental disagreements we have encountered over the past four years would only follow us to such a meeting.”

Until all UN member states are prepared to accept at least the possibility that the world of the future will require priorities adapted to that world, “SSOD IV would be of little value,” she said.

Rodolfo Benitez Verson of Cuba said his delegation “deeply lamented” the fact that after four years of intensive work, there was no consensus on the proposed Special Session. For the 114- member Non-Aligned Movement, the convening of that Session was a very important goal.

Jean Philip du Preez of South Africa said his country was “deeply disappointed” over the failure to reach consensus.

“The Special Session would have offered an opportunity to review the most critical aspects of disarmament, and to mobilise the international community and the public,” he said.

UN sources believed the Committee on Disarmament and International Security was expected to resurrect the debate at the next session of the General Assembly in September.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags