Friday, November 20, 2026
Mark Bourrie
- The healthiest people in the world are not found in countries of great wealth but in nations with the smallest economic gap between the rich and poor, according to a Canadian study.
The study by Monica Townson, a Toronto-based researcher, of the life expectancies and general health of people in developed countries found patterns connecting health with a lack of poverty and unemployment.
Townson’s research was underwritten by Canada’s ministry of health. Her book, “Health and Wealth: How Social and Economic Factors Affect Our Well Being,” has been published by the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives.
“We know that differences in health are linked to unemployment and poverty,” Townson said at a recent meeting with Canadian parliamentarians.
“But these influences alone don’t explain why the population of some countries is healthier than others. Why is life expectancy higher in countries like Greece, Japan, Iceland and Italy than it is in rich countries like the United States or Germany?
“There is now strong evidence that it is not the richest countries that have the best health, it’s the most egalitarian.”
Townson is an independent economic consultant working in the field of social policy. She has been a consultant to the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe and has advised Canadian governments on fair tax policy and pensions.
She pointed to the widening of the gap between rich and poor in Britain during the administration of former Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher as an example of health problems linked to inequality.
“As a result of Thatcher’s policies, in some areas of the country, people’s life expectancy dropped, which I think is pretty dramatic evidence that this is a key issue we need to think about,” she said.
“It’s evident that many of the socio-economic determinants of population health are closely inter-connected. Unemployment can result in poverty,” Townson writes. “Poverty may determine the type of housing family has; education levels may limit the earnings of individuals; early childhood development may limit a person’s educational opportunities.
“All these elements may explain why some individuals are healthy and others are not. But they do not explain why the population of some countries appears to be healthier than the population of others.
“Research on health inequalities within developed countries has increasingly focussed on the relationship of the individual to society: on how people are affected by social position; by wealth and poverty; by job insecurity and unemployment; by education; by social mobility; on the importance of social networks; on family disruption; on stress at work and the social organization of work…
“The evidence suggests that what matters within societies is not so much the direct health effects of absolute material living standards, so much as the effects of social relatives. The crucial evidence… comes from the discovery of a strong international relationship between income distribution and national mortality rates.”
She cites the Joseph Rowntree Foundation’s 1995 study of income and wealth in Britain, which found that inequalities in income started to rise after 1978-79.
It showed that the richest one-fifth of the British population increased their share of disposable income from 35 per cent in 1978 to 42 per cent in 1993. The share of the poorest one-fifth fell from 9.8 per cent to 7.6 per cent. Most of the growth in increase disparities took place among people of working age and their children.
Townson’s review of epidemiological literature found that mortality rates stopped their post-war decline in the people below the age of 44.
“As deprivation in some areas increased, mortality in some age groups in the poorest areas actually rose. In other age groups, they simply failed to fall,” she said.
“It is likely that similar processes affected mortality in the United States. As income differences widened during the 1980s, the rate at which the population’s life expectancy improved also slowed down. The national slow-down was associated particularly with a decline in life-expectancy among the black population.”
She also used the example of Canada’s indigenous people, whose life expectancy is seven years less than non-aboriginal Canadians. Income levels for Native Canadians is about half that of non- natives.
“It is evident that Canada has not yet adopted strategies for improving population health by addressing socio-economic conditions,” Townson said.
“About 1.5 million children, or 21 per cent of all Canada’s children, now live in low-income families – that’s 47 per cent more than in 1989.”
Townson’s study showed that the cuts to support programmes for the poor have fallen in most developed countries during the past decade, while social and economic systems increasingly were “entrenched and hard to challenge.”
She pointed to government cutbacks in unemployment insurance, welfare, and other entitlements that used to help narrow the gap between rich and poor in the United States, Canada and Britain.
“Canada, like many other countries that have adopted globalization and neo-conservatism, has moved from its social roots of collective responsibility toward a take-care-of-yourself attitude,” she said.
“Policy makers concerned about population health cannot make the problem of poverty go away by simply re-defining it or playing with numbers,” Townson concluded.
“Now, we’re seeing after-tax inequality rising, too, since many governments have stopped helping people, or have excluded poor people from programs by claiming there is no poverty issue,” she said.