Thursday, November 19, 2026
Johanna Son
- When offended by free-wheeling newspapers, government officials no longer lock up journalists or shut down their papers — they employ goons, or get their pals to take over ownership or pull out precious advertisement revenue.
This is what the worried media are saying in the Philippines and Thailand, which have the freest media in South-east Asia but are now facing stiff challenges to press freedom.
The two countries are now embroiled in their biggest cases of press freedom issues in recent years.
Philippine newspapers are now in a state of uncertainty, caught up in suspicions of hostile acquisitions by businessmen well- connected to President Joseph Estrada, and worried by a coordinated pullout of advertisements in a local newspaper in support of Estrada’s complaints about its coverage.
In Thailand, media circles are seeking the ouster for “media thuggery” of deputy prime minister Trairong Suwannakhiri, whose aides this month went to the ‘Thai Post’ offices and threatened the staff for running reports critical of Trairong.
These incidents signal “an unhealthy development which goes against the grain of civil societies”, said Kavi Chongkittavorn, chair of the South-east Asian Press Alliance (SEAPA) and editor of Thailand’s English-language daily ‘The Nation’.
“What happened in Thailand and the Philippines taught us that we, the press have to be vigilant,” he said in an interview. “Free press is not a given thing, we have to be constantly fightly for it.”
“If we lower our guard, the power wielders will jump on top of you,” remarked Chongkittavorn.
While the incidents in Thailand and the Philippines are different, they are linked to displeasure by the subjects, especially public officials, about coverage about them.
Trairong’s camp says the ‘Thai Post’ “insulted” the official by saying he had been afraid to meet protesting fishermen from the south. Reports said his men — which the ‘Post’ said were armed but which Trairong’s men deny — threatened to come back if the paper continued to insult Trairong.
In the Philippines’ case, Estrada had been complaining for some time about unfair, “malicious” coverage by some media.
Recent incidents seen as threats to media freedom have put him on the defensive, prompting him to say in a Monday speech to Congress: “Let all doubts be erased. Democracy, freedom and the Constitution are alive and well in this country.”
Still, developments in Philippine media “bear watching” due to fears they would lead to a “crony press’, says Melinda Quintos de Jesus of the Centre for Media Freedom and Responsibility.
Earlier this month, the ‘Philippine Daily Inquirer’ divulged that movie producers had stopped putting advertisements there as part of an agreement among them to show support for Estrada, who they felt the paper had been treating unfairly.
The producers said the move was “voluntary”, but not a few critics said it was done with support or endorsement by Estrada, himself a former movie actor.
Government financial institutions also reportedly stopped placing advertisements in the ‘Inquirer’, in what critics called a move to weaken the publication financially at a time when advertising is tapering off due to hard economic times.
Then in just a few weeks, the owners of the daily ‘Manila Times’ said they were selling the paper to a new group. Its last issue under the Gokongwei family’s ownership came out Jul 23.
But what should ordinarily be a business deal became a controversy after ‘Times’ editors said they suspected that the owners had been pressured into selling to investors that included a known friend and campaign contributor of Estrada, Mark Jimenez.
The ‘Times’, which had been losing money, had been vulnerable since it was sued by Estrada for 2.65 million U.S. dollars for saying he brokered a questionable contract with an Argentinian power firm.
The suit was dismissed after ‘Times’ owner Robina Gokongwei-Pe published a “personal apology” in April for the anguish caused by the article — after reports that the family’s sizable other business interests had come under pressure.
The new publisher denies that Jimenez is among the buyers, and presented real estate magnate Reghis Romero as the financier.
In a statement, ‘Times’ editor-in-chief Malou Mangahas described the move as “death by corporate strangulation” of an independent newspaper, or “privatised harassment and marginalisation of an independent press’.
“By all indications, the asset sale of ‘The Manila Times’ is a part of an insidious effort by this group, acting supposedly in the name and on behalf of the administration, to tame a critical press, through the backdoor,” Mangahas wrote.
While Estrada assured he would respect media freedom in his State of the Nation address Monday, he also lashed out at “those who make a career and a business out of hitting me”.
“I am not complaining that my administration is being criticised, for this is something that comes with the territory. But I question the ready bias, malice and fabrication,” he said over the weekend.
Estrada’s spokesman, Jerry Barican, said some newspapers were not into journalism but “constant heckling”, adding that wrong information in the press was equally “dangerous to a free press and democracy”.
“From the outside this looks like a case of a very powerful government intimidating media, but from inside this is a very powerful media intimidating the government,” he added.
But De Jesus says “the weaknesses of a free press are things we need to work with”, adding that parties must complain when they feel unfairly treated. “We have to learn to deal with these, and it is not easy.”
“But it is the retaliatory action (by the government) that has raised the alarm,” said De Jesus, adding that the Centre has seen faults in what some call the Inquirer’s “sensational” reporting.
For the media, the recent experiences of the Philippines and Thailand underscore how threats can come in new, varied forms. “You cannot fight the press head on. But indirectly, you can fight the press by taking away their ads. Another popular means is to sue for a ridiculous amount of money,” Chongkittavorn said.
While guarding against such threats though, newspapers must review their reportage and be willing to correct excesses, as one ‘Inquirer’ columnist conceded last week.
“Free press in South-east Asia must also mean a responsible press. The Philippine and Thai press have no problem with free press, but we have problems related to professionalism,” Chongkittavorn noted.