Friday, November 20, 2026
Mark Bourrie
- For the sixth year in a row, Canada has emerged at the top of the UN’s Human Development Index (HDI) in terms of life expectancy, educational attainment and adjusted real income – but not everyone is happy with this assessment.
Social activists say the good life here is limited to middle- class Canadians who are not affected by the growing gap between rich and poor.
And indigenous leaders say 800,000 native Canadians do not share in the country’s wealth or in the educational and social services that are admired by the authors of the 1999 Human Development Index, released last month.
The United Nations did issue caveats about Canada’s top spot, warning of the growing income gap and of the need to deal with aboriginal poverty and social issues.
The HDI was created by the United Nations in 1990 as a way to replace simple per capita income and Gross National Product calculations with a more wide-ranging measure of the well-being of countries.
“The real wealth of a nation is its people,” the first HDI report began. “And the purpose of development is to create an enabling environment for people to enjoy long, healthy and creative lives. The simple but powerful truth is too often forgotten in the pursuit of material and financial wealth.”
For Canada, the latest report “is an extraordinary accomplishment for all of us and we must take this result with great pride,” says the Minister of Human Resources, Pierre Pettigrew.
Canada is ranked 12th in the world in per capita income – 5,000 dollars below the United States and also trailing Switzerland, Kuwait and Brunei. But it has the highest literacy rate and the third-highest longevity rate (behind Iceland and Japan).
The UN says Canada spends its money well. Italy has a per capita income level similar to Canada’s, but ranks 19th on the HDI because its rate of education is 25 per cent lower than Canada’s.
A second UN ranking system is ignored by Canadian politicians, however, while it has been embraced by the country’s social activists.
The UN’s Human Poverty Index of 17 industrialized nations ranks Canada a mediocre 9th because 11.7 per cent (a conservative figure according to the activists) live below the poverty line.
Nine percent of Canadians die before they reach the age of 60, and one-sixth of the population is functionally illiterate. (Sweden tops the index, with 6.7 per cent of its population living below the poverty line. The U.S. has the most income inequality, with 19.1 per cent in poverty).
Critics of the HDI say that it really just measures the well- being of white, urban Canadians. Most of the poor, illiterate people who are prone to early death are aboriginals, who make up about 3 per cent of the population.
The country’s 600 native reserves, most of which are in wilderness areas or on marginal farmland, are dismal places where few people have jobs or access to post secondary education and decent health care.
In many native reserves, housing is in such short supply that two or three families often live in one small dwelling. Earlier this year, indigenous leaders in northern Manitoba produced a movie about substandard housing that showed people in a subarctic reserve living in a house that was partly made of sheets of plastic.
Life expectancy on Indian reserves is about 10 years below the national average. Many communities lack water or sewage lines, hospitals, and road links to the outside world.
In the cities, many of the homeless who live in parks and doorways are indigenous people who left the reserves to try to find work and ended up addicted to alcohol and drugs. The majority of the prostitutes in western Canadian cities are young native women, according to social workers .
“There are really two Canadas,” says Phil Fontaine, chief of the Assembly of First Nations. “There is the Canada of the urban middle class and the wealthy suburbs, and the Canada of native reserves, where First Nations people see little of the bounty of their own country.”
The average per capita income of the richest 20 percent of Canadians is seven times higher than the poorest 20 per cent – 32,110 dollars compared to 5,971 dollars.
“Go ahead, bask in the glory for about a minute,” comments David Ross, executive director of the Canadian Council on Social Development. “Then turn the page and see what the UN says about poverty in this country and then roll up your sleeves and do something about child poverty and homelessness and make this country number one for everyone, not just some people!”
The 1.4 million Canadian children living in poverty represents an increase of about 400,000 since 1989. That year, Canada’s lower house of parliament voted unanimously to eradicate child poverty by the year 2000.
“All we have done since then is to increase that poverty.” said Alexa McDonough, the leader of the country’s social democratic New Democratic Party.
Still, some observers believe Canada is a country that can’t lose: 30 million people in an area slightly smaller than China and Tibet, on a land mass rich in timber, metals, and oil.
Much of the country’s arable land isn’t even farmed but, despite its huge land mass and wealth of natural resources, Canada never has been able to solve the problem of regional disparity.
The financial wealth of the country is concentrated in the densely populated region on the Great Lakes, with Toronto at its hub. People living in the Atlantic coast region, especially in places that were dependent on the now-defunct fisheries, exist in dismal poverty.
In western Canada, people rely on industries such as mining, farming and forestry, which have been hard-hit by falling commodity prices and the recession in Asia. In Canada’s north, there are a few cities where there are good jobs in resource company offices and government agencies, but most settlements are native reserves.
The HDI also reveals a “glass ceiling” when it comes to opportunities for women in Canada. This country ranks number one in women’s accessibility to education and health care, but only fourth in creating economic opportunities for women.
Pettigrew says Canada’s problems are not being ignored by the government.
“We’re working very hard to eliminate child poverty,” he says. “There’s a lot more to be done.
“As a society, we must ensure that we do more to eradicate poverty in this country… Our government (which recently balanced its books) now has the margin to manoeuvre fiscally to address social problems.”