Economy & Trade, Environment, Headlines, North America

FINANCE-ENVIRONMENT: Gold Debate Highlights Tarnished Industry

Abid Aslam

WASHINGTON, Aug 15 1999 (IPS) - Gold industry opposition to a proposed sale of International Monetary Fund (IMF) reserves has obscured anguished voices of communities who say that, even at its best, the precious metal is a mixed blessing.

The IMF wants to sell some bullion, invest the proceeds, and use the resulting income to fund low-interest loans for economic restructuring in the poorest countries. Central banks, most recently Britain’s, have been trimming their idle gold stocks since the 1960s in favour of more active investments.

The business-based World Gold Council, governments and labour unions in mining-dependent countries such as South Africa, however, oppose open-market sales. They say that by driving down prices, corporate profits suffer along with national foreign exchange earnings, and miners’ jobs.

But for community activists, the sales provide an alternative to mining in meeting demand for gold and therefore could be turned into opportunities for economic and ecological conversion – if handled carefully.

“In particular, there must be just transitions for workers who lose their jobs and livelihoods whenever gold mines close,” say representatives of groups from 21 countries and numerous indigenous communities.

“Companies have a duty and mandatory obligation for social, environmental and economic rehabilitation of the community and the miners,” according to a declaration by the activists at a ‘Peoples Gold Summit’ in June

“Large-scale gold mining violently uproots and destroys the spiritual, cultural, political, social and economic lives of peoples as well as entire ecosystems,” the activists say. ” Historic and current destruction (from) gold mining is greater than any value generated.”

The activists make the point that most devastation has been wreaked on indigenous lands. Communities in the Amazon basin are beset with the toxic legacy of the region’s gold rush, which began in the 1970s, says analyst Eric Taylor in a report for Project Underground, the US-based global mining watchdog.

Gold has come to represent nearly one-fifth of the region’s economic output and has made major producers of Brazil and Venezuela, Taylor notes.

The Yanomami people of Brazil have been among those to pay a heavy price in lives and land lost to the miners. Before the boom, the Yanomami had little contact with the outside world and other tribes had none.

As a result, they were vulnerable to measles, new strains of malaria and other ailments common among the miners. Many more died in massacres – some backed by the government – according to local and international relief groups and scholars.

The miners themselves were poor folk from as far away as coastal Colombia and the Dominican Republic. “An essential component of mining is hope, and often the people who come to seek the gold come from places where there is no hope,” says Taylor.

The environmental group Greenpeace says that, in the past 10 years, miners have dumped up to 2,000 tons of mercury in the Amazon basin. Indigenous communities have had to cope with the ravages of Minamata disease – named after Japan’s Minamata Bay, where an estimated 1,800 people died in 1940-60 from eating fish contaminated with the heavy metal, which is used in gold extraction.

Pollution, disease, and land-rights violations also have been headline-making hallmarks of mining operations from the US Pacific Northwest to Guyana, Papua New Guinea and the Philippines.

Australia’s Broken Hill Proprietary company (BHP), majority shareholder and operator of the OK Tedi gold and copper mine in Papua New Guinea, last week received damning independent environmental reports confirming local complaints of widespread pollution and river contamination.

BHP now is considering withdrawing from the mine, a step that economists say would imperil recovery plans of the cash-strapped new government in Port Moresby. OK Tedi is one of the country’s largest export earners and churns out 10 percent of annual economic output.

Gold generates nearly one-fifth of foreign exchange earnings and about half of all mining jobs in South Africa, the world’s largest producer. “Urbanised black South Africans have also benefitted from the wealth produced,” says Devan Pillay, research chief at the National Union of Mineworkers (NUM).

“Nevertheless, it is also true that many black South Africans have not benefitted from the mining – in particular the mineworkers themselves and the rural communities they came from,” Pillay adds.

“For every ton of gold mined over the last century, a worker has died underground and over one million have been injured or maimed,” he notes.

Millions more have succumbed to illness. “Most of these people were diagnosed with these diseases after they had left the mines, resulting in little or no compensation,” according to Pillay.

“The burden of looking after them until they died thus fell on their families in the rural areas,” which in the meanwhile had suffered social and cultural upheaval under the apartheid migrant labour system.

Adding insult to injury, mine companies used weak gold prices to lay off workers – only to be caught in a lie.

In January 1998, one mining company announced it would cut 5,000 workers because the price of gold had fallen to 289 dollars per ounce the previous year. The NUM later found that the firm had sold its gold at 320 dollars per ounce on the futures market – before it had even been mined.

Weak prices have played a part in lay-offs over the past two years, Pillay acknowledges, but “it is notable that when the rand (or local currency) price of gold increased significantly last year, as a result of currency depreciation, the lay-offs did not stop.”

Gold prices picked up slightly this week on signs of recovery in East Asian markets and expectations that the IMF will not be able to sell up to 300 tons, or 10 percent of its holdings, over objections from the US Congress and gold-producing nations.

All the same, South Africa faces inevitable long-term adjustments. “There are approximately 30-50 years’ worth of mineable gold reserves left in South Africa” and the country needs this time “to manage the downscaling of gold mining (and) stimulate activity in other sectors,” says Pillay.

While mining has brought “untold suffering and misery to black people, its sudden demise today will bring even more suffering.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags