Thursday, November 19, 2026
Wesley Gibbings
- The spectre of ethnic conflict has been rearing its head ominously even as the country marks its anniversary of political independence, prompting one social scientist to speak of “cultural tea cup wars” and the threat of “other kinds of wars”.
On Tuesday, Trinidad and Tobago celebrated 37 years as the second Commonwealth Caribbean state after Jamaica to achieve independence from Britain following the breakup of the West Indies Federation in 1962.
At immediate issue is the controversial appointment of a Director of Culture in the Ministry of Culture, but the pronouncements of Hindu activists have suggested that the problem goes deeper than the filling of a public service vacancy.
“The UNC (United National Congress),” writes Hindu extremist Kamal Persad, “is fundamentally pursuing the PNM (Peoples National Movement) cultural policy which then was black patronage.”
The statement coincides with the appointment of renowned sitarist, Mangal Patassar, as acting Director of Culture replacing calypsonian Hollis Liverpool who retired from the public service a month ago.
Though subsequently refuted by Liverpool – known in the calypso arena as The Mighty Chalkdust – it had been claimed by one Hindu group that attempts were made to block Patassar’s appointment on account of his being Indian.
Such speculation gained currency last week with a statement from the Sanatan Dharma Maha Sabha that the delay in appointing Patassar was linked to its belief that the Ministry of Culture was designed to exclusively promote Afro-Trinidadian culture.
“Indian culture is slighted by the Ministry on a variety of levels,” Maha Sabha General Secretary Satnarayan Maharaj said.
The organisation has targeted Culture Minister Daphne Phillips, one of five African members of the Indian-dominated Cabinet of Prime Minister Basdeo Panday.
The ruling UNC receives its political support from Indo- Trinidadians while the PNM has traditionally attracted support mainly from Afro-Trinidadians.
Indo-Trinidadians comprise 40.3 percent of the population while Afro-Trinidadians make up 39.6 percent.
“State discrimination against Trinidadian-Indian culture has been a contentious issue over the years and can contribute to the defeat of the UNC in the general elections of 2000 should its ethnic base become alienated,” Persad said.
It is an issue that has not gone unnoticed by the UNC which, in its Independence Day message spoke of the country’s “diversity” which “at times … seems to threaten our stability”.
“Trinidad and Tobago stands above many nations of the world that have managed diversity in an enviable manner,” the party said. “We perhaps can afford to now lend this expertise to peoples of many countries now torn by civil conflict.”
Strikingly similar comments came from the PNM which, in its Independence message, said “As a nation varied by ethnic, cultural and religious diversity, we have stood as a beacon in a world plagued by conflict and rivalry.”
But social scientist, Selwyn Ryan, argued the “expertise” spoke of by the UNC can play a role in resolving some of the country’s own problems.
“Can it now be said that a national identity and reciprocal trust between the major communities have since (independence) been forged, or are we further away from that goal?” he asked.
“Much of what is currently being identified as being Indian, Hindu or African culture or identity in Trinidad and Tobago is in fact little more than half-forgotten collective memories or myths manufactured or resuscitated by political and cultural warriors and entrepreneurs who are seeking to use them to augment their stock of political, social or economic capital,” he said.
“Instead of seeking to recapture ancient cultures or roam the globe searching for lost identities, we should all behave like a real born Trinidadian,” he argued.
“Whatever might have obtained on the eve of independence in August 1962, we are now all creoles even though we do not all refer to ourselves as such,” Ryan said.
“The question that we ask on this the eve of the 37th anniversary of our independence is where the cultural tea cup wars that are being waged with sound and fury will transform themselves into other kinds of wars, or whether they would be transcended by a post-creole or neo-creole reality which is inclusive rather than exclusive,” Ryan said Monday.
For the moment, the public debate has hardly reached that level. Persad, like the Maha Sabha, has been counting budgetary allocations to Indian cultural events by the Ministry of Culture and has argued that by excluding “Creole Carnival culture”, the figures provided by the Ministry in its own defence would have been “not only false but distorted”.
One newspaper report Sunday seemed to suggest such a debate remained active even within the government with news that Cabinet had over-ridden the Culture Minister’s decision to have Patassar appointed de facto to his post without having the substantive designation of Director of Culture assigned to him.
Phillips herself appeared on one Indian radio station call-in programme to explain how her Ministry allocates funds to the various cultural activities.
Not entirely impressed, Persad said: “The UNC administration is fundamentally pursuing the PNM cultural policy which then was black patronage, but under the UNC must be viewed as black appeasement.”
Wesley Gibbings
- The spectre of ethnic conflict has been rearing its head ominously even as the country marks its anniversary of political independence, prompting one social scientist to speak of “cultural tea cup wars” and the threat of “other kinds of wars”.
(more…)
Wesley Gibbings
- The spectre of ethnic conflict has been rearing its head ominously even as the country marks its anniversary of political independence, prompting one social scientist to speak of “cultural tea cup wars” and the threat of “other kinds of wars”.
(more…)