Europe, Headlines | Analysis

RIGHTS-RUSSIA: Ploys and Daghestan Violence Threaten Democracy

Analysis - Sergei Blagov

MOSCOW, Aug 13 1999 (IPS) - Were it not for the announcement Friday of a massive military offensive against Islamic rebels in Daghestan, Moscow’s byzantine political manoeuvres – including countless government reshuffles – could be regarded as a form of entertainment.

However, coupled with the serious outbreak of violence in Russia’s volatile north Caucasus region, the hopeless instability of the Russian government could become an ominous sign for the country’s nascent democratic institutions and worsen the situation of social and political rights.

“Russia’s military debacle in Chechnya effectively put an end to hopes of reviving the country’s imperial pride,” Georgi Derlugian, associate professor of sociology at North-Western University in Chicago, told IPS.

“Now – on the eve of crucial parliament and presidential elections – the crisis in the north Caucasus region could have barely predictable repercussions for Russian politics,” argues Derlugian, who authored a book on Russia’s disastrous 1994-96 war with Chechnya.

President Boris Yeltsin has declared – as he did few years earlier, on the eve of Chechen war – that he was confident that Russian forces would defeat Chechen-backed Islamic rebels in Daghestan, in line with allegedly preexisted presidential plans.

However, these days few Russians are confident of the planning abilities of their president.

Russian jets, helicopters and artillery already operating in Daghestan were reinforced Friday, while the separatists, led by the notorious Chechen warlord Shamil Basayev claim to be achieving easy victories in the Botlikh region, near the border with Chechnya.

In spite of hundreds of sorties flown and interim prime minister Vladimir Putin’s tough words, the end of the rebellion seems long way off. Daghestan, made up of more than 30 nations and ethnic groups in the Caucasus mountains and steppes along the Caspian Sea, has been the scene of increasing border violence with Chechnya in recent months.

Some 1,200 rebels infiltrated recently into Daghestan from Chechnya, which has enjoyed a de facto independence since the end of the war in 1996.

Representatives of a body called the Islamic Shura, or council, of Daghestan appeared in the Chechen capital Grozny and declared their country an independent Islamic state.

They called on Chechens to support the Muslims of Daghestan in their “struggle against unbelievers for the liberation of the Islamic state of Daghestan from occupation.”

The rebels are understood to belong to the fundamentalist Wahhabi movement, but they are yet to gather significant support among Daghestanis, whose political and religious elite now seems to be cooperating with the Russians and has been recruiting volunteers to fight the rebels.

Russian officials have blamed unnamed foreign powers of backing the rebels. News reports in Moscow say that “several hundred” Pakistani and Saudi fighters are participating in the conflict. The Chechen Wahhabis are understood to maintain ties with Saudi Arabia and probably with the Taleban regime in Afghanistan.

Basayev has confirmed his role in the rebellion. He is considered a war hero by many Chechens, but is also wanted on terrorist charges in Russia, as the leader of a hostage-taking raid on a hospital in the Russian town of Budyonnovsk, where some 100 civilians were killed.

Russia has sent a letter to Chechen president Aslan Maskhadov urging him to crack down on the rebels operating out of Chechnya, but the president denied any Chechen link with the fighting.

Maskhadov has also claimed that the reported invasion from Chechnya’ is being simulated to deceive the Russian and international community.

No big wonder that former Russian prime minister Sergei Stepashin conceded Sunday that Russia risked losing Daghestan – which is considered one of the reasons why Yeltsin sacked him on August 9.

Communist party leader Gennady Zyuganov has said Yeltsin’s decision to change premiers in the middle of the Daghestan crisis would only make matters worse.

But while some linked Stepashin’s dismissal to a standoff in the Caucasus, which he was supposed to defuse, others said he had failed to assert himself in the formation of rival political blocs ahead of the December 19 parliamentary election.

An opposition bloc led by Moscow’s mayor Yuri Luzhkov has convinced former prime minister and veteran diplomat Yvegueny Primakov – the country’s most popular politician -to become Presidential candidate in a bid that Yeltsin-Putin cannot possibly beat, according to all opinion polls.

Observers speculated here that 47-year-old Stepashin may be considering a presidential bid himself, representing the right-wing parties, to run against Primakov and -if and when he stays in the public light until then – current prime minister Vladimir Putin, Yeltsin’s official heir.

Unlike Stepashin, prime minister Putin has decided to act and talk tough and promised that Daghestan’s rebels would be crushed within two weeks.

Putin, who headed the Federal Security Service (FSB) – KGB’s main successor agency – has a low political profile and is regarded as close to Anatoly Chubais, the architect of Russia’s controversial privatisation program.

Chubais, in turn, has close links with Yeltsin’s inner circle, popularly known as “The Family.”

Nobody was particularly surprised that President Yeltsin chose a former KGB operative to be prime minister in his latest government shakeup. Many Russian tsars and leaders have relied on the secret police – Stepashin also was a former FSB boss.

The real surprise came when Yeltsin declared that Putin was also his choice to succeed him as President next year, to guarantee reforms into the next century.

Turning low-profile Putin into a viable presidential candidate is understood to be a real hard sell. These days Yeltsin’s recommendation is the worst possible advertisement for any candidate – and even a brief and victorious war in Daghestan is unlikely to make him popular enough to be elected, analysts agree.

However, it is understood that a long and inconclusive war – in Daghestan or Chechnya – can be used as a pretext to declare the state of emergency and thus cancel both parliamentary and presidential elections (due in December 1999 and mid-2000, respectively).

By law, Yeltsin must step down next year. But in that scenario Yeltsin – and “The Family”- have some chances to prolong their political life, postponing strategic decisions urgently needed in a country dealing with disintegration.

The Daghestan fighting seems to be the biggest domestic challenge to the Kremlin since the war with Chechnya, said Derlugian. “If Daghestan goes, that could mean faster involution or downsizing of Russian statehood.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags