Friday, November 20, 2026
Abid Aslam
- Four leading US clothing companies have settled legal suits against them rather than stand trial for alleged sweatshop conditions on Saipan, touching off muted victory celebrations among US labour rights groups.
Under settlements announced Monday, Nordstrom, J. Crew, Cutter and Bock and Gymboree will require independent monitoring of labour conditions at Saipan-based contractors assembling apparel for the US-based retail chains.
The firms deny allegations of complicity in and knowledge of labour abuses on the island. Nevertheless, under the settlement, they are providing some 1.25 million dollars to finance the independent monitoring programme.
That sum also will cover partial damages to past and current workers whose wages, overtime earnings, and compensation for work- related injuries have been withheld. Additionally, a portion will be spent on public education and attorneys’ fees although he exact division of the money will be divided remains to be worked out.
Al Meyerhoff, lead attorney for the workers and US-based labour rights groups who were plaintiffs in the cases, hopes more companies will agree to join the settlement and add to the pot.
Otherwise, firms will face prosecution under two lawsuits filed in January against 17 retailers. The Gap, Tommy Hilfiger, and Wal- Mart are among leading US firms choosing not to settle.
“This is far from over,” Meyerhoff says. “This is round one.”
The first of the two lawsuits, filed in a Los Angeles federal court on behalf of 50,000 current and former workers from China, the Philippines, Bangladesh and Thailand, is a class action alleging breaches of US and international indentured-servitude laws.
The second case, filed in San Francisco Superior Court, is a suit charging, among other things, that the defendants have profited from unfair business practices.
The federal courts must decide whether to proceed with trials and where to hold them while spokesmen for the defendants, asserting their companies’ innocence have declined to comment on active litigation.
However, The Gap says in a recent statement that it “does not tolerate this type of conduct in the factories where (its subcontractors) do business.” Similarly, Wal-Mart, the largest US retail chain, claims that it has a “zero-tolerance position with regard to illegal or unethical working conditions” in Saipan.
The firms have sought to move the hearings from California, where they were filed in federal court, to Saipan. Critics claim this is an attempt to avoid media coverage. Possible alternative venues include Hawaii.
Saipan is the capital of the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands, a US territory in the Pacific. Apparel assembly is a mainstay of the local economy, which has been exempt from mainland minimum-wage and workplace-safety requirements as well as US import quotas and tariffs.
The territory’s apparel industry generates about one billion dollars per year in export earnings. The Commonwealth government raises nearly one-fourth of its operating budget from garment taxes and the industry provides the Commonwealth Ports Authority with 53 percent of its revenues, according to official and media reports.
But the industry has come in for a hammering from local and international rights groups as a magnet for sweatshops and international labour trafficking schemes, which involve sex workers as well as migrant garment and construction employees.
In addition, apparel manufacturers have complained that Saipan’s territorial status enables even factories owned and operated by Asian companies to label their products as ‘Made in the USA’ and to ship these to the United States free of duty and quotas.
Saipan firms thus are able to avoid paying 200 million dollars per year in tariffs, according to the U.S. Department of the Interior, which oversees the territory.
Commonwealth officials, however, say that because they use the US dollar, they face increased competition from Asian manufacturers whose currencies have fallen in value since 1997, effectively driving down their prices.
Commonwealth residents enjoy all privileges of US citizenship except the right to vote in federal elections. In addition to the minimum wage, they are entitled to Social Security, unemployment benefits, and workers’ compensation for job-related injuries.
Migrant workers, who are not covered by these protections, outnumber locals two-to-one. “About 16 percent of local U.S. citizens, however, are unemployed,” according to a recent report by the US-based Global Survival Network.
Migrant workers in Saipan have complained that they work 12- hour days and seven-day weeks without receiving overtime pay; that they have been confined to living in barracks; and that they are summarily deported or fired if they question working conditions.
Workers who file grievances with Commonwealth authorities can win ‘administrative orders’ confirming their right to thousands of dollars in unpaid wages or compensation for injuries but the judgments lack practical force, say labour-rights campaigners.
When employers are pressured to pay up, they simply declare bankruptcy or flee the territory, according to the report, which cited official documents and media accounts.
Also, Saipanese manufacturers have been hit by more than 1,000 citations over the past five years by the US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), for providing substandard living conditions. Yet workers claim that OSHA inspectors have frequently been barred from conducting their work on the island.
All that could change, said Lora Jo Foo, president of the non- governmental Sweatshop Watch. Monday’s agreement, “establishes a monitoring programme with teeth. It will make an important difference in the lives of thousands of Saipan garment workers.”
Monitoring of compliance with labour standards will be done by ‘Verite’, a Massachusetts-based non-profit firm with experience running similar programmes in Central America and China, said Meyerhoff.
The settlements give Verite powers to oversee contractors’ conduct, conduct surprise inspections of their factories, and investigate workers’ complaints.
The company also will be able to ‘cure’ violations by demanding payment of back wages, among other steps. The company has yet to announce when it will start operations; its executives were unavailable for immediate comment.
Four companies who were to be added to the lawsuits also have indicated they will join the settlement, according to Meyerhoff. These include Ralph Lauren, Philips Van Heusen, Donna Karan and Cadwicks of Boston.
Saipan contractors affected by the settlement include Global Manufacturing, Diovra Sapian, Concorde Garment Manufacturing and Jin Apparel, according to a statement by rights groups.