Development & Aid, Headlines, North America

SOCIETY-US: Some Americans Still Favour Segregation

Leslie Goffe

NEW YORK, Aug 23 1999 (IPS) - Half of a group of young adults of all ethnic backgrounds, polled in a survey in New York, approved of racial segregation – provided there was equal opportunity for all.

The “Racial Attitudes Poll of Young Americans”, conducted by the firm Zogby International for New York’s Hamilton College, found that a small majority of black, white and Hispanic young people between the age of 18-29 years would be comfortable living in a racially-segregated United States.

Of the 1000 people polled, 50.3 per cent agreed with the statement that: “it is OK if the races are basically separate from one another as long as everyone has equal opportunity.”

Only a relatively low 60 per cent of those questioned felt the federal government should ensure that black and white children go to the same schools, and more than 90 per cent admitted to telling racist jokes on occasion.

Asked whether racial relations had stayed the same or were getting worse, only 22 per cent thought relations were good to excellent, while 57.9 per cent thought relations were fair, and 19.4 per cent said relations were poor.

Researchers deemed the survey significant because it gauged the views of the first generation of Americans born after the civil rights struggles of the 1960’s. This generation was the first to be born in a United States that had no formal racial barriers in education, housing and in the workplace.

“This indicates that many young Americans are comfortable with the notion of a segregated society” explained Philip Klinker, director of the Arthur Levitt Public Affairs Center at Hamilton College, the New York school that commissioned the survey.

“This is a cause for concern since many school districts are dismantling their integration efforts at a time when new data shows high levels of school segregation.”

The survey did contain better news, however:

More than 56 per cent of the young adults polled said the federal government should make sure that black people receive fair treatment in jobs and more than 57 per cent agreed that generations of slavery and discrimination had created conditions that make it difficult for blacks to work their way out of the lower class.

But 54 per cent said it was unlikely that the United States would elect a black President in the near future and by small but consistent margins respondents admitted they were less likely to describe blacks as equally intelligent, peaceful and hardworking as whites.

Hilary Shelton, director of the Washington DC branch of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, NAACP, described the survey as both an indicator and a challenge.

“It gives us great hope as we look at the increased number that support equal opportunity” she said. “But there is an increased need to strengthen and renew our support of many programs that help guarantee equal opportunity such as affirmative action.”

But not all black political leaders appeared troubled by the survey, or dismayed as to what it might suggest about integration.

Niger Innis, a director of the New York-based Congress for Racial Equality (CORE) said that in many ways blacks had lost more through integration than they gained.

“As horrific as certain aspects of segregation were for blacks, there were other aspects,” he declared. “There were the thriving all-Negro baseball leagues, the many black businesses that were supported by blacks, black restaurants, black hotels.

“The fact is, there was a thriving black capitalism that was alive and well, even during segregation. It has since dissipated and we have to be honest about these things.”

Christian pastor, Ronald King, who at just 28 years old is representative of the age group in the survey, also would not mind “a kind of segregation.” Although it is controversial to say so, he “wouldn’t mind if a separate, but truly equal America could be created.”

“Segregation seems to be a better avenue for us in that we understand each other better than the white man does,” King said. “It seems kind of crazy but that is how it is, even after all the bloodshed to get integration, I think maybe segregation is a better thing.

“I don’t mind saying ‘hello” to them (whites) everyone once in a while, but that’s all I want to say…”

This view, however, is not shared by other African Americans.

New York City college student, Keith Weathers, 26, said that ending racial barriers in housing, the workplace, and especially in education gave him real hope for the future.

“I am surprised and amazed by this poll” Weathers said.

“I think the idea of segregation again is ridiculous. Who’s to say if you go back to a segregated society that everything really would be equal? I just can’t see that happening.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags