Environment, Headlines, North America

FINANCE-ENVIRONMENT: Bankers Smell Profit in Pollution

Abid Aslam

WASHINGTON, Sep 15 1999 (IPS) - Carbon dioxide is odorless but it smells like money to bankers hustling an emerging market in “greenhouse gases.”

Carbon dioxide and other gases are released mainly when fossil fuels such as coal and oil are burned. Most scientists blame them for raising atmospheric temperatures, with far- reaching consequences for climate, health, and economic activity.

‘Emissions trading’ is permitted under the 1997 ‘Kyoto Protocol’ on climate change. Signatories have put off deciding the size and rules of the new commerce until next year but potential market players already are gearing up for a multi-billion-dollar market.

The idea is that firms can reduce carbon emissions by pursuing greater energy efficiency, using ‘clean production’ technologies and building or investing in clean production and renewable energy projects – say, solar power plants – or forest preserves.

These would result in ‘carbon offsets’ which could be certified and converted into corresponding ‘credits’ – or licenses to spew equivalent amounts of carbon.

The World Bank, which will open its ‘Prototype Carbon Fund’ to investors in November, estimates that trading could reach 150 billion dollars per year by 2020. The Sydney Futures Exchange plans to begin trading emissions next year and expects five billion dollars in business during the first year.

The Australian exchange’s preliminary estimates suggest that trading volume eventually could reach 700 billion dollars, says Amy Clarke, financial services advisor to the Ernst and Young Environment Group in London.

Depending on the rules decided by governments and the pace at which technologies become more eco-friendly, the market for carbon emissions eventually could evaporate. By then, however, financiers expect to move on to trading in waste water and other pollutants.

“The market will last as long as we emit,” Clarke says. “But if the greenhouse gas market wanes, it likely will be superceded by other markets.”

Emissions trading remains controversial among environmentalists but financial analysts see a potential bonanza for banks, investment houses, and accounting firms.

“Technical measures to reduce greenhouse gas emissions usually require investments. This can lead to an increasing demand for loans by companies and subsequently to new business opportunities for banks,” says Heinrich Hugenschmidt of the Union Bank of Switzerland.

“Investment banks already active in commodities and securities trading could expand their services towards trading and brokerage of emission credits,” charging commissions for their services, Hugenschmidt adds.

Banks also could set up diversified investment funds to spread the risks of financing individual carbon-reducing projects. These schemes would operate like existin g mutual funds, through which investors buy the stocks and bonds of a large number of companies rather than tying themselves to the fortunes of only one or two firms.

In addition, accounting and consulting firms stand to gain from a surge in demand for ‘green’ audits, advice on environmental strategy and verification of carbon reductions, says Clarke, of Ernst and Young.

The world can afford to keep burning fossil fuels at the current rate – releasing six billion tonnes of carbon per year – for less than 40 years before courting major ecosystem damage, warns Matthew Spencer, climate and energy campaigner with Greenpeace UK.

Given the high stakes involved, many environmentalists favour direct state intervention to promote renewable energy and curb fossil fuel use and exploration.

Ideas include taxing – or at least withdrawing public subsidies from – activities that contribute to global warming. In the United States alone, such state aid to business and industry amounts to 21-36 billion dollars per year, according to the Alliance to Save Energy, a watchdog group.

Alternatively, revenue from an international currency- transactions tax – designed to stabilise financial markets by dampening speculation – could be used to fund the transition from fossil to renewable energy, ‘greens’ argue.

With currency trading estimated at 1.3 trillion dollars per day, a tax of 0.25 percent would yield 150-200 billion dollars annually.

Interventions against ‘market forces’ do not sit well in business and policy-making circles, however, hence the push for ‘market-based’ schemes, Spencer notes.

Demands for a global carbon market have been accommodated “to ensure and maintain participation in the Kyoto negotiations of the United States – the largest single emitter of greenhouse gases – as well as Canada, Japan, Australia and New Zealand,” says Charlie Kronick, director of Britain’s Climate Action Network.

“Perhaps the most important feature of (such) flexible mechanisms is the ability to provide overall cost savings to the developed countries that use them,” Kronick adds.

Financial and environmental analysts alike describe emissions trading as a “low-pain option” for those industrialised countries and companies unable or unwilling to commit to carbon reductions in the short term.

While market players seek to exploit the resulting business opportunities, however, Kronick warns that “emissions that are avoided (can simply) be traded back into the atmosphere, with no actual emission reduction taking place.”

Ironically, say environmentalists, the United States has yet to ratify the Kyoto agreement, arguing that it should require tougher action by key developing countries including China, India and Mexico.

While that dispute runs its course, firms in ‘high-risk’ industries such as energy can boost their political influence and ‘social capital’ by being seen to act voluntarily in advance of any new government regulations, says Rebecca Seiler of EcoSecurities Ltd.

This could be done by striving for energy efficiency in existing operations or by lining up new projects – such as wind farms, dams, even nuclear power plants – in regions best positioned to enter the carbon market as exporters of cheap emissions ‘credits’.

These include the Amazon, Central and Latin America, Eastern Europe and Indonesia, according to Seiler.

Goods-producing companies “can shape the carbon-reductions process, with the money guys setting the norms for the carbon market,” says an executive from a US-based investment house.

“Government agencies are now trying to define ‘verification’, ‘certification’, and other key terms. Financial companies must influence the process,” he stresses.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags