Headlines, North America

FINANCE: US Debt Proposals Off Target

Abid Aslam

WASHINGTON, Sep 23 1999 (IPS) - The US government wants Congress to triple debt relief for the world’s poorest countries but the move will have little impact unless properly directed, critics say.

The administration of President Bill Clinton says it wants to commit around one billion dollars to debt relief – more than tripling its budget allocation for the fiscal year starting Oct. 1.

The funding request coincides this week with the arrival in Washington of finance ministers from around the globe for the annual meetings of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and World Bank.

“It is essential moral policy to write off debts to nations in significant parts of the world where a child is more likely to die by the age of five than attend secondary school,” says US Treasury Secretary Lawrence Summers.

His department – the US equivalent of a finance ministry – estimates that, if other creditors meet goals agreed by the ‘Group of Seven’ (G-7) economic powers, the poorest countries’ current debt of 127 billion dollars will be cut to 37 billion dollars.

As details of the funding plan become known, however, they belie the administration’s show of US ‘leadership’ on the debt issue, says Jeffrey Sachs, director of the Centre for International Development at Harvard University.

“Too much of the money is devoted to multilateral institutions and too little to cancelling our claims against these countries,” says Sachs.

The White House proposes spending 330 million dollars to offset the cost of writing down debts owed directly to the United States, contributing a further 650 million dollars to the IMF-World Bank debt initiative for 42 ‘Heavily Indebted Poor Countries’ (HIPCs).

Smaller amounts will go to helping the ‘Paris Club’ of government creditors and to a previously-agreed arrangement to swap debts for tropical forest preservation projects.

“Bilateral debt is the fundamental starting point,” Sachs insists. It is the biggest chunk and “the easiest to solve, if countries are willing to take bold steps.”

The 42 HIPCs owe 100 billion dollars to bilateral creditors and Sachs wants it all stricken off, along with eight billion dollars owed to the IMF.

In addition, he says, reductions should be sought for the countries’ debts of 36 billion dollars at the World Bank, 20 billion dollars with regional lenders – such as the African, Asian and Inter-American Development Banks – and another 20 billion dollars with private finance institutions.

Above all Sachs, echoing the sentiments of scores of activists here and around the world, wants the IMF removed as the HIPC initiative’s gatekeeper.

“The IMF is a monetary institution designed to provide short- term lending to countries in short-term crisis. Instead, it’s running Africa’s economies,” says Sachs.

The Fund’s use of low-interest loans to enforce economic restructuring programmes – including cuts in social spending – has long been contentious but officials say this is intended to improve African and other low-income economies’ chances of putting their debt-relief dividends to economically productive use.

As far as Sachs is concerned, however, “the IMF does not belong in Africa, period.”

“It’s masquerading as our institution for everything,” he says, “because the US Treasury wants it to be.”

Political pundits say that, so long as that remains the case, the IMF will preside over the HIPC initiative – restricting relief to countries it deems to be performing satisfactorily under its ‘Enhanced Structural Adjustment Facility’ (ESAF).

The agency’s opponents, however, hold out hope that the Treasury department eventually will come around.

“There is a very, very deep sense that the IMF is vastly overextended,” says Sachs. “This is an institution with precious few friends, even in Washington.”

Republican lawmaker Spencer Bachus nevertheless says he is optimistic Congress will approve the Clinton Administration request.

“The cost of funding debt relief is one dollar and 20 cents a year for every man, woman and child in the United States,” Bachus says. “The cost of not doing it will be the deaths of tens of thousands of people.”

However, lawmakers from both parties are busy drumming up support for legislative proposals that could alter the Treasury plan – perhaps even beyond recognition, campaigners say.

A proposed ‘Debt Relief and IMF Reform Act of 1999′ would block use of money derived from the transfer of IMF gold reserves for debt relief – unless the agency agrees to a series of pre- requisites.

These include cancelling the Fund’s claims against all HIPCs and Haiti, improving the agency’s transparency, and closing down ESAF.

“Basically, they would have to stop being the IMF,” says Soren Ambrose, policy analyst at ’50 Years is Enough’, a network of US-based non-governmental organisations (NGOs).

“It’s an IMF-hater’s bill,” says Ambrose, who gives the proposal only fair chances of passing.

Another proposal – the ‘Debt Emancipation for Emerging Democracies Act’ – would require the United States to cancel debts owed to it by HIPCs and Haiti and withhold money from the IMF until it follows suit.

The proposal also would block US funding for the IMF until the agency shuts down its structural adjustment lending window for the poorest countries.

Only countries with democratic elections and militaries under civilian control would benefit. The gains would go to social programmes. Countries spending at least 20 percent of their budgets on health and education spending also would qualify for private sector project-financing support from the US Overseas Private Investment Corporation.

Even if the measures fail, activists hope they will help to set the tone of negotiations over IMF issues between Congress and the Administration.

For its part, the IMF is talking up efforts to make ESAF a tool for poverty reduction and shows no sign of entertaining requests to close the facility. Friday’s agenda at the Fund includes a session on “ESAF in the New Millennium.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags