Friday, November 20, 2026
Mark Bourrie
- The US government joined outraged environmentalists last week in demanding that Canada do more to protect endangered species of wildlife.
US President met privately with Canadian Prime Minister Jean Chretien for several hours and discussed a letter from a group of US Republican and Democrat senators who want Canada to bring in a tough new endangered species law.
During Chretien’s six years in office, his government’s stand on environmental legislation that has been under fire from environmentalists for failing to provide adequate protection to wildlife. Many critics have alleged the legislation as a watering down of existing laws and twice, government bills have failed to pass Canada’s two houses of Parliament.
Clinton came to Ottawa Friday to officially open the new U.S. embassy here and address a 30-country forum on the future of federalism.
In an effort to maintain the “feel good” atmosphere of the visit, government spokeswoman Jennifer Lang downplayed the issue of the endangered species dispute, saying that she did not even know if Clinton talked about the senators’ concerns during the meeting between the two leaders.
US presidential sources, however, said the issue certainly was raised.
The criticism of the Canadian government by both U.S. senators and local environmentalists has created a strange alliance.
Usually, Canadian activists are critical of the U.S. for cross- border pollution but the environmental group Greenpeace agrees that Canada has failed to live up to commitments made to the United States and other nations to protect biodiversity.
“There are hundreds of species in Canada currently in danger of extinction (including the Beluga whale, the spotted owl and the grizzly bear) while others already have been lost.
Legislation to protect endangered species in Canada is long overdue to match federal US laws that protect endangered species, environmentalists declared.
Canada made an international commitment to producing an Endangered Species Act when it became the first signatory to the Rio Convention on Biodiversity in 1992 (required under Article 8), Greenpeace said. “Canada has not lived up to that agreement.”
The organisation hopes that Environment Minister, David Anderson, will bring in another bill during the next session of Parliament that will address the accusations that the Canadian government is easing environmental restrictions and making only a token effort to protect endangered species.
The letter from the US senators may carry added weight in Ottawa as it raises questions about “unfair subsidies” for resource producers who are not obliged to spend money to protect the habitat, as do U.S. logging and mining companies.
“The United States spends millions of dollars and exerts a lot of political effort to save species, like grizzly bears and wolves but, once they cross the 49th parallel, they can be legally shot as pests,” the senators said.
The senators claim Canadian companies are reaping the benefits of Canada’s lack of endangered species protection.
Their letter says resource-based industries in Canada have an unfair advantage over U.S. businesses because American companies must share the costs of protecting or recovering an endangered species.
The senators point out that a timber company in the Canadian province of British Columbia can log without over concern for the habitat of the spotted owl but American logging companies must obey tough laws that protect these endangered birds.
The senators, representing nearly all US states, said that if Canada doesn’t follow suit, it could affect trade relations between the two countries.
Under NAFTA and World Trade Organization rules, Canada’s lack of tough endangered species laws could be condemned as unfair subsidies, the U.S. legislators say.
The senators and environmental groups like Greenpeace are angry that the proposed environmental bills protect wildlife in only four percent of Canada’s huge wilderness area. Much of it is outside the territory in the boreal forest and the Pacific rainforest that is clear cut by the country’s loggers.
So far, activists say, government legislation has done little to protect species in the arctic or subarctic regions of the country, areas that are most vulnerable to pollution caused by mining and oil and gas exploration.
Greenpeace said it was appalling that the legislation as proposed applies only to species on four percent of Canada’s landbase. In addition, habitat protection is not guaranteed for any species and it is the destruction of the habitat that is responsible for 80 percent of species decline in Canada.
“Canada needs an effective Endangered Species Act,” Greenpeace says. “A recent poll found that 94 percent of Canadians support endangered species legislation. The legislation that is proposed is a ‘greenwash’ – and may be worse than having none at all.”