Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

TRADE: Activists Target Canada’s Export Credit Agency

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Oct 4 1999 (IPS) - Social activists want the government to rein in the activities of the Canadian Export Development Corporation (EDC) and force it to consider the environmental and human rights impact of its foreign investments.

Non-governmental organisations (NGOs) get the chance to make their case to over the next few months at public hearings in members of Canada’s Parliament during public hearings this winter. By law, the EDC’s mandate must be reviewed before next summer.

The EDC, wholly-owned by the Canadian government, underwrites businesses that operate in 200 countries.

The corporation made loans to China to buy Canadian-made turbines for the Three Gorges Dam project, after China was turned down by the World Bank. It also backed investors in the Omai mine in Guyana.

In 1995, a burst tailings dam released 3.2 billion litrres of cyanide and heavy metal laced waste into the country’s main river causing devastation to the country’s fishery and eco-tourism industry.

“Our once-pristine river here is Guyana’s rainforest, which scientists say is the largest intact section of virgin rainforest left in South America, is now polluted. The effects of this mine have been devastating,” said Mary Anotak, a resident of Essequibo, Guyana.

She was speaking here at a meeting of Canadian NGOs who plan to push Parliament to make the EDC accountable and more concerned with the political and environmental effects of the investments it sponsors.

The EDC underwrote 50 million dollars of the cost of the OK Tedi mine in Papau New Guinea, the third-largest open pit copper mine in the world.

In 1984, a landslide destroyed the dam around the mine’s toxic tailing ponds, sending 80,000 tons of waste rock containing lead, cadmium, zinc and copper into the Fly and OK Tedi rivers. Nearly 70 kilomotres of the two rivers were environmentally destroyed.

It also underwrote mines that have spilled poisonous tailings into rivers in the Philippines and Kyrgyzstan.

The corporation was founded in 1944 and, six years ago, the government expanded the powers of the EDC to underwrite and insure foreign investment and allowed it to expand its loan and insurance portfolio to 22 billion dollars.

The corporation pays no income tax, is exempt under Canada’s Freedom of Information laws, and all of its borrowing is backed by the federal government.

“The Parliamentary hearings are the one chance for us to press for reform of the EDC,” said Pam Hudson, co-ordinator of the umbrella group of NGOs who oppose the credit agency’s policies.

“Any time we ask for information, we’re told that we can’t have it because it would reveal business secrets. That excuse gives the EDC the right to do what it wants. Members of Parliament can’t find out about the EDC.

“Even the Finance Minister, who promised to get information for us, had to come back to us and say that the EDC could not give him specific information!”

Critics say the agency is more aggressive and more secretive than similar credit agencies in the United States and Europe. The World Trade Organization (WTO) already has objected to the EDC’s use of 2 billion dollars of “Canada Account” funds to support politically – motivated export deals.

This money comes from Canada’s Treasury departmernt, and may be labelled an unfair subsidy when the WTO looks at the issue later this year.

The Canada Account was at the centre of a Brazilian complaint to the WTO about illegal export subsidies to Bombardier, a Quebec- based aerospace company and transit system builder. Bombardier is one of the few industrial successes in the predominantly French province. Canada is appealing a WTO ruling in Brazil’s favor.

“It exists because other countries do the same thing,” says Glen Hodgson, director of government relations and corporate policy and director of international relations for the EDC. “If we didn’t have it, Canadian companies would lose business.”

Under EDC rules, the agency underwrites as much as 90 per cent of the risk of Canadian investors doing business in foreign countries. Political risk, such as expropriation, is covered, as is the loss suffered if a company is shut down because of an environmental disaster.

Environmental critics of the EDC say the agency cares only about the losses suffered by businesses, and not about the problems caused to the ecosystem of the host country.

The EDC has countered by saying it supports 300 million dollars in “Green exports”, goods and services that are supposed to improve the environment of the countries recieving the investment.

A communique issued by the EDC says it has “formalized and strengthened its environmental review practices. Briefly, EDC considers the environmental effects and risks associated with projects it supports as part of its overall risk assessment process.

“EDC will decline support for projects which, after taking into account the implementation of mitigating measures, are likely to cause significant adverse effects that cannot be justified by the anticipated positive effects of the project.”

In July, a law firm hired by the Canadian government to examine the operations of the EDC suggested its operations be cut back, and that Ottawa consider privatizing the corporation. The consultants agreed with business critics who say the EDC cuts into the business of banks.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags