Headlines, North America

TRADE: Conflict Could Prolong WTO Summit

Abid Aslam

SEATTLE, Nov 29 1999 (IPS) - Negotiators from 135 countries sit down here Tuesday to launch a new round of trade liberalisation talksthe biggest in 13 years, a number that also could prove to be unlucky for the World Trade Organisation (WTO).

The mood before the start of the WTO’s third ministerial conference appears as inclement as the weather in this city of 600,000 residents – many of whose livelihoods depend on the ability of corporations, such as Boeing and Microsoft, to trade overseas and on the power of local government and labour unions to distribute the resulting gains among workers.

Fighting over the agenda of the four-day conference is so intense that some diplomats say they might need to stay an extra day rather than leave empty-handed.

Already the disputes reflect the need of governments to win concessions for increasingly diverse home constituencies. These include citizens’ groups that arrived in force in Seattle to tell delegates that freer trade and economic globalisation – as seen from their factories, farms and homes – have brought few benefits and a world of social, political and environmental woes.

“No new round; turn around” is the common refrain from these groups.

US President Bill Clinton is going all out to make sure that this does not happen. He is scheduled to address the WTO gathering and officials say he likely to remain for much of the conference.

Clinton had wanted other heads of state to join him in a “leaders’ forum” during the WTO talks but he failed to generate enthusiasm for the idea among the higher-ups and the trade body.

White House officials have played down the aborted plan as an “informal idea” that had been dropped for lack of time to organise it.

European officials, however, say they were surprised by the President’s last-minute advances and suspected his aim had been to make sure that other leaders would be in Seattle to share the blame if the WTO talks were to fail.

For the US trade team, success will lie in convincing other countries to further open goods, agricultural and services markets, reduce tariffs and export subsidies for these, and remove government procurement policies favouring domestic pr oducers over foreign ones.

US negotiators also want to reduce tariffs on imports of information technology products, of which the United States is a leading producer. They also seek to extend a tariff moratorium for e-commerce (such as electronic purchases over the Internet) that otherwise will lapse this month.

The US administration, hoping to mollify domestic activists, has made a priority of pressing WTO members to adopt a ‘social clause’ designed to promote core labour standards – including minimum wages and the right to unionise – and measures to minimise environmental damage associated with trade.

Clinton nevertheless has reminded his compatriots that the US case for trade is clear if they expect to maintain their privileged lifestyle.

“You don’t have to be a genius to figure out that if you want to keep 22 percent of the world’s income for four percent of the world’s people, you’ve got to sell something to the other 96 percent,” Clinton says.

Developing countries, however, say the ‘social clause’ will serve as pretext for rich countries to erect barriers agai nst imports of low-wage goods and thus undermine their competitive advantage by raising production costs.

At the same time, US negotiators oppose calls from developing countries and Japan to review rules on ‘dumping’ – or the export of products at prices deemed artificially low. Exporters penalised for low prices contend that US competitors have used dumping charges unfairly to avoid competition.

The United States also is blocking Indian and Pakistani proposals that the WTO hold off further work on intellectual property rights until they have reviewed implementation of agreements under the ‘Uruguay Round’ of trade negotiations, launched 13 years ago in the resort town of Punta del Este.

Developing and European countries, as well as Japan, generally oppose US efforts to liberalise agricultural trade for fear that foreign competitors will swamp local producers and, in poor countries, further erode food security.

WTO Director-General Mike Moore’s “wish list” for the Seattle conference includes agreement on a package to assist the least developed countries.

“Taken together, these nations account for only half of one percent of world trade. And yet, in many cases they face import barriers higher than those applied to products from the richest countries,” Moore says.

He argues that “the removal of all barriers to imports from the least developed countries would extend the gift of opportunity to people who desperately need our help.”

In addition, the former New Zealand prime minister and union leader wants members to cough up more money to teach poor countries the finer points of negotiating and implementing trade agreements.

Moore’s wish coincides with calls by World Bank President James Wolfensohn and others for the next sequence of global trade deals to be dubbed the “development round”. The 71-nation African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) bloc demanded last week that rich countries drop all tariffs against the poorest nations’ exports.

Debt-relief advocates, however, say that idea is off the mark.

Creditors push highly indebted poor countries “to increase their exports but much of the money earned from these exports is used to service debts to the IMF and World Bank,” says Dennis Brutus, Honorary Co-President of Jubilee 2000 Afrika.

“If the rich countries want to help the poor countries, let them cancel the debts and remove the weight of structural adjustment policies from the backs of the poor,” he insists.

One point on which most WTO members appear to agree is that the organisation itself needs reform. Although they differ on the specifics, countries want the agency to be more transparent.

Many developing countries are particularly irked by the WTO’s use of so-called ‘green room’ consultations, in which Moore invites a handful of member states to hammer out positions on specific issues – which the wider membership then is invited to endorse.

Moore defends this practice as time-saving and insists that decisions reached in the secret sessions are not final until agreed to by all members. Third World negotiators, however, have fired off a letter accusing Moore of placing a higher premium on efficiency than on democracy.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags