Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour

LABOUR-INDIA: Power Strike Could Stymie Privatisation Plans

Ranjit Dev Raj

NEW DELHI, Jan 19 2000 (IPS) - A crippling five-day-old strike by 100,000 power employees in northern Uttar Pradesh state threatens to stymie ambitious World Bank-recommended plans to restructure ailing government power utilities.

Warnings by Uttar Pradesh power minister Lalji Tandon that the state government would begin sackings from Wednesday have failed to impress the workers who have sworn to resist any attempt to privatise the state-run utility.

“The power system in the state is complicated and the government cannot hire 100,000 new employees overnight,” said Shailendra Dubey, who leads the Northern India Power Engineering Federation.

News reports said Lucknow, the capital of Uttar Pradesh which has a population of 165 million people, faced acute water shortages as an immediate consequence of massive power shortages over five days caused by the strike.

Dubey said the strike would continue until the government stops making threats to hire new staff, gets down to negotiations and scrap plans to privatise. The government has already sacked 60 striking engineers.

With power workers in five other northern Indian states, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Delhi, Punjab and Haryana threatening to join the strike, the government has called in the army to take care of supply and maintenance.

Tandon failed to assure the workers they have nothing to fear and that the “corporatisation” of the power utility was limited to a simple trifurcation of its functions into generation, transmission and distribution.

According to Dubey, corporatisation is only the thin edge of the privatisation wedge and would almost certainly lead to service terminations and higher power tariffs for consumers.

Union power minister, P. Kumaramangalam has said repeatedly that there is no alternative to corporatisation because of the forty percent transmission and distribution losses in Uttar Pradesh and most other Indian state — attributed to power thefts.

Power unions insist that the utilities are accumulating losses because of political interference in their running and because of huge subsidies to consumers and even free electricity supplies to some groups like farmers.

Either way, state utilities across the country currently owe the central government 5.4 billion dollars with little hope that the money would ever be recovered.

Current policy initiatives by the right-wing Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)-led government openly favour private and foreign investors through counter-guarantees and customs duty exemptions on imported equipment while starving the utilities of plan funds.

So far, the experience with power trans national corporations (TNCs) like Enron and Cogentrix has not been a happy one for consumers faced as they are with ever-increasing tariffs linked to the high capital cost of new plants and costly fuel.

In western Maharashtra state production from government plants had to be backed down to accommodate Enron Corporation’s plant at Dhabol which produces electricity at 12 cents a unit or twice what it costs the state utility.

Yet, last month, the government hastened to offer counter- guarantees to another United States-based power giant, Cogentrix after it threatened to pull out of a controversial 1000 megawatt project in Southern Karnataka state.

Counter-guarantees by the central government assure private power producers full realisation of their state investment form the sale of power to the concerned state electricity board — but costs are passed on to consumers.

With the costs of grid power escalating, several industries have set up their own captive power units which can produce electricity from diesel or coal at around seven cents a unit. The exodus of customers has further hurt the utilities.

According to the independent ‘Powerline Report on Captive Power Plants’ some 20,000 megawatts of electricity are already being produced by captive power plants.

The report warned that if the restructured utilities fix tariffs at levels recommended by World Bank consultants, the only sectors that will suffer will be poorer sections among domestic consumers and genuine agriculture users.

According to Powerline reports several state utilities have been found to have resorted to large-scale manipulation of

figures to blame losses on the agriculture sector rather than to transmission and distribution.

Even in states like Delhi and Orissa which have no agricultural load, losses due to transmission and distribution (privately referred to as theft and dacoity) are still above forty percent.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags