Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour, Latin America & the Caribbean

LABOUR-JAMAICA: Guards Spurn New Term for Prisons Chief

Dionne Jackson-Miller

MONTEGO BAY, Jan 6 2000 (IPS) - Tensions between the Jamaican government and correctional officers are escalating as guards continue to loudly protest the re-appointment of the commissioner of corrections, whose tenure has been marked by both significant prison reform measures and rocky labour relations.

National Security and Justice Minister Keith Knight is standing behind his decision to re-appoint Lt. Col. John Prescod to the post, and is insisting that the guards and unions will not be allowed to dictate government appointments.

“I want to make it clear that I have confidence in Col. Prescod,” Knight said. “I think (he) has worked very hard, has achieved a great deal in bringing about change in the system. We have had industrial action (during Prescod’s tenure), but we have also had change.”

Modernisation and change are precisely what the government wanted when it brought in Prescod from the army six years ago.

At that time, local and international criticisms were mounting in a prison system where charges of corruption, bribery and abuse of prisoners by guards were commonplace. Over the past six years, Prescod has won the admiration of many by his seeming determination to stem corruption and improve prison conditions.

But when the news broke last week that the government was planning to sign Prescod for another two years as Commissioner of Corrections, prison guards immediately protested, eventually going on strike and leaving soldiers to man the country’s penitentiaries.

The industrial action was the latest in a series of skirmishes that has correctional officers arguing that the Commissioner does not command their confidence.

Their major objection stems from a negative assessment of Prescod’s tenure, including the slow pace of salary negotiations, the absence of promotions, staff shortages, and poor relations with senior officers.

“The view is coming across that the Commissioner stands for rehabilitation and the guards don’t,” said Lambert Brown, vice- president of the University and Allied Workers Union (UAWU) which represents the guards. “We think this man is a failure. He has failed to motivate the staff in the prison. It is not rehabilitation (that) is the issue, it’s leadership.”

Knight concedes that the labour tension has affected the assessment of Prescod’s leadership.

“Had the course been smoother, then his performance would have been better appreciated, and we would have been closer to the objectives,” Knight said. “But the fact is that however rocky the course has been, changes have been made, changes for the better, related to the guards, inmates, probation service.

“There are so many new things that have come into the institution since Col. Prescod,” he added. “I am very pleased with his approach to the need for change, his commitment to change, and his performance in bringing about change.”

Knight’s view is shared by several prominent groups active in the penal system.

In positions diametrically opposed to that of the guards, organisations representing probation officers, prison medical officers and prison chaplains have come out in favour of Prescod’s re-appointment.

“We have found him to be resolute in bringing the services of correctional work into a professional mode,” said Rev. Andrew Bennett, president of the Inter Faith Prisons Chaplaincy Services.

“It is my view that Col. Prescod has brought the prisons apace with the rest of the world. I believe that prison is equally about rehabilitation as it is punishment,” he added.

Indeed, Prescod’s implementation of a rehabilitation programme emphasising education and recreation for prisoners and their involvement in income-generating projects is often cited as one of his major achievements.

However, his detractors are quick to point to the 1997 prison riots in which 16 men died. The violence erupted after guards and prisoners slammed Prescod for publicly stating that condoms would be distributed in prisons, asserting that his comments hinted at homosexual relations between the two groups.

And last October, 22 men escaped from the country’s maximum- security prison. The official enquiry that followed turned up evidence of lax security practices, which Prescod has denied any knowledge of.

Independent human rights consultant Flo O’Connor said that while Prescod has made a real difference, his influence is difficult to assess.

“It is extremely difficult to put one person in an institution in which corruption has become endemic, to change that institution, change the attitudes which inform the behaviour of the majority of those involved at the institution,” she said.

“In every report done on the prisons in this country, corruption and behaviour of guards has been an ongoing concern. Based on what I experienced by working in the prisons, by and large the opposition to Col. Prescod stems from the fact that against all odds, he has remained committed to trying to bring the prison force screaming into the 21st century,” O’Connor said.

But others say that the penal system remains plagued with problems and charge that there have been no real improvements.

“I have not seen any change,” said Wentworth Charles, spokesman for the non-parliamentary Opposition National Democratic Movement. “If you look at the overcrowding there, if you look at security recommendations in relation to the General Penitentiary over the years, nothing that I see there can reflect any change.

“What has happened in my view is a worsening of the situation resulting in prisoners escaping from a maximum security institution on a regular basis,” Charles said.

And while the government tries to broker an agreement with the guards to ease the way for the man chosen to lead the penal system for the next two years, O’Connor is calling for a review of the administration’s approach.

“I think the government needs to get realistic and acknowledge that one person cannot do the job,” she said. “Maybe at this point what is needed is an outside management team to assist Col. Prescod.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags