Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, North America

POLITICS-MIDEAST: Clinton Hopeful on Israel-Syrian Talks

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Jan 10 2000 (IPS) - After a week of high-level negotiations, President Bill Clinton appeared to have made real progress in putting the Middle East peace process back on track, saying Monday he was ôstill quite hopefulö about the prospects o f moving Syria and Israel towards a peace deal.

ôThese people really talked about the substance of their differences for the first time. They were very open, they were very candid, they covered all the issues and I thinkàthey broke a lot of ground,ö he said.

Clintons remarks came ahead of a US State Department announcement tha t the top negotiators, Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak and Syrian Foreign Minister Farouk al-Shara, who were heading home Monday, would return to the US Jan. 19 to continue the talks.

“It’s clear that both sides are talking very seriously,” said Hisham Melhem, a Washington-based journalist for Lebanon’s As-Safr newspaper, who is monitoring the talks in the rural hamlet about 100 kms northwest of Washington.

Melhem’s remarks followed the presentation by US President Bill Clinton to both Prime Minister Barak and Foreign Minister Shara Friday of a US-drafted “working document” which was described as a “procedural tool” designed to bridge the major substantive gaps which held up progress most of last week.

Maintaining a news blackout on the talks, the parties have declined to comment on the document’s contents. But the fact that Washington has put forward its own proposal is considered a major development, signifying Clinton’s willingness to intervene more actively in the talks.

The Sunday dinner hosted by Clinton at the Clarion Hotel in Shepherdstown, was indeed the sixth time he has met with the parties in the seven days since the talks were convened.

The document, as well as Clintons direct participation, appears to hav e overcome some of the procedural obstacles which deadlocked the talks last week.

All four working groups which are supposed to take up specific aspects of any eventual treaty met for the first time Monday morning, while both Syrian and Israeli newspapers with close ties to their respective governments reported greater flexibility in the two sides positions.

The central issue in the negotiations, which began last month after a three-year hiatus, is the extent and conditions under which Israel will withdraw from the Golan Heights, which it captured from Syria in the 1967 Arab-Israeli war.

Israel not only has built key military installations, including sophisticated spy stations which can eavesdrop on conversations in Damascus 50 kms away, on the Golan, but it has also installed some 17,000 civilians in settlements that dot the Heights.

The Syrians are demanding a total withdrawal from the Heights – which offer a commanding view of almost all of northern Israel – back to the borders which immediately preceded the ’67 war.

They argue that Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin agreed to such a withdrawal in talks before his assassination in 1996.

But Barak and the Israelis until now have been coy about such a commitment, They insist that Rabin, Barak’s mentor, had accepted a total withdrawal only as a “hypothetical formula.”

The issue is critical, not only because of the strategic nature of territory in question, but also because when Clinton announced the resumption of peace talks in December, he said they would start from where the negotiations left off three years ago.

“It’s clear from the talks last week that there had been no agreement on where they left off in 1996,” said Melhem, who added that the US document may have helped resolve this question.

Indeed, Syrias main daily newspaper, Tishrin, suggested that that is what happened.  The United States has played an important role in putting the peace process back on track after the Israelis tried to avoid committing to a full withdrawal from the Golan, it reported Monday morning.

Tishrin also suggested for the first time that Damascus was prepared to accept full normalization of relations with Israel in return for a total withdrawal a point Israel insists that Syria was unwilling to concede in the negotiations three years ago.

The four working committees, which include US as well as Israeli and Syrian diplomats, are supposed to deal with future security arrangements; overall bilateral relations; water rights; and border demarcation.

As of Friday, only the first two committees had met, despite Syria’s demand that Israel should commit itself to a full withdrawal before other issues are discussed.

The border and water issues are closely related. Damascus wants to reclaim its shoreline with the Sea of Galilee and the Jordan River to guarantee access to these key resources in a water-short region. Israel, on the other hand, is eager to retain as much control over them as it can.

Security issues also represent major challenges to a final peace treaty. Israel wants to maintain some of its intelligence facilities on the Golan as an early-warning station even after a withdrawal. But Damascus has rejected this outright.

Syria, however, has not rejected the possibility that some kind of monitoring station be maintained, so long as is it is not manned by Israelis.

That has given rise to speculation that Clinton may be willing to commit US forces to monitor the area, a notion endorsed last week by retired Gen. Brent Scowcroft, who served as national security adviser to Republican presidents Gerald Ford and George Bush.

“Given the tens of billions of dollars the United States has poured into the area and the recurrence of conflict in the region over the decades,” Scowcroft wrote in the New York Times last Thursday, “we should be prepared to give a substantial American security guarantee.”

Washington is also prepared to provide many more billions of dollars in exchange for a treaty, which the administration hopes will be a capstone to eight years of Mideast diplomacy.

Barak has reportedly asked Clinton for a military aid package worth 17 billion dollars if Israel carries out a full withdrawal.

Such a package would include weapons, such as Tomahawk cruise missiles, Apache helicopter gunships, and sophisticated AWACS radar planes, which Washington has previously denied Israel.

It also wants a direct link with US intelligence satellites, which would mark a significant upgrade of Israel’s “strategic alliance” with Washington, particularly it loses its monitoring stations as part of a withdrawal.

That assistance is needed, according to Israeli officials, in order to assure their public, a majority of which opposes a total withdrawal from the Golan, that Israel will not lose any strategic advantage by giving up the Heights.

The Jewish state, by far the largest recipient of US military and economic aid since the late 1960s, has long indicated it also expects Washington to pay the bill – estimated at about 10 billion dollars – for relocating Israeli settlers and removing army bases on the Heights.

“Barak is really engaged in two sets of negotiations: with Syria and with the United States,” said Melhem.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags