Headlines, North America

TRADE-UNITED STATES: Public Supports Globalisation With Conditions

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Mar 29 2000 (IPS) - Most US citizens support trade and deeper integration into the global economy so long as workers’ rights and environmental protection are not compromised, according to a new stud y released here Tuesday.

The public is also willing to undergo economic sacrifice, including p ossible job losses and higher prices for consumer goods, if that results in a n improvement in living standards and working conditions in poorer nati ons, according to the report by the University of Maryland’s Progam on International Policy Attitudes (PIPA).

The 96-page study, an elaboration of a survey first released last Nov ember in advance of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) ministerial meeting in Seattle, finds strong support for continued growth in world trade but a “significant lack of confidence” in the way trade is being developed, according to Steven Kull, the main author of the study, ‘Americans on Globalization.’

The public, he said, believes the government “can do more and should do more” to protect US workers and the environment from the consequences of globalisation. In particular, it should devote much greater resources to retraining workers who lose their jobs as a result of overseas compet ition.

The study comes at a critical moment as Congress prepares to vote on two key trade measures over the next 10 weeks. If passed, they would be the f irst major trade bills, despite a number of efforts by Clinton, approved b y Congress in more than five years.

They include a bill, different versions of which have passed both hou ses, that would offer new trade preferences to countries of sub-Saharan Af rica and the Caribbean Basin, and another that would grant China permanent normal trade relations (NTR).

The latter bill, the most controversial piece of foreign-policy legis lation to be debated in Congress this year, would permit Washington to take full advantage of a trade agreement the administration reached with China late last year. It would also facilitate China’s entry into the WTO.

Both bills are strongly opposed by a coalition of organised labour – a key constituency of President Bill Clinton’s Democratic Party – and vario us environmental groups which together have made defeating the China NTR bill their top legislative priority this year precisely because it does no t provide for any enforceable protections for workers’ rights and the environment.

In addition, a number of right-wing Republicans oppose the China bill due to concerns about Beijing’s communist government and its long-run strate gic ambitions. The powerful textile lobby, which wields clout in both par ties, also opposes both bills.

On the other side, US corporations with major overseas interests stro ngly favour both bills, as do a majority of Republican lawmakers and both of the two major presidential candidates – Democratic Vice President Al Gore and Texas Governor George W. Bush.

Both sides are likely to seize on the new report as evidence of publi c support for their positions. While business will see in it a repudiat ion of traditional protectionist positions, opponents of pending trade bills will trumpet its strong support for placing conditions on trade.

“The American public does not buy the ‘trade ueber alles’ idea,” said Lori Wallach, a leader of the anti-China trade forces, at a briefing on th e report at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace here Tuesday ..

The report – based on existing polling data, an extensive survey of m ore than 100 questions directed at some 1,800 randomly selected responden ts just before the Seattle meeting, and discussions with “focus groups” aroun d the country – found a strong consensus behind Clinton’s own stated policy that future trade agreements must provide enforceable protections for work ers’ rights and the environment. That policy, which was strongly rejected by many developing nations at the WTO meeting in Seattle, however, is not ref lected in the two pending trade bills.

“In principle, a majority of Americans support the growth of internat ional trade, especially when the removal of trade barriers is clearly recip rocal,” the report states. “However, Americans are lukewarm about the actual net benefits of trade for most sectors of society … A strong majority f eels trade has not grown in a way that adequately incorporates concerns fo r American workers, international labour standards and the environment. ”

Asked specifically about whether the WTO should consider labour stand ards and the environment when making decisions on trade and given the majo r arguments for and against, four out of five respondents gave affirmat ive answers.

Moreover, some 93 percent of respondents agreed with the statement th at “countries that are part of the international trade agreements should be required to maintain minimum standards for working conditions.”

“That’s the biggest number we’ve ever gotten on a poll,” Kull said.

More than 70 percent of respondents said US trade policy mainly benef its business and the wealthy and does not give enough consideration to av erage citizens. Two-thirds of respondents said the government should invest more in retraining and education for workers hurt by overseas trading.

Their concern for workers, however, was not confined to those within the United States. Three out of four respondents agreed that they had a ” moral obligation to make efforts to ensure that (people in other countries) do not have to work in harsh or unsafe conditions.”

A slightly greater percentage agreed that they would prefer to spend 25 dollars for a piece of clothing that they knew was produced in non- sw eatshop conditions than 20 dollars for the same piece of clothing if they did not know how it was made.

Similarly, more than four out of five respondents said US corporation s should be expected to abide by US laws and regulations on working con ditions and environmental protection in their operations abroad.

The survey also found strong support – ranging between two-thirds and four-fifths – for imposing trade sanctions against countries accused of serious human rights violations, terrorism, or environmental destruct ion. That finding could bode ill for the pending China bill because oppone nts argue that renewing Beijing’s NTR status on an annual basis permits C ongress to review its human-rights record.

Indeed, three out of four of the survey’s respondents said Washington should limit its trade with China due to its poor human-rights record, a fin ding that was echoed in another poll taken two months ago by Peter D. Hart Research Associates. It found that two-thirds of likely voters oppose permanent NTR status for China without annual Congressional reviews.

The Kull survey, according to experts here, shows a growing consensus in favour of continuing globalisation subject to conditions. “The public thinks that free trade is here to stay,” said Guy Molyneux, a top pol lster for the Hart firm. “But what they are saying is they want some kind o f rules and standards.” Without such standards, he added “it is simply imposs ible for free trade to continue.”

Wallach, who heads Public Citizen’s Global Trade Watch, agreed. “Whil e globalisation may be inevitable,” she said, “the particular way of do ing it is not.”

Since the poll was taken, she said, grassroots activity directed agai nst the China bill, in particular, has grown manifold, primarily because the public protests against the WTO meeting in Seattle had made the trade issue far more visible.

While most experts agree that the Seattle protests had a marginal eff ect on public attitudes towards free trade and globalisation, the protests g reatly magnified public awareness about the two issues.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags