Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour, Latin America & the Caribbean

LABOUR-LATAM: Market Interests Thrash Workers’ Rights

Gustavo González

SANTIAGO, Apr 28 2000 (IPS) - The controversial approval of labour reforms in Argentina, just days before International Labour Day, has established Latin America’s most recent milestone in the growing predominance of market interests over union rights.

Behind this phenomenon there lies an undeclared battle between International Labour Organisation (ILO) efforts towards a globalisation that does not bulldoze achievements made in the area of workers’ rights, and International Monetary Fund (IMF) recommendations for the liberalisation or deregulation of the labour market.

The historically strong union movement in Argentina became divided during the legislative debate on the reforms, which introduce labour contract negotiations by company as opposed to negotiations by economic sector, among other changes.

The framework agreements that covered specific areas of labour activity would be reduced to encompassing individual companies, while workers give up wage raises or reduce their vacation time in order to ensure their continued employment.

The creation of a three-month test period prior to official hiring and an end to the automatic renewal of union contracts are other elements included in the new Argentine labour legislation.

Changes like these were originally proposed under the government of Raúl Alfonsín (1983-1989), but neither he nor his successor, Carlos Menem (1989-1999), were able to break through the resistance of the General Confederation of Labour (CGT). Then social-democrat president Fernando de la Rúa took office and changed all that.

The unionists who oppose the labour reforms maintain that the project was openly billed as a “recommendation” of the IMF and the World Bank, multilateral organisations that promote deregulation as a way to make developing economies more attractive for foreign investment.

Argentina’s new labour scheme parallels several of the norms imposed in Chile in the early 1980s under the dictatorship of Gen. Augusto Pinochet (1973-1990), the region’s pioneer in establishing a neoliberal model for opening national markets to outsiders.

The Chilean government of Eduardo Frei, whose term in office ended March 11, tried in late 1999 to implement labour reforms that were just opposite of those now approved in Argentina: re-establishing union negotiations by federation or employment sector.

The Chilean bill was rejected by the Senate’s right-wing majority, which argued that the country would lose its competitive edge on the international market if it were approved. The centre-left president, meanwhile, pointed out that it would be difficult for Chile to negotiate trade accords with industrialised countries if it does not have labour legislation that meets current international standards.

Both positions reflect the debate underway in the globalisation context, in which those promoting economic liberalism say the market must determine which are the best labour conditions for attracting investment in developing countries.

Union and environmental organisations, however, maintain that labour deregulation not only perpetuates inequalities in the world economy, but it also exposes the poorer countries to accusations of “social dumping” when it comes time to engage in trade talks.

One way or another, liberalisation imposes itself as a result of the employment instability that characterises globalisation, deepening within economic crisis, such that labour reform in Argentina only legitimises a situation that already existed in practice.

More than political or socio-economic arguments, it is cold data that plays in favour of deregulation in Argentina. Unemployment reaches 13.8 percent and underemployment stands at 14.3 percent in a nation where 40 percent of the labour force works without a contract and, as a result, without social security or health insurance.

Brazil is also engaged in debate about labour market deregulation, with wage rules being the most complex of the issues, as president Fernando Henrique Cardoso attempts to de-link the minimum wage base – just 84 dollars per month – from the retirement pension system.

The goal is to push the minimum wage up to the equivalent of 100 dollars, but economic authorities argue that an increase of that magnitude would bankrupt the social security system. For now, the state governments have opted to grant higher salaries, but in practice, no wage rises have been formalised.

In Mexico, where the economy is maintained in large part by the ‘maquiladoras’ (companies that assemble industrial goods for export), the wave of labour deregulation occurred in 1993 when the country joined the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), alongside the United States and Canada.

Independent unionists accuse the Workers’ Central of Mexico (CTM), which controls most of the nation’s labour organisations and is tied to the governing Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI), of promoting liberalisation of the labour market.

“The CTM is preventing the exercise of labour rights recognised by law. It fights freedom of association and is allied with the government and foreign investors, for whom the most attractive things about Mexico are its low wages and the control (the government) has over the unions,” argued Bertha Lujan, co-ordinator of the Authentic Labour Front.

Within NAFTA, there is a North American Labour Co-operation Agreement that commits the member countries to respecting workers’ rights, but it lacks any enforcement mechanism, so it does not apply in Mexico, Lujan pointed out.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags