Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines

CULTURE-SINGAPORE: Rich City-state Rethinks Social Values

Mohan Srilal

SINGAPORE, Aug 21 2000 (IPS) - In just three decades, this tiny South- east Asian republic has been able to achieve a level of economic development that took European powers more than two centuries to do.

But this achievement has also produced a new generation of Singaporeans who are perhaps the most materialistic and status- conscious in Asia.

Now, these values are being questioned, from within, by the island country of more than four million people.

Debate in the local media on social issues has become much more common that in the past. Even political leaders are getting into the act.

During this month’s 35th National Day celebrations, many of the Singaporean ministers’ speeches touched on social issues. Most touched on the theme of preserving national cohesiveness in the face of the income divide, and other challenges Singapore faces as it dives head-on into globalisation.

In his National Day message, Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong observed: “Whether we like it or not, every Singaporean is now competing against the rest of the world.”

Earlier this month, Deputy Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, the son of the architect of modern Singapore, Lee Kuan Yew, kicked off a debate about Singapore’s social values when he said that Singaporeans must change their social attitudes to respect workers no matter what job they do.

Lee observed that although many companies have been creating new jobs this year, many employees have also been retrenched. These retrenched workers, usually more than 50 years old, are finding it difficult to get new jobs given the demand for specialised skills such as those in information technology.

“Not all workers retrenched from an electronics factory may succeed in learning to work in a wafer-fab plant,” he said. “Yet, they may be unwilling to become a sweeper or cleaner, jobs which pays well and which they can do.”

Such manual jobs here are done by foreign workers mainly from Bangladesh, India and Thailand.

Lee argues that older Singaporeans could more easily take on jobs now considered menial — if social attitudes are changed so that workers are respected regardless of the jobs they hold.

“Almost a quarter of the population here today are foreign workers,” Pradip Ganesh, a Singaporean nearing his 50th birthday, pointed out to IPS.

“With these foreign workers highly visible and very much in the public spotlight, there is widespread resentment among the grassroots that they are not being well looked after by the government,” he explained.

“This could spill over to the political domain with dire consequences to the government’s popularity,” he warned.

The ruling People’s Action Party (PAP), which has ruled Singapore since its birth in 1965, is well known for its political foresight.

Thus, perhaps its realisation of these danger signals has prompted the government to encourage public debate in the media about Singapore’s social values.

In recent months, there have been many conferences and seminars organised by think tanks like the Institute of Policy Studies to discuss social issues. The government has also held a number of closed-door dialogue sessions known as “Feedback Units” with the grassroots communities.

All these have been well attended, and some have reportedly featured vigorous and hard-hitting debates.

Internet-savvy Singaporeans have also hit chatrooms and discussions forums to debate these issues — often staying anonymous or adopting fancy pseudonyms.

Responding to those who blamed the government for failing to bridge the income gap in Singapore, Home Affairs Minister Wong Kan Seng pointed out that the gap between the rich and poor “has never been eradicated by any government anywhere”.

He argued that the best solution was for the government and the community at large to cooperate to look after those who were left behind, while ensuring that the best be rewarded for their efforts.

In recent weeks, the results of a spate of public surveys on Singaporean social values have been published in the newspapers.

These include such topics as how materialistic Singaporeans are, why career-minded women in their mid-30s are not interested in marriage, should foreign domestic workers be better treated, and why Singaporeans shun volunteer work.

One telephone survey done by the English-language daily ‘Straits Times’ found that most people here value their families and will attend to their needs, but one in three also said that they will not consider doing any community work at all.

“Contributing to society” ranked last in a choice of four life goals, trailing behind happy families, making more money and interesting careers.

In another survey among teenagers, the newspaper found that money ranks high for Singapore’s teeners because they need the new gadgets of the Internet age, such as mobile phones, pagers, Palm Pilots, mini-disc players and Internet-enabled phones.

“We’re a very status-conscious society,” said 20-year-old Andy Lim. “People look at what you have and size you up accordingly.”

“Singaporeans look down on people who do not belong to their social class,” said construction supervisor Muhamad Mustaffa, adding that engineers, clerks and office girls in his workplace never mix with him and can sometimes be very rude to him.

In recent months, the treatment of foreign domestic workers have been in the spotlight with exposure in the media of how they are barred from certain social clubs where their employers are members.

Also, a number of court cases have been filed involving abuse of domestic workers, with the accused being women of high social standing.

There are some 100,000 foreign domestic workers here, mainly from Indonesia, the Philippines and Sri Lanka.

Associate professor Brenda Yeoh of the National University of Singapore says that many people would argue that “putting people in their right place” contributes to social cohesion.

But she rejects this argument, saying this was precisely the rationale put forward to justify apartheid for so long.

Advises Yeoh: “A globalising Singapore will need to recalibrate the arithmetic of place to achieve a truly cosmopolitan social and economic landscape.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags