Asia-Pacific, Headlines | Analysis

POLITICS-SOUTH ASIA: Little Hope From Kashmir Talks

Analysis - M. Venugopala Rao

NEW DELHI, Aug 2 2000 (IPS) - The stage appears to have been set for a first-time dialogue between the Indian government and Kashmiri separatist militant groups, but it is unlikely to be substantive.

The ‘cease-fire’ called by one of the most feared Kashmiri militant outfits has raised hopes across the world. But the massacre of nearly 50 people Tuesday in two separate attacks by militants in India’s troubled state has also put a question mark over the latest peace bid.

Close observers of the Kashmir dispute that has embittered India-Pakistan ties for half a century, point to the many complications and contradictions to be resolved before such talks can take off.

Not least among these is the lack of agreement among the militants themselves that is seen to have led to Tuesday’s incidents in which 30 Hindu pilgrims and 18 migrant labourers were gunned down by armed separatists in the hill resort town of Pahalgam and Anantnag district.

The complications are also caused by the Indian government being constrained to talk within the framework of the constitution.

Confounding the situation is the perceived ineffective hold of the military regime of Pakistan over these groups.

Although Islamabad has demanded a place in these talks, New Delhi is cool to the suggestion. However, former Indian Foreign Secretary J.N. Dixit and other diplomats suggest that “we will end up talking to them”.

The fact that India and Pakistan are moving toward a dialogue that could dispel fears of a major South Asian conflict carrying a nuclear shadow, is attributed in some measure, as Dixit puts it, to “general international pressure”.

“Circumstantial evidence” suggests active and continuing U.S. interest in defusing the high tension in the area before and after last summer’s undeclared Kargil war, says Muchkund Dubey, another former foreign secretary.

There is speculation within the diplomatic community and the major political parties, that Indian Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee would be under some pressure to present an agenda of peace in South Asia when he addresses the U.S Congress in September.

However, the lack of consensus within India’s amorphous ruling coalition and within the country’s larger political establishment, on the question of Kashmir and peace with Pakistan, complicates New Delhi’s task.

After accepting and reciprocating the cease-fire offer by the Hizbul Mujahideen, the Vajpayee government has shown signs of confusion that have upset the Hizbul.

The public statement by a top Vajpayee aide that the talks would be within the framework of the constitution, has caused the Hizbul to threaten to call off the ceasefire.

In offering the dialogue, New Delhi had dropped its usual insistence on adhering to constitutional guidelines that state that Kashmir is an inalienable part of India.

Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Farooq Abdullah, a Vajpayee ally, too has said that the talks would be “unconditional”. Insisting on talks within the constitutional framework would only block the dialogue, he has declared.

Kashmiri separatists too face major problems in evolving a consensus on the position they should adopt in the dialogue with India.

The Pakistan-based United Jehad council that groups 14 militant groups, several of them foreign mercenaries, has asked the Hizbul to withdraw its cease-fire offer and rejoin the “holy war” in Kashmir.

But Hizbul ‘supreme leader’ Syed Salahuddin, who is based in Pakistan, has endorsed the cease-fire as a “tactical” move.

Press reports from Pakistan relate the Hizbul move to “back channel” consultations between Indian and Pakistani emissaries. Confirming such consultations, Dixit says these are useful before formal talks take place at the diplomatic level.

But New Delhi would have to resolve major issues of domestic political contention for any dialogue with Pakistan to acquire substantial form and content.

The foremost among them is to give workable shape and substance to the intractable question of internal autonomy promised to Jammu and Kashmir several decades ago.

Since the state joined India in 1947 “under unique circumstances”, as Dubey recalls, a special dispensation was provided for Kashmir in the Indian constitution. Barring defence, external affairs and communications all other matters were left to the state legislature.

This autonomy, diluted over the years, is now sought to be restored by a resolution passed late June by the state assembly.

It was the outright rejection of this demand by the Vajpayee government, that, ironically, provided a window of opportunity for New Delhi and Indian Parliament to address the need of ending the Kashmiri alienation and the drift to separation.

Fears that this could lead to similar demands from other parts of the country like the north-east and the south, should not block what Dubey calls “a new political contract” with the people of Kashmir for their “emotional integration into Indian nationalism”.

Dubey fears that failure in this regard could lead to the “super imposition” of an artificial solution like a proposed religion-based trifurcation of Jammu and Kashmir into Hindu- majority Jammu, Muslim-majority Kashmir Valley and Buddhist Ladakh. But these fears are not widely shared.

Legal and social developments in the state and the rest of the country, since the subcontinent’s partition by departing British rulers, makes such a division of Kashmir an absurd idea.

This would be a reversal of India’s aim of promoting a multi- religious, multi-ethnic and democratic society, say other diplomats and constitutional experts.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags