Sunday, November 22, 2026
Jim Lobe
- US President Bill Clinton Friday announced that he will leave to his successor the decision on deploying a controversial anti-ballistic missile (ABM) defence system that Russia, China, and some US allies steadfastly oppose.
In an address at Georgetown University here, Clinton stressed that the system, which is designed to protect US national territory from a missile attack by so-called “rogue states,” was technically sufficiently advanced to warrant its deployment.
He said he would continue testing of the components of the system over the five months remaining in his term, adding that he still believed that a ” national missile defence” system was both desirable and technically feasible.
However, he said, he “could not conclude that we have enough confidence in the technology or the entire system to move forward to deployment.”
The decision was hailed by arms-control and peace groups which, like many foreign nations, have strongly opposed any ABM system due to its likely impact on prospects for international arms- control reduction.
“President Clinton has come to the common-sense conclusion that national missile defence is not ready for prime time,” according to Daryl Kimball, director of the Coalition to Reduce Nuclear Dangers.
“This is the right call at the right time, and the President should be applauded for it,” said Tom Collina, an arms-control specialist at the Union for Concerned Scientists (UCS).
Clinton’s decision was actually previewed Aug. 11 when the Pentagon’s chief weapons tester advised the administration that the NMD system, which was slated to cost some 60 billion dollars, could not be fully operational by the 2005 target date.
That was the date set by the administration for full deployment of a limited NMD system after US intelligence agencies concluded that North Korea, whose missile technology is considered the most advanced among “rogues” such as Iran and Iraq, would attain the capability of launching an inter-continental missile by that time.
To protect against such a North Korean threat, construction of a new, hi-tech radar station in the Aleutian Islands of Alaska would have to begin by next spring, and bids for the project were scheduled to go out by December. The president’s decision essentially puts off final deployment of the system to at least 2006.
Russia and some agencies within the administration had argued that starting construction on the radar would technically violate the ABM Treaty signed by the United States and the Soviet Union in 1972.
“The President has realised that a decision to deploy or even initiate construction of a key anti-missile radar in Alaska would be seen as a unilateral decision to pursue deployment and would needlessly provoke immediate adverse consequences in our relations with Russia, China, and our NATO allies – who oppose deployment – and undermine prospects for further nuclear arms reductions,” said Stephen Young, deputy director of the Coalition.
When he first committed his administration to developing a limited NMD system, Clinton said the decision to deploy would be based on four criteria, including the urgency of the threat, the foreign- policy implications, the cost, and the technical feasibility.
In his remarks Friday, he stressed that the technology was the major reason for his decision and that he did not believe that a limited NMD would destabilise the international order or the current nuclear balance among nations.
Indeed, of the last three major tests of the system, in which “kill vehicles” launched from missiles were supposed to seek out and destroy incoming missiles, only one was tagged a success by the Pentagon. Even that one was denounced as badly flawed by missile experts who charged that it was essentially fixed in advance.
Critics say that the system’s testing programme is fundamentally flawed in that it does not sufficiently test whether the system can discriminate between real warheads on incoming missiles and decoys which could be produced cheaply and easily by potential adversaries. “This programme is a lemon,” said the Coalition’s Young.
Still, the deployment of an NMD system is favoured by both major party candidates Gore and Bush, in part because polls have shown consistently over the past decade that a strong majority of the public either believes the United States already has a system capable of protecting it from enemy missiles or wants one if it doesn’t.
Of the two major candidates, Gore has backed the Clinton administration’s limited NMD programme. In a statement issued after Clinton’s remarks, he said he “welcome(s) the opportunity to be more certain that these technologies actually work together properly.”
Bush, on the other hand, favours expanding the proposed system of ground-based rockets by adding sea-based and possibly air- and space-based interceptors similar to those proposed by the Reagan Administration’s ill-fated “Star Wars” programme. He has also stressed that he would proceed with deployment of NMD without regard to its consequences on the ABM treaty or other arms control agreements and negotiations.
In a statement issued after Clinton’s announcement, Bush declared that the president’s decision “underscores the fact that for seven years, the Clinton-Gore administration has failed to strengthen America’s defences.”
But other prominent Republicans said Clinton probably made the right decision. “We’ve ended up with a system that (about which there) is real doubt that it can do the job,” said Brent Scowcroft, former national security adviser under Bush’s father.
Scowcroft, who favours a sea-based system capable of intercepting enemy missiles during their boost phase, noted that recent developments in North Korea – notably its unprecedented rapprochement with the South – have reduced the possibility of a threat from that quarter as early as 2005.