Asia-Pacific, Headlines | Analysis

POLITICS-PHILIPPINES: Protracted War Looms in Muslim South

Analysis - Marites Danguilan Vitug

MANILA, Sep 25 2000 (IPS) - By ordering a massive government assault against the Muslim extremist group, Abu Sayyaf, in the southern Philippines, President Joseph Estrada is sending a strong signal that he is out to crush the kidnap-for-ransom group.

The Philippine military, which started bombing the lair of the Abu Sayyaf in Jolo, capital of Sulu province, and surrounding villages Sep 16, has not ceased its offensives.

Since then, two hostages — French journalists — have fled to freedom. From their accounts, they escaped from their captors.

Three Malaysians, who were recently kidnapped from Pandanan island off Sabah, and an American are still in captivity. Leaders of the Abu Sayyaf, which means ‘bearer of the sword’, are still at large but the military has reported the arrest of several members.

The Abu Sayyaf will definitely use the remaining hostages as bargaining chips. But Estrada has refused any truce nor negotiation with the group — which says it seeks an Islamic state in the Philippine south but is often described as mere bandits after the recent kidnappings.

Meanwhile, thousands of Sulu residents are caught in the crossfire and civilian casualties have been reported. Many have evacuated to the nearby province of Zamboanga. (The military has banned journalists from entering Sulu.)

But the government has few victories to show for its assault.

Instead of opting for a swift, tight, and clandestine on-the- ground operation to rescue the remaining hostages, the Armed Forces chose to rain bombs. Many expected that the military would adopt a surgical approach, using a scalpel, rather than a bolo, as a long sharp knife is called here.

After all, the Abu Sayyaf has a core of about a few hundred members. The rest of its followers — estimates say more than 1,000 — joined because of the lure of money that came after the series of ransom payments paid to the group in the past four months.

Libya reportedly paid 12 million dollars for the release of mostly foreign hostages last month. Even before that, Filipino officials estimated that the Abu Sayyaf had already gotten 245,000 U.S. dollars in similar payments for other hostages.

Many of the newer recruits were hired to secure the hostages, which, at their peak, reached more than 30.

At the end of the day, the military assault will leave Sulu, already one of the poorest provinces in the Philippines, even more devastated.

In the early 1970s, the scenic island was the site of most intense fighting between the military and the Moro National Liberation Front (MNLF), then the main Muslim rebel group. Much of Jolo was razed to the ground during the conflict.

Since then, sporadic encounters have taken place. It was only in 1996 that the MNLF entered into a peace settlement with the Philippine government under then President Fidel Ramos.

Still, it will take many years to rebuild the place. Sulu, a Muslim-dominated province in this mainly Catholic country, has one of the lowest literacy rates. Infant and maternal mortality rates are high. Residents have little access to health services and basic needs like potable water. Farm to market roads are unpaved.

While Sulu is not the birthplace of the Abu Sayyaf, its economic conditions are similar to the adjacent island of Basilan, where the ragtag band of self-proclaimed Islamic rebels was organised in 1991.

More than half of the population of Basilan, also a predominantly Muslim province, live in poverty.

A native of Basilan, Abdurajak Janjalani, founded the Abu Sayyaf after he came back from religious education in Libya. The group pushed for an independent Islamic state, calling for a return to the pure practice of the faith.

But they failed to match their rhetoric with their deeds. Critics say they twisted Islam and used it to serve their interests.

In 1995, they raided a town in Mindanao, burned the market, looted stores and the banks, and killed civilians. Since then, they had been engaged in kidnapping-for-ransom operations.

However, when Janjalani, said to be a charismatic leader and preacher, was killed by the police in 1998, the Abu Sayyaf dwindled.

The military and local government officials dismissed the group as a spent force and became complacent — only to be surprised early this year when the Abu Sayyaf revived itself and held hostage teachers and schoolchildren in Basilan.

They also killed a Catholic priest and some of their captives. In April, they crossed to the neighbouring country of Malaysia and seized foreign hostages from a resort in Sabah.

Now, the Abu Sayyaf, for the first time since its founding, gained extensive international media attention. However, it remains a short-term threat, a criminal group that government says it is determined to deal with severely.

Meantime, the focus on the Abu Sayyaf has fogged the fact that there is a more serious insurgent force in Mindanao, the 15,000- strong Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF), a breakaway group from the MNLF.

An ideological group, the MILF has been fighting for secession since the 1980s. They reject the Abu Sayyaf’s tactics and condemn them for giving Islam a bad name.

Estrada’s government is thus fighting a war on two fronts: with the Abu Sayyaf and the MILF. In both, it is mishandling the situation.

Early this year, an impatient Estrada called off peace talks with the MILF and unleashed the military against its fighters.

For the first time in 25 years, the southern island of Mindanao saw the longest and most intense fighting between rebel forces and government troops. The military took over the main camps of the MILF — and the rebels have now shifted to guerrilla tactics.

A protracted war with the MILF will thus take place in Mindanao, whatever victories are claimed by the Estrada government.

At the same time, the Philippine military, with its decrepit vessels, will continue chasing after the Abu Sayyaf, awash in ransom money and equipped with powerful speed boats.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags