Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Debbie Singh
- Land ownership has caused much ethnic and internal tension in the Pacific Islands in recent years, as indigenous peoples chafe at how land has been managed by the state and colonialists in this small region of seven million people.
A classic example of this has been the internal conflict between the peoples of the Guadalcanal and Malaita provinces in the Solomon Islands, which has resulted in mass bloodshed and violence in early June.
Land and ethnic issues were also used to justify acts of mass destruction and human rights violations by rebels who staged Fiji’s civilian coup on May 19 — and takeover that has since resulted in a change in the country’s government.
These two cases have prompted many to ask where the real roots of ethnic unrest lie in the South Pacific.
“The real cause of the conflict has been the land issue,” Phillip Solodie Funifaka, general secretary of the Solomon Islands Christian Association said in an interview here.
Funifaka also spoke at a four-day regional meeting on indigenous rights in the Pacific in September, jointly organised by the World Council of Churches and Pacific Conference of Churches in Suva.
“Most economic development takes place on the island of Guadalcanal but the majority of workers are Malaitan,” he said, referring to tensions that erupted after Guadalcanal militants sought to drive out settlers from another island, Malaita, that they said were dominating government and business and taking over land.
A ceasefire is now in place in the Solomon Islands, and peace talks ongoing aboard a New Zealand navy ship off Honiara, the country’s capital located in Guadalcanal island.
“The people of Guadalcanal did not agree with the method used by foreigners (Malaitans) on a land settlement. This was raised but was ignored by the government at the time which resulted in violence and tension,” Funifaka said.
In June 1999, former Fiji prime minister and leader of the 1987 coup in Fiji Sitiveni Rabuka and a Commonwealth representative were called into the Solomon Islands to act as mediators in the conflict.
In January, Malaitans seized control of the country’s armory from the people of Guadalcanal, leaving the regional and international community at a loss to find a resolution. Killings of both Malaitans and Guadalcanal people also followed.
But where state, international and regional diplomacy had failed, respite came from an almost unlikely, although unsurprising, source.
Churches and non-government organisations came to the forefront of negotiations, drawing on tradition, religion and the Pacific way of consensus in an attempt to seek resolution to a situation spinning out of control in a region steeped in religion, culture and tradition.
“All the Churches in the Solomon Islands then came together as liaison between the two groups and requested them to lay down their arms and have dialogue,” Funifaka explained.
“Women’s groups met with soldiers, mothers talked to their sons and about 300 boys returned home. The churches were also very instrumental in the ceasefire agreement which has now been signed,” Funifaka said.
“It appears that the only authority accepted by the dissenting groups was that of the Church and other groups,” he added.
Tevita Nawadra Banivanua, Fiji representative and general- secretary of the South Pacific Association of Theological Schools (SPATS), agrees with Funifaka on the role of the Church in peace negotiations.
However, Banivanua says that the land struggle is not the same in the Melanesian and Polynesian sub-regions of the Pacific, as he says Polynesians are not as affected by change and appear freer from struggle in comparison to Melanesians.
“Melanesians have a way of identifying themselves with the land and also have the aspect of provincialism to deal with,” he said.
“Colonialism has restructured land laws which to fit structural adjustment programmes and these have worked against indigenous people,” Banivaua added, looking into differing conceptions of land between indigenous folk and other peoples.
“These were the first structural adjustment programmes which islanders had to deal with,” he said.
“In countries like Fiji, Vanuatu, the Solomon Islands and Papua New Guinea what lies below six feet of the earth’s surface is deemed state land, therefore, minerals and so forth are seen as national property. Indigenous people are not consulted about what lies below six feet.”
“However, changing values have meant that more indigenous people are questioning this as we believe that the land includes trees, soil and everything under it. We want ownership of all of it, not just a part,” Banivanua said.
On May 19 coup in Fiji — where land was named the main reason behind a rebellion laced with ethnic and civil tension — he said the coup had “brought forth new ways of looking at things”.
“The indigenous Fijian people felt they had been deprived and only a few with the traditional Fijian set-up were benefiting (from access to resources),” he added.
Ethnic tensions have been simmering in Fiji between ethnic Fijians and Indian Fijians and the coup rebels pointed to the land leases held by ethnic Fijians, many of them for Fiji’s key export sugar, as a sign of major economic clout.
Forty-four percent of Fiji’s 800,000 people are ethnic Indian, and the unseated government of Mahendra Chaudhry was the country’s first Indo-Fijian government elected under a multi-ethnic constitution.
“We must also make room for minority groups in the country and I believe in affirmative pluralism or the search for a common good. We need to affirm our differences and search for practices which benefit everyone,” Banivanua said.
Echoing the need for churches to involve themselves in peace efforts is Eugenio Poma, a former Bolivian bishop and now coordinator of the Indigenous People’s Programme at the World Council of Churches (WCC) in Geneva.
“The WCC feels that indigenous people should voice their own cries themselves. They have been oppressed for so long and their views have not been heard by the Church or state,” Poma said.
“Traditionally, indigenous people have not been part of the decision-making process in Churches and states in many world regions,” he conceded.