Sunday, November 22, 2026
Jim Lobe
- The Republican-led House of Representatives Wednesday signed off on a 2001 foreign-aid bill that includes most of the requests made by President Bill Clinton, including debt relief for the world’s poorest nations, more money for fighting AIDS, and fewer conditions on US population programmes overseas.
The package was hailed as major victories by debt-relief and population advocates, in particular.
“We’re pleased as punch,” said Seth Amgott, an analyst here with Oxfam International, a leader in the broad coalition of groups and celebrities who lobbied for debt relief. He noted that, with the Senate’s approval, the debt-relief package promised by the Group of Seven major donor countries at last year’s Cologne Summit, will be fully funded through 2002.
“This is an important shot in the arm,” said one official in the World Bank which, with the International Monetary Fund (IMF), is overseeing the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) initiative, as the debt-relief programme’s formal title.
The Senate is expected to approve the same 14.9 billion dollar aid bill by Friday as one of its last acts before Congress adjourns in advance of next month’s national elections.
While some senators have indicated they intend to object to some elements of the package, it has already been cleared by a House-Senate conference committee, making it more difficult to amend.
Clinton originally had asked Congress for about 15.1 billion dollars in foreign aid next year, but, as of last month, each house had separately approved bills that fell 1.7 billion dollars below that total. The most important shortfalls included debt relief, appropriations for multilateral financial agencies, like the World Bank, AIDS funding, and refugee and migration assistance.
But Clinton vowed to veto any package that fell so short, and, in subsequent negotiations with Congressional Republicans, succeeded in restoring most of the cuts.
The United States is among the world’s biggest aid providers in terms of total assistance, but it provides the least of all major donors in per capita terms, and, in real terms, Washington provides only about half the aid that it provided 15 years ago.
Moreover, the largest recipient of US aid is Israel, whose per capita income rivals that of some European countries. Israel will receive almost 20 percent of the 14.9 billion dollars approved for next year. Altogether, Israel and those Arab countries which have peace accords with the Jewish state receive more than one-third of the US aid budget, or more than five billion dollars.
The rest of Washington’s bilateral aid programme goes mostly to countries of Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union, and, to a lesser extent to sub-Saharan Africa, and to anti-drug efforts in South America. Most of the balance is devoted to multilateral agencies, including the United Nations and its specialised arms, the World Bank, and regional development banks.
Most of the controversy surrounding this year’s aid package focused on debt relief and the perennial problem of US funding of population programmes overseas.
Clinton had asked Congress to approve 435 million dollars for 2000 and 2001 as Washington’s contribution to the HIPC initiative which is supposed to reduce the combined debt of 33 of the world’s poorest countries by some 90 billion dollars – much of it owed to multilateral agencies – over the life of the programme.
Beneficiaries may qualify by implementing far-reaching economic reforms and agreeing to devote most of the resulting savings to health, education and other social services. Eleven countries – most of them in Africa – have so far gained at least some relief, and the Bank and the IMF say they hope 20 of the 33 will have qualified by the end of this year.
But the programme has been partially held up by the delay in securing US funding. All other donors have paid in their contributions.
Initially, the Republican leadership in both houses was hostile to the idea, approving only a fraction of Clinton’s request. But a diverse coalition, led by grassroots development groups like Oxfam and Jubilee 2000 and including Pope John Paul II, right-wing televangelist Pat Robertson, well- respected economist Jeffrey Sachs, and the Irish rock star, Bono, waged a high-profile pressure campaign on recalcitrant lawmakers which produced results over the weeks and months. Indeed, Bono, head of the rock group U-2, became a constant visitor to Capitol Hill and a regular feature subject in the city’s newspapers.
In the end, the Republican leadership caved in and approved the full request subject to only one condition: those countries which receive relief under HIPC be deemed ineligible to receive multilateral loans to finance major construction projects for a period of two years. It rejected demands by Senate Banking Committee Chairman, Republican Phil Gramm, that additional conditions be attached.
“Congress decided the richest country in the history of the world can afford to forgive debts to pay for new schools, childhood vaccination, and AIDS prevention for the poorest people on earth,” said Raymond Offenheiser, president of Oxfam America.
In another victory for anti-debt forces, however, the compromise included a requirement that the US representative on the IMF and Bank boards oppose any effort by those agencies to condition loans to countries on their adoption of user fees for basic health care or education services.
“This is the first step toward eliminating one of the most destructive components of the austerity programmes the IMF and World Bank impose on most of the countries of Africa, Asia, and Latin America,” said Njoki Njehu, director of the ’50 Years Is Enough’ network, a major critic of Bank- and IMF-funded structural adjustment programmes (SAPs).
The anti-debt coalition was also successful in persuading Congress to increase funding for AIDS/HIV prevention programmes, especially in Africa, by about 50 percent, to some 300 million dollars. It also approved a total 963 million dollars earmarked for child survival and disease programmes – 248 million more than last year.
On population programmes, which has been caught up in domestic abortion politics for years, the Republican leadership agreed to increase funding from 385 million dollars in 2000 to 425 million dollars in 2001 and drop current restrictions on US funding overseas groups which perform abortions or lobby their home governments to ease anti-abortion laws.
In exchange, Clinton agreed that none of the money appropriated for population programmes in fiscal 2001, which actually began Oct. 1, could be spent before next Feb. 15; that is, before the new president takes office.
It is widely assumed that, if Texas Gov. George W. Bush wins next month’s presidential election, he would re-instate the ‘Mexico City’ policy which prevailed under his father’s and Ronald Reagan’s administrations. Under that policy, groups which performed or recommended the use of abortion were barred from receiving any US aid.
In one of his first acts as president in 1993, Clinton ended that policy, but after the Republican sweep in the 1994 Congressional elections, he was forced by the Republican leadership to accept new restrictions a partial reinstatement of ‘Mexico City’.
“This compromise marks a reprieve from five years of funding cuts, free speech restrictions, delays, holds, audits, accusations, harassment and intimidation,” said Amy Coen, president of Population Action International (PAI), a family-planning advocacy group. “But, depending on the voters’ decision on Election Day, it may not be worth the paper it’s written on.”