Saturday, November 21, 2026
Thalif Deen
- The growing violence in the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem has once again revived a politically sensitive issue at the United Nations: the dividing line between a “terrorist” and a “freedom fighter”.
Syria and Lebanon, two hardline Middle Eastern neighbours, argue that rock-throwing Palestinians are freedom fighters battling to oust an occupying power. And any acts of violence by Palestinians are, therefore, justifiable acts against heavily armed Israelis.
Houssam Asaad Diab, the Lebanese delegate, told the UN’s Legal Committee, that Israel should never forget the fact that it occupies Arab lands contrary to the UN charter, international law and international humanitarian law. “Resistance to Israeli-occupation is not terrorism”, he asserted.
Ghassan Obeid of Syria pointed out that Israeli attacks had resulted in the deaths of 250 “Palestinian martyrs”.
The news media, he said, continue to show pictures of Israeli attacks on children, including the now famous image of a little boy who had been shot dead in the arms of his father. More recently, he said, a German doctor, who was not a “terrorist”, had also been killed.
But the Israeli delegate Aaron Jacob, citing last week’s bombing of a school bus and the detonation of a car bomb in the heart of Israel, argued that it was disingenuous in the extreme to portray the situation as attacks against defenceless Palestinian children.
“Israeli soldiers have been responding to 1,300 recorded armed attacks,” he said. Violence was not justifiable, he said, even if they were perpetrated in the name of national liberation.
As a result of the charges and counter-charges, the Legal Committee last week failed to obtain unanimous support for a draft resolution that condemned persistent worldwide acts of terrorism as criminal and unjustifiable – regardless of the objective.
The resolution, which also called for joint international action to eliminate terrorism, was adopted by a vote of 131 in favour to none against but with two abstentions (Syria and Lebanon). About 49 countries were not present at voting time.
The resolution, which will go before the General Assembly for ratification shortly, urges member states not to finance, encourage, provide training for, or otherwise support terrorist activities.
Diab said that Lebanon strongly condemned all acts of terrorism, including organised violence such as murder, the taking of hostages and aircraft hijacking. He said Israeli-occupation and actions against Palestinian civilians remained one of the worst forms of terrorism and must be condemned.
Diab also insisted that there should be a clear definition of terrorism, and that the criteria for that purpose must be established.
Lebanon’s position was that there should be a distinction between criminal terrorist acts and acts of people fighting against foreign occupation and for self-determination.
“It is the inalienable right of peoples to restore their independence and sovereignty,” he said, adding that the draft resolution before the committee did not reflect that viewpoint.
Meanwhile, Cuba advanced its own case when it pointed out the innumerable acts of terrorism against the country, mostly from Cuban exiles living in the United States. Soraya Elena Alvarez Nunez, the Cuban delegate, said these were acts organised and financed from the United States and whose citizens continued those activities with impunity.
“They are not allegations, but facts which can be backed up with evidence, including the names of the people involved and proof of their participation,” she added.
She said her country had suffered from terrorism for more than 40 years. More recently, she pointed out, there was an attempt on the life of President Fidel Castro during his participation in the Ibero-American summit.
She also said that Cuba supported UN efforts against terrorism and affirmed the central role of the General Assembly in the ongoing fight against terrorism.
Responding to the Cuban charge, US delegate Robert Rosenstock said the accusations were strangely out of place. “Terrorism is committed by individuals. States commit violations of international law,” he asserted.