Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

EDUCATION-VENEZUELA: Private Sector Calls for Dialogue on Reforms

Andrés Cañizález

CARACAS, Jan 8 2001 (IPS) - The Catholic Church and experts in education urged the Venezuelan government to open up a dialogue in search of a consensus on the imminent implementation of a measure that will give the state more power in its role as supervisor of the educational system.

“A broad-based dialogue is necessary in order to avoid errors and to enable all of us to contribute, from the unique perspective of each institution or sector, a grain of sand in the construction of a good educational system,” Archbishop Baltazar Porras, president of the Venezuelan Episcopal Conference, said on Sunday.

Porras, who has publicly disagreed with the government of Hugo Chávez on several occasions in the past, stated at the inauguration of a meeting of Venezuela’s bishops that “the state cannot impose education, nor tie the educational system to ideology.”

The archbishop was referring to the reach of a decree issued in late October by the Education Ministry, which created the post of roving supervisors with the power to intervene in schools in case of irregularities.

Private school associations protested the decision, which they see as part of an official policy to “control” the educational system or “tie it to ideology” in the framework of Chávez’s so-called “Bolivarian revolution” – which takes its name from South American liberator Simón Bolívar – aimed at overhauling the political system.

Porras’ call to dialogue was part of a controversy that has raged for several weeks, in which paid ads were taken out in the press and Education Minister Héctor Navarro delivered speeches, announcing that the new supervision process could begin to operate this month.

Orlando Albornoz, an education expert, said Monday that authorities “have lamentably handled this conflict in a clumsy manner, because they have forgotten about the importance of dialogue.

“It seems that Minister Navarro does not want to meet with those concerned, but he will have to do so,” said Albornoz, who headed the education office of the presidential commission on state reform in the mid-1990s.

Navarro explained that his decision was based on article 106 of the Bolivarian Constitution, in effect since late 1999, which stipulates that all private educational institutions must submit themselves to the strict oversight of the state.

“The idea is to create a level of supervisors who directly answer to the minister and report any irregularity that crops up in any centre of education,” he said.

The possible irregularities he cited were the charging of tuition in public institutions, poorly trained or bad teachers, school principals who misappropriate funds, or rundown schools.

Navarro said the government decision was adopted because today’s supervisors “do not supervise,” and because the cost of tuition had skyrocketed over the past two years.

He also denied that the new supervisors would be “handpicked,” explaining that they would be selected through a public competition.

The question of the new supervisors is the government’s most controversial decision in the area of education, and was protested by a large number of bodies, such as the National Association of Private Educational Institutes and the Venezuelan Chamber of Private Education.

But the government decree also covers other aspects, and appears to be the spearhead of a broader educational reform, as part of the process of sweeping political changes promoted by Chávez since he took office in February 1999.

Carlos Lanz, who directs the Education Ministry’s National Educational Project, said that “projects are starting to be designed here” as part of the new political process.

“There are new institutions, a new social tissue, and we want to recuperate the dignity of the citizenship, of shared interests and concerns,” he said.

Lanz categorically denied that the government was attempting to emulate Cuba’s educational system, and refuted rumours that parochial schools were about to be closed down.

Among the modifications proposed by the National Educational Project are the creation of a “scholastic government,” in which parents, representatives of the private and public educational systems and local communities will all play a key role.

Also expected is a flexibilisation of the educational curricula and study plans, new training programmes for teachers, and the overhauling of the Education Ministry’s bureaucratic structure.

Lanz, considered the Education Ministry’s leading ideologue, believes the “content of the study plans must be open and contextualised, just as the timetables and schedules…must respond to the needs and interests of the children, local communities and municipalities.”

With respect to dialogue with other concerned sectors, Lanz said the Education Ministry was willing to discuss aspects of the reform process. But he defended the predominant role played by the state in designing and guiding the country’s educational process.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags