Asia-Pacific, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

POLITICS: Taliban Move to Destroy Statues May Jeopardise Aid

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Mar 13 2001 (IPS) - The destruction of two ancient Buddha statues by the Taliban government is likely to have a serious negative impact on the humanitarian crisis in Afghanistan, UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan warned Monday.

“Obviously, some donors will be turned off. I do not think it is going to please them and I don’t think it is going to make it easier (for us) to raise money,” he said.

Japan, according to a published report last week, has already threatened to reduce aid to Afghanistan if the two statues in Bamiyan are destroyed.

Last year, the international medical aid organisation, Medecins Sans Frontieres, warned that international donor pledges to the country had fallen short of the estimated needs: only about 50 percent of the promised 300 million dollars in humanitarian aid was delivered in 2000.

Annan, who visited an Afghan refugee camp in neighbouring Pakistan Monday, said he was particularly concerned about the negative fall-out on the people of Afghanistan and on the one million internally displaced refugees.

“We have to think of the people, the people who are in a tragic, desperate situation, who had nothing to do with the decision to destroy the Buddha statues. And I think a hungry child is a hungry child, and we should do whatever we can to assist the people,” he added.

After a two-month field investigation last August, the United Nations concluded that UN economic sanctions imposed on Afghanistan in 1999 have caused severe hardships on the people – not on the country’s political leaders who were the real targets.

‘A significant impact of sanctions is the extent to which ordinary Afghans feel isolated and victimised,” the Office of the UN Co-ordinator for Afghanistan said in a report released last year.

Over the weekend, Annan met with the Foreign Minister of Afghanistan Wakil Ahmad Mutawakel who was quoted as saying: “The world was not concerned about Afghan refugees – but only about rocks and statues.”

The destruction of the ancient statues, he said, was an internal religious issue. “It was not aimed at challenging the world.”

Asked if the minister confirmed the destruction of the statues, Annan told reporters Monday: “Yes, I did discuss the statues with the foreign minister, and I walked away from the meeting not very encouraged.”

Basically, the minister confirmed that “all moveable statues have been destroyed, and that the destruction of the two Buddha statues had begun, but he could not tell me the status of the demolition”.

Annan also said that if they do carry through this “lamentable decision, I think they will be doing themselves a great deal of disservice, and they will be doing a great deal of disservice to Islam in whose name they claim to be doing this”.

“But I do not think anyone will accept that because not many, or hardly any, Islamic scholars or religious leaders have supported their position,” he noted.

On Friday, the 189-member UN General Assembly adopted, without a vote, a resolution that “strongly” urged the Taliban “to take immediate action to prevent the further destruction of the irreplaceable relicts, monuments and artefacts of Afghanistan’s cultural heritage.”

The draft resolution, which was co-sponsored by 93 of the 189 member states, said it was “deeply concerned and appalled” by the Taliban edict of Feb. 26 ordering the destruction of all statues and non-Islamic shrines in Afghanistan, “and by the deliberate ongoing destruction of these relics and monuments, which belong to the common heritage of mankind”.

Ambassador Dieter Kastrup of Germany, who introduced the draft resolution, told delegates that Islamic regimes had protected the cultural heritage of Afghanistan, including the unique monumental statues at Bamiyan, for 1,400 years.

“Islam had a centuries-old tradition of wisdom and tolerance, which the barbarous destruction contradicted, sending false ideas about that religion,” he added.

Ambassador Kamalesh Sharma of India said that the towering Bamiyan Buddhas stand witness to the pride of the Afghan people and their tradition.

“The Taliban edict constitutes an assault not only on Afghan tradition but also on the common heritage of mankind and the very idea of civilised living.”

Currently, only three countries, Pakistan, the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and Saudi Arabia, maintain diplomatic relations with the Taliban government.

Although the Taliban controls over 90 percent of the territory in Afghanistan, it has been shut out of the UN General Assembly. The UN seat is still being held by the ousted government of President Burhanuddin Rabani.

Afghanistan has not only suffered the consequences of a prolonged military conflict and a fast-spreading drought, but also of grinding poverty and harsh restrictions imposed on the movement of people, particularly women.

The sanctions, imposed by the Security Council in November 1999, called for a ban on all international flights by the Kabul-based Ariana Airlines, and a freeze on the bank accounts of the Taliban regime.

The sanctions were imposed in an attempt to persuade the Taliban regime to hand over Osama bin Laden, who is accused by the United States of masterminding the bombings of the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania in 1998, and military facilities in Saudi Arabia in 1995 and 1996.

Last December, the 15-member Security Council imposed additional sanctions on Afghanistan despite strong reservations by Annan. The only two countries abstaining on the vote were China and Malaysia.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags