Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

DEVELOPMENT-INDONESIA: Few Excited by New Anti-Poverty Drive

Kanis Dursin

JAKARTA, Apr 27 2001 (IPS) - Call Ani a cynic. A resident of one of Jakarta’s slum areas, the young mother of one shows no excitement over the news that the Indonesian government has just launched a new body tasked to help reduce the number of poor people.

Even after it is explained to her that the Coordinating Board on Alleviation of Poverty (BKPK) could radically change Indonesia’s policies toward the poor, Ani remains unmoved.

“The government has always been pledging to help our less fortunate brothers,” she says, “but nothing happened.”

The coordinating board, however, is optimistic that the new strategy will succeed. After all, its officials argue, this time around, the government is engaging the help of local administrations, business people and non-government organisations (NGOs) in the state’s poverty alleviation programmes.

In the past, such programmes were designed and carried out by specific government departments only.

But agricultural economist H S Dillon, head of the BKPK after its creation by the Wahid government in late March, says that from now on, “local governments, NGOs and the poor people themselves will be given matching grants if they work effectively”.

“The magnitude of the country’s poverty is such that it is no longer possible for the government to eradicate it alone,” he explains.

Since the economic crisis hit Indonesia in 1997, the number of Indonesians living under the poverty line has soared, from 11 percent of the total population, or 22.5 million, in 1996 to 24 percent or 49.5 million in 1999.

Today, 25 percent of the country’s 213 million people are considered poor. This means more than 50 million Indonesians live in absolute poverty. The effects of this reversal of some of Indonesia’s gains in human development in recent decades could be felt for generations to come, experts say.

The World Bank and the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) have donated 300,000 U.S. dollars for the operational costs of the coordinating body on poverty, which will be accountable to Vice President Megawati Sukarnoputri.

Its main task is to draw up the framework of all poverty eradication programmes, monitor and coordinate their implementation. It will also do pro-poor policy analysis and develop new fiscal instruments for poverty reduction, as well as promote private sector partnership.

Moreover, says Dillon, “we will make sure that all poverty eradication funds reach targeted communities, the poorest of the poor, and prevent possible leakage”.

The BKPK head, however, refuses to elaborate on the amount of money allocated or the source of the matching grants.

Data provided by the Central Bureau of Statistics (BPS) reveal that just about half of the nine basic goods channeled through the social safety net programme, put up to help the poor during the Asian economic crisis, went to poor families — 53 percent in urban areas and 48.66 percent in rural areas.

The remaining half went to either middle- or upper-class families.

The government launched the social safety net programme in 1998, using assistance funds from the bailout moneyn it got from institutions like the World Bank, the Asian Development Bank and the International Monetary Fund.

The programme covers food security, job creation and sustainable income generation, social protection to access to public health and education services, and support for small and medium-sized enterprises.

All these programmes were designed by the central government and carried out by departments like the National Education Ministry, Health and Social Welfare Ministry, and Public Works Ministry. “The departments acted like little kings,” says Dillon. “They had their own programmes and projects and did not want to be coordinated.”

To make matters worse, whatever small successes the government has had in alleviating widespread poverty and delivering services have been greatly undermined by climatic, financial, social and political crises that have beleaguered Indonesia since 1997.

Millions of Indonesians thus still live on the brink of survival. A similar fragility is evident in other areas such as nutrition, health and education, according to a report by the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF).

An increase in poverty exacerbates malnutrition condition among children under five years old. The UNICEF report suggests that six million of Indonesia’s 23 million children under five are under-weight and malnourished.

At least eight percent or 1.8 million children under five are suffering from severe malnutrition. Some remote rural districts in Sulawesi, Kalimantan and East Nusa Tenggara report up to 50 percent total malnutrition.

More than half of the under-fives have ‘hidden hunger’ deficiencies of vitamin A, iron and zinc. This has far-reaching and long-lasting consequences, including the perpetuation of poverty through productivity losses caused by physical and mental impairment.

In addition, despite the government’s policy of compulsory education up to the age of 15 years old, over six million children aged between six and 15 years are not in school. Data suggest that they never enrolled or dropped out.

Many of them are now engaged in hazardous or exploitative child labour. About 150,000 children live homeless and unprotected in the streets of Indonesia’s major cities. An estimated 40,000 are child sex workers.

Meanwhile, some activists seem to echo Ani’s pessimism when polled for their views on the BKPK.

Urban Poor Consortium (UPC) chair Wardah Hafidz welcomes the setting up of BKPK, but questions the board’s policy to address the rampant corruption, collusion and nepotism problems. “Dillon’s concept sounds fine, but how will it tackle the core problem – the rampant corruption, collusion and nepotism?” she asks.

Activist Kamala Chandrakirana, head of the Indonesian Workshop for Structural Poverty Eradication, also remarks that the biggest challenge for the BKPK would be to gain trust from the people, who have been disappointed by previous poverty eradication programmes.

She observes: “No matter how sophisticated poverty eradication programmes are, they are doomed to fail if the people themselves do not believe that this body is a genuine partner in eradicating poverty.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

DEVELOPMENT-INDONESIA: Few Excited by New Anti-Poverty Drive

Kanis Dursin

JAKARTA, Apr 27 2001 (IPS) - Call Ani a cynic. A resident of one of Jakarta’s slum areas, the young mother of one shows no excitement over the news that the Indonesian government has just launched a new body tasked to help reduce the number of poor people.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags