Saturday, November 21, 2026
Jim Lobe
- Despite renewed pledges to press for a Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA) accord by 2005 as a top priority for his administration, US President George W. Bush will attend this weekend’s Summit of the Americas in Quebec City without as strong a hand as he would have liked.
Almost three months after taking office, his administration has not yet even drafted a bill to submit to Congress that would grant him “fast- track” – renamed “trade-promotion” – authority to negotiate the FTAA, although in a speech to the Organisation of American States (OAS) here Tuesday he said he was “confident” of winning such authority by year’s end.
The sharp slowdown in the US economy – which may even be moving into recession – could also strengthen domestic protectionist pressures that had largely been held at bay during the country’s longest economic expansion in history during Bill Clinton’s administration.
And, with as many as 25,000 protestors expected to demonstrate their opposition to FTAA surrounding the walled old city, where the 34 leaders attending the Summit will be gathered, the event itself could well become the kind of public-relations disaster that took place at the 1999 World Trade Organisation (WTO) meeting in Seattle which deterred Clinton from even seeking fast-track authority during his last year in office.
Indeed, compared to the first Summit of the Americas in Miami, the mood surrounding the Quebec meeting is downright pessimistic.
“We have to tone (down) our expectations,” according to Bruce Stokes, a trade specialist at the influential Council on Foreign Relations (CFR) here. “The best that can be hoped for is a political push to move forward as rapidly as possible” on negotiating the FTAA, he said.
First raised by Bush’s father in 1990, the FTAA will be the top agenda item at the weekend Summit, George W.’s first multilateral meeting since his inauguration in January. In that respect, all eyes will be focused on the US president and how committed he appears to be to negotiating a final accord by the target date, 2005.
“The result (of the Summit) will depend very much on what (he) says,” according to Peter Hakim, head of the Inter-American Dialogue, a hemispheric think-tank here. “So far, the United States hasn’t given enough of a signal that it is really ready to be a partner.”
Indeed, most free-traders who strongly favour an FTAA have been disappointed that Bush’s campaign rhetoric – which featured strong expressions of commitment to FTAA – has not been backed up by concrete action.
Unlike the Clinton administration which stressed the central importance of economic globalisation in the post-Cold War world, Bush’s foreign- policy team seems far more interested in traditional power politics.
After taking power, for example, it considered reducing the post of US Trade Representative (USTR), who negotiates trade agreements, to sub- cabinet rank, and re-arranged the White House flow chart so that international economics staff would report to the president through National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice, a former Soviet specialist with virtually no background in economics or trade.
Rice, who gave a preview of Bush’s Summit at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace here last week, was panned by trade analysts who attended the address, which, in the words of one, was “short on specifics and long on platitudes”.
Of greater concern to the administration has been the failure so far of USTR Robert Zoellick to make any progress in forging a compromise between Republicans and Democrats on a “fast-track” or trade-promotion bill that would give Bush authority to negotiate the FTAA, as well as other trade agreements.
Without fast-track authority, trade agreements negotiated by the executive branch can be amended on the floor of Congress, which would then require re-opening negotiations. With such authority, however, Congress can only vote a trade package up or down, without subjecting it to amendment or normal procedural delays.
As the price for their support of fast-track authority, Congressional Democrats have insisted that all new trade agreements, such as the FTAA, include strong and enforceable labour rights and environmental protections, stronger than those included in side agreements to the 1994 North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) with Canada and Mexico.
The Congressional leadership in Bush’s Republican Party, on the other hand, strongly opposes any provisions which would make such protections enforceable through sanctions. It is Zoellick’s task to forge some kind of compromise which will satisfy enough lawmakers on both parties to rally substantial majorities in both houses behind new fast-track legislation.
But the fact that he has failed to do so – or, according to some insiders, to even seriously engage in a negotiating effort between the two sides – is worrisome to many who support the FTAA.
“There has to be some kind of compromise, particularly on the labour issues,” said Hakim, who added that he hopes that Bush will signal in his remarks in Quebec that he is sensitive to labour’s demands. “If he says anything about labour, that will be a good sign,” according to Hakim.
So far, however, Bush has disappointed. In a speech to the Organisation of Americans States (OAS) here Tuesday in which he outlined his Summit agenda, he never mentioned Democratic demands on the environment or worker rights, stating only that his administration was “now actively working with Congress on a strategy for passing legislation granting trade promotion authority.
“We will intensify this effort when I return from Quebec, and I am confident that we will succeed,” he added.
His only bow to critics was a promise to publish the current working draft of the FTAA to “allow our citizens to see what is being negotiated and give them a chance to provide their views on this important document”.
But others believe that, even if Bush intensifies his efforts, he must still overcome powerful forces over which he may have only limited influence, according to analysts here.
A downturn in the US economy, particularly if it persists, could well result in an upsurge in protectionist pressure not only in the United States but in some other FTAA countries, says John Cavanagh of the Institute for Policy Studies (IPS), an influential critic of economic globalisation.
Indeed, free markets and other neo-liberal economic principles on which the FTAA is based evoke much less enthusiasm in the region today than they did in 1994, primarily because they have not fulfilled hopes for lifting tens of millions out of poverty, says Hakim.
Many of the demonstrations in Quebec over the weekend will be led by trade unions, which are legitimately concerned that more free-trade agreements without strong worker rights’ protections will accelerate the “race for the bottom” as countries compete for corporate investment, according to Cavanagh,.
Another factor will be resistance, particularly from Brazil, to concluding a far-reaching accord without major trade and politically sensitive concessions by the United States itself.
Indeed, Brazil, which will hold key presidential elections next year, could by itself block a successful negotiation. “If Brazil and the U.S. can come together, you will get an FTAA by 2005,” according to Mack McLarty, Clinton’s special Latin America trade envoy.
One hedge against this is the administration’s desire to negotiate bilateral accords, starting with Chile whose president, Ricardo Lagos, met with Bush here Monday. “A bilateral agreement with Chile will add to the momentum (for an FTAA),” says McLarty.