Economy & Trade, Headlines, Human Rights, Labour, North America

LABOUR-US: Unions Turn to Immigrants to Revive Movement

David Bacon

OAKLAND, California, May 11 2001 (IPS) - US labour groups are beginning to embrace undocumented immigrant workers but the government and employers oppose their attempts to increase union membership.

“Most unions today are at least trying to organise,” says Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees Union President John Wilhelm. “And no matter the industry, they run into immigrant workers. Immigrants are everywhere.

“That’s what brought home the failure of the AFL-CIO’s old immigration policy,” Wilhelm adds, referring to the country’s largest labour federation, in which he chairs the immigration committee.

In the past, unions wrote off workers like Matilda and Patricia. The women came to the United States from Mexico and El Salvador, respectively, and ended up working at a San Francisco motel. Their last names have been withheld at their request.

The motel, which paid the room cleaners the minimum legal wage of 6.25 dollars per hour, never said much about the workers’ immigration status until the low wages inspired the women to join a union. Then, say union officials, the motel began a campaign of intimidation that culminated in the workers’ dismissal on the grounds that the Social Security Administration had notified management that the workers’ identification numbers did not match the government’s database.

As recently as 1986, the AFL-CIO supported the Immigration Reform and Control Act’s “employer sanctions” provision, which provided the pretext for the motel’s actions.

The law requires employers to keep records of workers’ immigration status, and imposes fines – which are low and rarely collected – on those who hire the undocumented. The real impact of the law is on the workers, making it illegal for them to hold a job. Employer sanctions were a hallmark of immigration enforcement under President Bill Clinton.

It has become common for companies to use the employer sanctions as a weapon to resist organising drives. Recognising this, the AFL- CIO passed last year an historic resolution calling for the repeal of sanctions and for a legalisation programme that would allow undocumented immigrants to normalise their status.

As a result, the political rules and alliances that have limited the possibility for immigration reform are changing, with labour adding its voice to calls to grant amnesty for the country’s undocumented immigrants, estimated at between nine million and 11 million.

Over the past year, the AFL-CIO, individual unions and community organisations around the country have organised hearings and marches in support of amnesty.

Immigrant workers have become important to unions. Over the past year, union membership has dropped from 13.5 percent of the labour force to 13.3 percent, and 9 percent in the private sector. To avoid further erosion, unions must organise 400,000 workers a year. To increase membership by one per cent, they must recruit twice that number. The AFL-CIO recently proposed unionising 1,000,000 new workers yearly, a rate not achieved since the 1940s.

In major cities like Los Angeles, the resurgence of union activism has rested on strikes and organising drives among immigrant janitors and hotel workers. Immigrant carpenters, garment workers, and truck drivers have staged pivotal strikes. Immigrant day labourers, domestic workers, and gardeners have built independent organisations, even without labour law protection and support from local unions.

“Every period of significant growth in the labour movement was fueled by organising activity among immigrant workers,” Wilhelm says. “We’re a labour movement of immigrants and we always have been.”

Employers, however, are pursuing a very different idea. With the avid support of key Congressional Republicans and the US administration, they are seeking new “bracero” contract labour programmes. These would transform workers like the room cleaners into even cheaper and more vulnerable guest workers.

Bracero schemes were in place from 1942 until 1964. While guaranteed labour rights on paper, guest workers depended on their jobs to remain in the country. Employers therefore had the power not only to fire workers who protested bad conditions but, in effect, to deport them as well. Many abuses were documented.

In January, Texas Senator Phil Gramm, one of the loudest anti- immigrant voices in Congress, flew to Mexico City to meet Mexican President Vicente Fox, a former Coca-Cola executive with close links to major Mexican and US corporations. On his return, Gramm announced that he and Fox had discussed a vast expansion of bracero programmes. Gramm also proposed increased enforcement of employer sanctions, to force them into the contract labour scheme.

Gramm’s visit was followed by that of President George W. Bush, who had cultivated a pro-Latino, pro-immigrant image during his election campaign for fear of the punishment that California’s Latino voters, enraged over anti-immigrant policies, imposed on the state’s Republican Party. Bush also fears crossing the right wing of his own party, to whom immigration is still anathema. His solution: supporting contract labour, touting it to Latinos as a chance to work legally while telling right-wingers that it affords no one the opportunity to stay. Bush’s position also aligns him with the agriculture and meatpacking industries, which want guest workers.

For his part, Fox needs to protect the huge economic role migrant labour plays in the Mexican economy. The remittances of Mexicans working in the US – estimated to be between 6 billion and 8 billion dollars a year – rank as the third largest source of foreign income after oil and tourism. Politically, Fox has to speak to the needs of millions of Mexicans who seek a way to cross the border without the harrowing journey through the desert, which claims hundreds of lives every year. He supports a general amnesty as well as contract labour, which can be portrayed as a means of providing the sought-after opportunity to work in the north.

There is another framework for dealing with these issues. In 1990, the United Nations General Assembly adopted an International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of Their Families. It extends basic human rights without distinction to all migrants and establishes the principle of “equality of treatment” with citizens of the host country in employment and education. All countries retain the right to determine who is admitted to their territories, and under what conditions people gain the right to work.

Countries that send immigrants favour the Convention but countries that receive them don’t. The United States has not ratified it.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags