Friday, November 20, 2026
Tim Shorrock
- The White House is pushing Congress to vote as early as next week on a bill granting President George W. Bush trade promotion authority (TPA). Democrats, however, are scrambling to provide an alternative that would add labour and environmental protections to the bill.
If they succeed in crafting a compromise, the final bill could make it impossible for many developing countries, particularly major economies like Brazil and India, to enter trade negotiations with the United States.
House of Representatives Republican leader Richard Armey of Texas has vowed to push for a vote on TPA next week. The Republican bill does not include any provisions on labour and the environment.
The White House campaign is scheduled to go into high gear Friday with a major address on trade by Bush. Nicholas Calio, the president’s chief lobbyist on Capitol Hill, and Gary Edson, his deputy national security adviser, will lead the effort to win legislative support. Commerce Secretary Donald Evans and U.S. Trade Representative Robert Zoellick will also play key roles.
Some members of Bush’s party, however, want to buy more time so they can negotiate a compromise with Democrats that is more likely to pass the full House. On Wednesday, Representative Bill Thomas, the chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee, said a delay is needed because he is “trying to attract 30 to 40 typically pro- trade Democrats” to vote for TPA.
To pass, TPA will need support in both the House of Representatives and the Senate.
The Democrats appear to be badly divided, particularly on the controversial issue of allowing the United States to impose sanctions on countries that violate international standards on worker rights and the environment.
Senator Max Baucus, the Democratic chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, unveiled his long-awaited TPA proposals Wednesday.
For developing countries opposed to linkage between trade and human rights, the most controversial part of the Baucus package is a provision that would require the United States to demand that trading partners do not “derogate from current domestic labour rights laws for purposes of stimulating exports or investment” and that would make a country’s failure to meet that requirement “subject to dispute settlement.”
In a speech on the floor of the Senate, Baucus sent a strong message to developing countries, particularly Brazil, that Congress is impatient with threats to walk away from negotiations for a Free Trade Area of the Americas if the TPA legislation includes his suggested language.
“For countries like Brazil who suggest that they will not negotiate with us unless we weaken our trade laws, I say this: we will move forward without you,” said Baucus. “Almost every country in the world, and certainly many in South America, are eager to negotiate free trade agreements with the United States. We do not need Brazil’s approval to enforce US trade laws.”
Baucus, however, did not directly call for sanctions for countries violating labour standards. Instead, he proposed to give the president the option to choose other remedies, including fines and penalties. That approach was soundly rejected by pro-labour Democrats and lobbyists for trade unions opposed to TPA, previously known as ‘fast track’.
“This is a non-starter; it’s laughable,” said Segundo Mercado- Llorens, who is lobbying against TPA for several labour and environmental groups. He said labour unions would not agree to any language on worker rights “until the enforcement tools available to corporations on intellectual property, including sanctions,” are available for workers.
At a press conference on Wednesday, Representative David Bonior, one of the unions’ strongest allies in Congress, said that Baucus’s proposals lacked the “hammer and chisel you need” to enforce internationally recognised workers rights. Sander Levin, a fellow Democrat, is working on what he calls “enforceable” labour and environmental provisions.
The debate on negotiating authority will follow several critical votes on trade this week that could point the way for a compromise on TPA.
The House voted Tuesday, by a lopsided margin of 259-169, to support President Bush’s request to retain normal trade relations with China, following the completion in June of Beijing’s US negotiations to join the World Trade Organization. Unions and environmental groups that unsuccessfully opposed the act last year apparently decided that the tide was against them this time and, instead, plan to put their efforts into defeating fast track.
On Thursday, by an even greater margin, the House approved another Bush administration request to grant Vietnam a one-year waiver on continuing commercial trade with the United States. This allows Vietnam to continue receiving credits from the US Export-Import Bank and the Agriculture Department. In addition, the House Ways and Means Committee approved normal trade relations with Vietnam. This will remain subject to annual review until Vietnam joins the WTO.
Perhaps most significantly for the future of trade negotiating authority, the committee endorsed Thursday a US free trade agreement with Jordan that includes strong labour and environmental provisions backed by sanctions. The Senate Finance Committee also has approved the agreement, drawn up during the closing days of the Bill Clinton administration. If the full House and Senate pass it, Jordan will become only the fourth country – after Canada, Mexico and Israel – to have a US free trade agreement.
The US labour umbrella group AFL-CIO has strongly endorsed the Jordan agreement as an example of the kind of trade legislation its member unions could support. But some Republicans just as adamantly opposed those provisions.
The measure cleared the Senate committee when Republican Senator Charles Grassley, who is working with Baucus on compromise language for fast track, said he would support the bill. He was persuaded after Jordan and the Bush administration signed letters stating that neither side would use the agreement’s dispute settlement procedures to block trade.
While that has apparently satisfied Republicans opposed to a social clause in trade agreements, it has infuriated organised labour.
“These side letters completely eviscerate the possibility of using sanctions,” said Mercado-Llorens. “The Republican actions on the Jordan agreement are not much encouragement to those who believe there is a possibility of bridging the gap between the progressive Democratic Party view and mainstream Republican views on trade and sanctions.”
Meanwhile, in another debate being closely watched for its trade implications, the Senate prepared Thursday to add an amendment to a 60 billion dollar transportation bill requiring strict safety standards before Mexican trucks are allowed on US roads under the North American Free Trade Agreement. President Bush strongly opposes the measure and has threatened to veto any bill that includes it.
But on Wednesday, the die was cast when the Senate rejected, by a vote of 65-35, an amendment from Republican Senators Phil Gramm and John McCain that said the United States would not “discriminate against Mexico” by imposing higher standards for trucks.
Afterwards, Trent Lott, the Republican Senate minority leader, said that the dispute over Mexican trucking was evidence that the Bush administration’s push for fast track was in trouble. “The Democrats are getting in a position of not supporting free trade and reacting to labour demands and that appears to be a problem with trade promotion authority,” he said.