Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Education, Headlines

PAKISTAN: Doubts Greet Law to ‘Modernise’ Religious Schooling

Nadeem Iqbal

ISLAMABAD, Aug 29 2001 (IPS) - Ten-year-old Shahid Iqbal wants to become an ‘alim’ (priest), believing that it is not only a good profession but would also allow him to serve God and humanity.

“After completing my senior level of Islamic education I qualify to be appointed head of a mosque anywhere in the world,” said Shahid, one of 400 students undergoing orthodox religious teachings in one of the ‘madrasah’ (religious schools) in Pakistan’s capital.

The traditional duties of an ‘alim’ includes leading five times of prayer a day and delivering lectures to Friday congregations, besides administering marriage contracts and performing rituals at births and burials.

Muhammad Naveed, an eight-year-old student, says that in two levels of studies, they are taught how to read the holy Koran and interpret it in order to find religious solutions to everyday problems.

But now Muhammad Naveed may also have to study some secular topics — such as the social sciences and English — under a new law promulgated by the military-led government this month, which provides for the integration of the system of Islamic schooling with the general education system.

The law aims to give children full-fledged, comprehensive and specialised Islamic schooling along with general education subjects. It will require the registration, regulation, standardisation and uniformity of curricula and standard of education of ‘madrasah’ in Pakistan.

The government of President Pervez Musharraf put this law in place in the face of a growing perception in the west that ‘militant Islam’ is the new, post-communist, global menace facing the world.

‘Madrasah’ are often increasingly seen as breeding grounds for the foot soldiers of this brand of Islam and as places that exist merely to motivate and train the next generation of young Muslims to wage ‘jihad’ (holy war) — be it in Indian-controlled Kashmir or Bosnia, Chechnya and other places.

By this reform in education, the military-led government wants to promote Pakistan’s image as an enlightened, progressive and modern Muslim state, where obscurantists’ policies do not get dominance.

The new law will affect some 15,000 religious schools in the country, from which 40,000 students graduate every year. Officials estimate that their joint budget is some 40 million U.S. dollars — more than the annual budget of Pakistan’s 28 universities.

These seminaries receive funding from Muslim countries and individual Muslim philanthropists.

So long as ‘madrasah’ confined their activities to traditionally imparting purely religious learning, they remained ‘harmless’, analysts say.

But a turning point came in the 1970s, when some religious parties went into political activism and ‘madrasah’ were asked to provide volunteers for rallies and other party work.

With the former Soviet Union’s invasion of Afghanistan in 1979, the ‘madrasah’ that were controlled by some religious parties started sending volunteers for ‘jihad’ in Afghanistan. Thus, many ‘madrasah’ became centres of military training, indoctrination and recruitment.

But local observers say in hindsight that it is not only Pakistan that was responsible for this occurence — and that this politicisation was not a purely religious issue at all.

As a recent editorial of the leading English-daily ‘Dawn’ said: “The outside power that contributed most to the militarisation of many ‘madrasah’ was the United States.”

“In its frenzied drive to turn Afghanistan into a Soviet Vietnam, Washington funneled enormous funds and overt and convert military aid for the war of resistance in Soviet-occupied Afghanistan,” it added.

“Many of ‘madrasah’ boys then turned into full-blooded ‘mujahideen’ (militants) and remained in possession of their weapons and in a ‘jihadi’ mood even long after the Soviet Union had pulled out of Afghanistan (1988),” the paper recalled.

Another phenomenon that struck Pakistan during the same period was the rise of sectarian terrorism. These seminaries also trained sectarian militants and allowed free field for dominantly Shiite Iran and Sunni Saudi Arabia to fought a proxy war on Pakistani soil. Thousands were killed in these clashes.

The other week, the Musharraf government banned two militant sectarian outfits besides banning the collection of funds for ‘jihad’ and bringing foreign funding under strict official scrutiny.

But these moves drew severe resistance from religious parties.

In an interview, local religious leader Qari Saeedur Rehman said that under “pressure from western countries”, the government imposed curbs on religious institutions despite that fact that they were not getting funding from the government and were autonomous.

If government wants to reform the current system, it must introduce Islamic teachings in government-funded secular schools, he argued.

Sahibzada Usman Ghani, district administrator of Jamat Ahle Sunnat, urged the government not to disturb the system as these ‘madrasah’ had in fact helped spread Islam in the world.

According to the conservative English newspaper ‘The Nation’, the resistance from religious leaders “is probably based on the assumption that the introduction of modern scientific disciplines in the curricula is an insidious attempt to spread secularist ideas and popularise western culture”.

“Besides, they feel it would dilute the focus on the theological studies, which is the primary objective of these institutions. Removing that misunderstanding should be the government’s policy,” it pointed out.

At present, Pakistan has three parallel systems of education.

There are elite English-medium schools, which are often affiliated with the British system. In the second tier there are the middle-class government schools where the medium of instruction is the national Urdu language and where a nominal fee is charged.

The religious schools are the third type, which are mainly run on public and private donations and where education, including lodging, is given to poorer students free of charge.

If the government plan succeeds under the new law, then the religious schools would be integrated into second tier.

But the government schools’ performance is not up to mark, not least because only 2.6 percent of the country’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is allocated for education. Although the government claims that Pakistan’s literacy rate is 49 percent, independent sources say it is not higher than 23 percent in reality.

Amid this backdrop, many wonder where the government would get the funds to bring the autonomous religious schools into the mainstream education system.

Some officials say some funds would come from the United States, since in December last year U.S. legislation removed sanctions on Pakistan in the field of basic education.

Sanctions have been imposed on Pakistan since May 1998, when Pakistan detonated nuclear weapons in a tit-for-tat exchange with rival India, and after the October 1999 military coup that saw Musharraf taking power.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags